What next for New Zealand's National party and its embattled leader?

New Zealand overwhelmingly embraced Jacinda Ardern’s Labour, leaving Judith Collins’ party in the wilderness

Judith Collins had a spring in her step and a high-beam smile when she appeared for reporters the day after a New Zealand election that delivered a landslide victory to her opponent, Jacinda Ardern of Labour – the country’s most popular leader of modern times.

“I’m feeling really good,” she said. “Woke up today, the sun was shining.”

It was almost as though she had not just presided over a crushing defeat of her National party, which commentators labelled a bloodbath and that culminated in an election night event that was bleak and funereal in tone.

National, which had painted itself as the stable, experienced choice for its nine years in government before Ardern’s ascension in 2017, has plummeted from 56 to 35 seats in the 120-seat Parliament.

Now Collins – a veteran but polarising lawmaker who often set herself up as the opposite to Ardern’s exhortations to kindness – joins the ranks of two predecessors this year who failed to make headway against the prime minister’s popular Covid-19 response. And while she has been eager to blame the unprecedented circumstances for much of her defeat, analysts said National had also failed to address factors well within its control.

David Farrar, the principal of Curia Market Research, who conducts polls for National and will address its caucus at its next meeting on Tuesday, said: “They had seven leaders and deputy leaders in one term of government, various MPs causing trouble, and three years of on-and-off leaks.

“It does short-term damage, but after a while it also corrodes the brand.”

New Zealand voters generally cast their ballots cautiously, preferring fairly evenly matched governments with minor parties providing checks on the major parties’ powers.

In Saturday’s election, they dispensed with that, delivering Ardern, at current counting, 64 seats out of 120. Her victory is not only a ringing endorsement of her leadership during the Covid-19 pandemic, but a stinging rejection of Collins’s National – which struggled to make headway in attacks on Ardern’s border control competence during the pandemic, and struggled with mess and dysfunction within its caucus.

National has at times been dismissive of Ardern’s global popularity, pointing instead at what they called her failures to deliver at home. And at one point it appeared to be working: in October 2019, a Newshub Reid research poll had National slightly leading Labour.

By Saturday, that had more than reversed.

“That suggests voters proactively choosing Ardern,” said Ben Thomas, a public relations consultant and former National government staffer. “Which has to be a reflection of the bond she formed with the electorate during Covid.”

Now, National will watch keenly to see whether Ardern – given a sweeping mandate to do as she likes, and with no minor parties as handbrakes on her agenda unless she chooses to work with them – will deliver on her promises.

“I hope our country does a lot better than the current government’s fiscal settings will enable them to do,” Collins said on Sunday, referring to her pitch that she would lead a stronger economic recovery from Covid-19. “I feel very concerned for my country.”

Her party’s slogan had been: “Strong Team, More Jobs, Better Economy.” But to add insult to injury, the head of Labour’s polling firm, Stephen Mills from UMR, said Ardern’s party had outperformed National on each metric of surveys conducted by his company..

When asked whether she expected to be the party’s leader at the next election, in 2023, Collins said on Sunday: “I expect so.”

But it is her 34 colleagues who will make that call, beginning at Tuesday’s caucus.

One National lawmaker told the Guardian that National’s woes could be traced back to the vote that rolled the former leader Simon Bridges in May. At the time Bridges was, personally, wildly unpopular, but things went from bad to worse for the party after his ousting. Some now believe he should have been retained.

His successor, Todd Muller, led the party for just over 50 days then quit abruptly, citing his mental health.

Bridges has become a cult favourite online due to the freewheeling social media presence he has adopted since leaving the role. But he told interviewers following Saturday’s vote that he was “not interested” in resuming the leadership.

Only two other contenders have been widely mentioned. One is Mark Mitchell – a former police officer and private security contractor in Iraq – who has been an MP since 2011 but is not widely known.

He told TVNZ on Sunday that he would not challenge Collins’s leadership. “Absolutely not, it’s not on the table. It’s the furthest thing from my mind,” he said.

The other rumoured contender is Christopher Luxon – an evangelical Christian and former chief executive of the national carrier Air New Zealand – who won the Auckland seat of Botany on Saturday night.

But Luxon will be entering parliament for the first time and has no political experience. He has not spoken definitively on a leadership challenge.

Few have come out in support of Collins. Paul Goldsmith, the party’s only senior MP to attend the grim election night event in Auckland, told the Guardian when asked if Collins would continue: “Look, we’ll take stock over the next couple of weeks.”

Farrar, the National pollster, said the public would “not be interested in anything National had to say before Christmas”, and the party should use that time to “take a breath” and reflect quietly.

“I don’t think the public wants much of a focus on politics at the moment,” he said. “Everyone’s still focused on Covid, and people didn’t want an election.”


Charlotte Graham-McLay in Auckland

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Can New Zealand's National party reinvent itself under Todd Muller? | Jennifer Curtin
The new opposition leader must win back centrist voters, just four months out from the election

Jennifer Curtin

23, May, 2020 @1:38 AM

Article image
Judith Collins named New Zealand National party's new leader
Tough-talking conservative politician will take on Jacinda Ardern at polls in September

Charlotte Graham-McLay in Wellington

14, Jul, 2020 @11:44 AM

Article image
Jacinda Ardern pushes stability over change in New Zealand's 'Covid election'
The prime minister is pitching a mix of steady leadership and big-spending policies to voters after a world-leading coronavirus response

Phil Taylor in Grey Lynn, Auckland

09, Aug, 2020 @7:36 AM

Article image
Judith Collins: New Zealand's 'anti-Ardern' whose hero is Thatcher
The New Zealand opposition leader has pulled no punches after being thrust into the role just a few months before the election

Charlotte Graham-McLay in Wellington

14, Oct, 2020 @4:25 AM

Article image
Laptops stolen in burglary at New Zealand's National party headquarters
Thieves broke in to the office in Auckland on Sunday night or Monday morning

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

20, Jan, 2020 @1:27 AM

Article image
Resolutions but no revolution as National ends its annual conference as divided as ever
There was a degree of heat, but not much light cast on the future of a party still recovering from last year’s election thumping

Liam Hehir

08, Aug, 2021 @6:49 AM

Article image
New Zealand's opposition leader Simon Bridges dumped after crash in popularity
Todd Muller takes top job in National party ahead of September’s election against popular Jacinda Ardern

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin and Charlotte Graham-McLay in Wellington

22, May, 2020 @1:52 AM

Article image
The winner of the third NZ election leaders' debate? Death
Jacinda Ardern and Judith Collins both bring B-game to seemingly interminable show

Steve Braunias

06, Oct, 2020 @12:40 PM

Article image
Why New Zealand rejected populist ideas other nations have embraced
Labour’s historic win delivered Ardern a second term while voters punished politicians who embraced populism

Charlotte Graham-McLay in Wellington

19, Oct, 2020 @2:13 AM

Article image
Jacinda Ardern to govern New Zealand for second term after historic victory
New Zealanders give Labour more votes than at any other election in past five decades

Eleanor Ainge Roy and Charlotte Graham-McLay in Auckland

17, Oct, 2020 @3:26 PM