EU seeks Amazon protections pledge from Bolsonaro in push to ratify trade deal

Brazilian president’s stance on deforestation remains stumbling block for South America agreement

Brussels is in talks with Brazil’s far-right nationalist president, Jair Bolsonaro, over commitments on the future of the Amazon as it seeks to persuade Emmanuel Macron and other EU leaders and parliaments to ratify the trade deal the bloc has negotiated with South America.

The ratification of the draft trade agreement between the EU and the “Mercosur” or Southern Common Market free-trade zone – which spans Brazil, Uruguay, Paraguay and Argentina – has been in doubt almost since it was announced last June.

France, Ireland and Austria have said they will block parliamentary ratification unless Bolsonaro agrees to do more to tackle Amazonian deforestation and record numbers of fires. The Brazilian president has repeatedly scorned international appeals over the protection of the Amazon and championed his country’s right to exploit its natural resources.

The European commissioner for trade, Valdis Dombrovskis, in an interview to mark his first week in the job since replacing the Irish politician Phil Hogan, said he recognised that ratification of the Mercosur trade deal, secured after 20 years of haggling, was now unlikely.

But Dombrovskis, a former prime minister of Latvia, said the deal, which slashes import taxes on a huge range of goods, was one worth fighting for and that the commission was seeking hard pledges from Bolsonaro in pursuit of its ratification.

He said: “We know that [there are] a number of concerns, especially concerning deforestation in the Amazon and adherence of Mercosur countries to the Paris agreement [on the climate emergency] and this is something we need to enforce because on the [European] commission side we share these concerns.

“So we are currently engaging with the Mercosur authorities, I would say, especially with Brazil. Well, informally, currently, to see what kind of meaningful commitments, Mercosur countries can take in order to ensure a successful ratification of this agreement.

“I think it’s clear … that if we would not do anything now, just follow things through procedurally and put this agreement to ratification, there are chances that it will not be ratified, and that would be a regrettable outcome. Therefore we need to see what kind of preconditions or pre-commitments that can be from the Mercosur side to ensure successful ratification of the agreement.”

In a statement issued last month, the French government said it had “major concerns” about the deforestation of the Amazon and a rise in production of beef in the region, one of the Brazilian products for which the Mercosur trade deal would offer greater EU market access.

“The draft agreement has no provision to impose discipline on the practices of the Mercosur countries in the fight against deforestation,” the French government said in a statement. “This is the major shortcoming in this agreement and this is the main reason why, as it stands, France opposes the draft agreement.”

Emmanuel Macron sits with Jair Bolsonaro (back L) at the G20 Summit in Osaka in 2019.
Emmanuel Macron sits with Jair Bolsonaro (back L) at the G20 Summit in Osaka in 2019. Photograph: Dominique Jacovides/AFP via Getty Images

Macron has also personally clashed with Bolsonaro, a climate change sceptic, describing him as “extraordinarily rude” after the Brazilian leader personally expressed approval for a Facebook post implying that the French president’s wife, Brigitte Macron, was not as attractive as his own wife, Michelle.

But Dombrovskis said that despite the obstacles, the trade deal negotiated with the Mercosur countries actually offered the EU leverage in changing damaging behaviour.

“If we were just to walk away from this deal after negotiating for 20 years … then what kind of credibility, what kind of leverage, would we have to engage with Brazil or other Mercosur authorities on those topics? The very fact that we negotiated a deal allows us to engage in a more meaningful manner.”


Daniel Boffey in Brussels

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
G7 leaders to hold emergency talks over Amazon wildfires crisis
Brazil’s handling of fires to top agenda in Biarritz as France and Ireland threaten to block trade deal

Julian Borger in Biarritz, Jonathan Watts, and Tom Phillips in Mexico City

24, Aug, 2019 @1:15 AM

Article image
Jair Bolsonaro demands Macron withdraw 'insults' over Amazon fires
Brazilian and French presidents continue feud over G7 aid package for wildfires raging in Amazon rainforest

Tom Phillips Latin America correspondent

27, Aug, 2019 @5:47 PM

Article image
G7 cash for Amazon fires is ‘chump change’, say campaigners
World leaders offer $20m now plus reforestation plan, but critics want major policy shifts

Jonathan Watts, Julian Borger and Angelique Chrisafis

26, Aug, 2019 @6:05 PM

Article image
Jair Bolsonaro says 'deceitful' media hyping Amazon wildfires
In a combative UN address Bolsonaro denied – contrary to the evidence – that the world’s largest rainforest was being devastated

Tom Phillips Latin America correspondent

24, Sep, 2019 @4:59 PM

Article image
Bolsonaro government thanked Johnson for Amazon fire support
UK prime minister’s refusal to criticise sharp rise in deforestation and Amazon fires praised by Brazilian ambassador

Alexandra Heal and Andrew Wasley

30, Mar, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Observer view on Jair Bolsonaro and the Amazon wildfires | Observer editorial
The ecological carnage we are witnessing will reverberate far beyond the borders of Brazil

Observer editorial

25, Aug, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Deforestation of Brazilian Amazon surges to record high
Environmentalists fear 2019 will be one of worst years for deforestation in recent memory

Jonathan Watts

04, Jun, 2019 @4:14 PM

Article image
Brazil space institute director sacked in Amazon deforestation row
Far-right leader Jair Bolsonaro calls satellite data showing rise in deforestation ‘lies’

Dom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

02, Aug, 2019 @6:11 PM

Article image
Amazon facing ‘urgent’ crime crisis after gutting of protections, says drugs tsar
Brazilian government warning comes as UN report says that flourishing organized crime groups are driving a boom in environmental devastation

Tom Phillips and Ana Ionova in Belém

28, Jun, 2023 @9:30 AM

Article image
Jair Bolsonaro claims NGOs behind Amazon forest fire surge – but provides no evidence
Brazilian president claims green groups behind blazes, which have increased 84% over same period last year

Jonathan Watts

21, Aug, 2019 @5:11 PM