UK archbishops urge ministers not to breach international law over Brexit

Leaders of Anglican church say internal market bill risks being a ‘disastrous precedent’

The Anglican church has publicly challenged the government’s willingness to break international law over Brexit, with five archbishops from Great Britain and Ireland joining together to condemn what could be a “disastrous precedent”.

In a rare step, the archbishops of Canterbury and York, plus their counterparts in Scotland, Wales and Ireland, have written a joint letter warning that such a step would have “enormous moral, as well as political and legal, consequences”.

If the internal market bill, due to be debated by peers on Monday, became law, it would “profoundly affect” the relationship between the four nations of the United Kingdom, the archbishops said.

They added: “We believe this would create a disastrous precedent. It is particularly disturbing for all of us who feel a sense of duty and responsibility to the Good Friday (Belfast) Agreement – that international treaty on which peace and stability within and between the UK and Ireland depends …”

The archbishops said that the UK government was preparing to breach the Northern Ireland protocol, which had been agreed to facilitate the UK’s departure from the EU.

The letter said: “If carefully negotiated terms are not honoured and laws can be ‘legally’ broken, on what foundations does our democracy stand?”

The letter, published in the Financial Times, came after the Northern Ireland secretary, Brandon Lewis, told MPs last month that the proposal would allow the government to break international law in a “limited and specific way”.

It caused a furore, with Conservative pro-Brexit peer Michael Howard demanding to know how the UK could criticise Russia, China and Iran for their conduct when it was prepared to flout international law.

The letter is signed by Justin Welby, archbishop of Canterbury; Stephen Cottrell, archbishop of York; Mark Strange, primus of the Scottish Episcopal church; John Davies, archbishop of Wales; and John McDowell, archbishop of Armagh.

They were “taking the rare step of writing together because the decisions implemented in this bill will profoundly affect the future of our countries and the relationships between them”, their letter said.

It would result in an “entirely novel system, replacing one that evolved slowly and by careful negotiation over decades”.

The archbishops urged legislators “to consider this bill in the light of values and principles we would wish to characterise relationships across these islands long after the transition period”.

Responding to the archbishops’ move, Steve Baker, a former Brexit minister, told the Mail he was “extremely disappointed that the archbishops are sowing disunity and division at a time when they could instead build up much-needed harmony in our nation”.

Another former Brexit minister, David Jones, said their comments went “way beyond the remit of the church. It is a straightforward question of constitutional propriety. Once again, the archbishops seem to have swallowed every scrap of remain propaganda unquestioningly and are now regurgitating it.”

Welby voted remain in the 2016 referendum but urged the result of the poll to be respected. Cottrell, who was enthroned as archbishop of York on Sunday, said in the lead-up to the referendum that “a vision for Europe and the world which emphasises our belonging to and our responsibility for each other” was needed.

• This article was amended on 19 October 2020 to reflect the fact that while the archbishop of Armagh is based in Northern Ireland, he is the Anglican primate of all Ireland.


Harriet Sherwood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Archbishop of Canterbury suggests Brexit 'in fascist tradition'
Justin Welby groups Brexit with election of Donald Trump and rise of Marine Le Pen and Geert Wilders

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

13, Feb, 2017 @7:31 PM

Article image
Justin Welby: no-deal Brexit would harm poorest people in UK
Archbishop of Canterbury says he prays every day for Theresa May and other politicians

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

14, Jan, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
No 10 goes into battle with archbishops over Rwanda asylum plan
Downing Street refuses to deny PM told MPs archbishops were being unfairly critical as church figures defend Justin Welby

Peter Walker, Geneva Abdul and Tobi Thomas

20, Apr, 2022 @6:16 PM

Article image
Church of England issues EU referendum prayer
Nine-line prayer appeals for ‘grace to debate the issues in this referendum with honesty and openness’

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

26, Apr, 2016 @4:17 PM

Article image
UK accused of 'magical thinking' over Brexit plan for Irish border
Britain’s call for ‘flexible solutions’ as it pursues goal of avoiding border posts with Ireland leaves EU officials rolling their eyes

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

25, Aug, 2017 @6:03 PM

Article image
Archbishop of Canterbury says he may chair Brexit citizens’ forum
Justin Welby sets out conditions for accepting role despite outrage among Eurosceptics

Matthew Weaver

27, Aug, 2019 @4:48 PM

Article image
Northern Irish unionists fear post-Brexit land grabs
Report identifies Zimbabwe-style seizures as key concern in the event of a united Ireland

Rory Carroll and Lisa O'Carroll

18, Jul, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Europe could allow a united Ireland to join EU after Brexit
Leaders expected to discuss statement at weekend summit that if the island reunifies, the north will automatically regain EU membership

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

28, Apr, 2017 @9:04 AM

Article image
Peter Hain: hard Brexit puts Northern Ireland peace process at risk
Former minister introduces amendment to article 50 bill in Lords, saying government must ‘support maintenance of open border’

Peter Walker Political correspondent

27, Feb, 2017 @6:36 PM

Article image
Northern Ireland must not be 'collateral damage' of Brexit, report says
First of six Lords reports on effect of Brexit on Britain, highlighting potential impact on UK-Irish relations

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

12, Dec, 2016 @12:01 AM