Can the UK avoid 50,000 Covid-19 cases a day?

Continued doubling of infection rate feared by top advisers is unlikely to happen, say some experts

On one thing, everyone agrees: the UK is at a turning point.

After a summer of crowded beaches and pubs reopening, followed by children returning to school and employees going back to the workplace, new cases of Covid-19 are definitely on the rise.

In the starkest scenario, laid out by the government scientific and medical advisers Patrick Vallance and Chris Whitty on Monday, the UK could be headed for almost 50,000 cases a day in less than a month, leading to more than 200 deaths a day by mid-November.

Their calculation is a simple one: there were 3,105 new cases on 15 September. If cases were to rise exponentially – leading to four “doublings” between now and mid-October – there would be 49,680 new cases on 13 October. This would put the UK among the worst countries in the world – alongside India, the US and Brazil – for reports of new cases of the virus.

A version of a slide from this morning's briefing by chief medical officer for England Chris Whitty which shows that, were a doubling of cases to occur every seven days, there would be 50,000 cases by 13 October

But can we trust these figures – are 50,000 cases a day plausible?

This is hotly contested.

One of the biggest challenges in assessing the prevalence of the virus is testing. As was the case during the first wave, without a comprehensive and timely testing regime we have no clear way of knowing how many new cases there are.

While a range of possible interventions means it isn’t inevitable the UK will see 50,000 cases by mid-October, there are a number of indications that things are heading the wrong way.

Hospital admissions are now doubling every eight to nine days. And even though we are starting at a low base (there were 205 new Covid admissions on Friday in England compared with 3,099 new patients admitted in just one day at the peak on 1 April) this is data with an inevitable outcome: more hospital admissions lead to more deaths.

Hospital admissions for Covid-19 in England have been doubling roughly every eight days since the start of September

We can also learn from what is happening elsewhere. In Spain and France an increase in cases has led to a rise in deaths. Spain’s seven-day average case rate is currently 26 per 100,000, while in France the figure is 15 per 100,000, both higher than the UK, where the seven-day average is five per 100,000.

In Spain and France a rise in cases has led to an increase in hospital admissions and deaths.

We also know from the first wave that cases can rise quickly, take time to fall and, even with sweeping interventions, stemming the spread of the virus takes time.

When the lockdown was introduced on 23 March there were 967 cases and 206 deaths in the UK. However, the increase in new cases continued until mid-April, when the seven-day average peaked at 5,195, and given limited testing capacity at the time that figure could have been far higher.

Ten days later the daily death toll hit 1,000, marking the start of a 22-day run of more than a thousand deaths per day.

However some experts think it is unlikely that the UK will reach the 50,000 figure. Dr Daniel Lawson, senior lecturer in statistical science in the school of mathematics at the University of Bristol, said the simple extrapolation from the current reproductive rate of Covid-19 was not likely to be accurate over a timescale of weeks.

“The number is plausible if the UK as a whole does not respond to the outbreak, but an increase in compliance and risk avoidance will make it unlikely to come about as predicted. Additional local or national interventions will also reduce the infections.

“In other words, the scenario is unlikely to come about – but we do need to pay attention to it anyway, because the public do need to take action to lower the infection rate and only some of this is achieved by policy; the rest is done by us. If we ignore this scenario, it could yet come about, or worse restrictions put in place instead.”

The latest seven-day average shows there were 3,679 new cases a day in the UK. One in five people – almost 14 million – in the UK currently face some restrictions or will from 22 September. What we choose to do in the coming days and weeks will have an amplified impact in the months ahead.

Contributors

Caelainn Barr, Pamela Duncan and Niamh McIntyre

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK could have 50,000 Covid cases a day by mid-October, say scientific advisers
Country told it is on course for 200 deaths a day and to prepare for six months of restrictions

Jessica Elgot and Simon Murphy

21, Sep, 2020 @1:57 PM

Article image
Secrecy has harmed UK government's response to Covid-19 crisis, says top scientist
Exclusive: Sir Paul Nurse says lack of openness fuelled poor decisions and put public trust at risk

Ian Sample Science editor

02, Aug, 2020 @8:11 PM

Article image
UK at 'critical point' over Covid-19, top scientists to tell public
Patrick Vallance and Chris Whitty to make televised appeal ahead of ‘challenging winter’

Heather Stewart and Josh Halliday

20, Sep, 2020 @9:00 PM

Article image
Government must be transparent about science advice it receives
Analysis: inquiry into UK’s response to Covid crisis shows Sage guidance should be put in public domain as soon as possible

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

12, Oct, 2021 @6:14 PM

Article image
UK Covid news: Nicola Sturgeon eases some restrictions on outdoor mixing in Scotland – as it happened
Scottish first minister announces limited changes to mixing, in particular for teenagers

Andrew Sparrow

09, Mar, 2021 @4:56 PM

Article image
'The seasons are against us': what we learned from UK's top Covid scientists
Patrick Vallance and Chris Whitty’s briefing predicted an autumn of rising deaths and difficult lockdown choices

Peter Walker Political correspondent

21, Sep, 2020 @2:00 PM

Article image
No 10 says scientific advisers will return to Covid-19 briefings
Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance have been regulars at Downing Street daily updates

Heather Stewart

27, May, 2020 @3:01 PM

Article image
Chris Whitty: keeping Covid restrictions will only delay wave
England’s chief medical officer says hospitalisations will not be reduced by keeping rules this summer

Ian Sample and Natalie Grover

05, Jul, 2021 @6:58 PM

Article image
Attendees of Sage meetings worried by presence of Cummings
Scientists on UK government’s coronavirus advisory group say Dominic Cummings was an active participant

Felicity Lawrence, Severin Carrell , David Pegg

26, Apr, 2020 @12:00 PM

Article image
10% of England's population could be tested for Covid-19 every week
Exclusive: NHS test and trace asks public health directors to sign up to rapid saliva testing plan

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

28, Oct, 2020 @7:09 PM