Mayors across the north of England have rejected the government’s financial package for areas in local lockdown, warning it would cause long-term economic devastation.

Mayors from Greater Manchester and the North of Tyne, Sheffield city and Liverpool city combined authorities are calling on northern MPs to mount a parliamentary challenge against the new lockdown measures, which are expected to be unveiled on Monday.

Speaking in a joint press conference with other northern leaders on Saturday afternoon, the Greater Manchester mayor, Andy Burnham, said he would consider legal action should such a challenge fail.

Steve Rotheram, the mayor of the Liverpool metropolitan region, said he had been told by the government it would announce a tier-three lockdown for Liverpool on Monday, to come into force on Wednesday. The area currently has about 540 cases per 100,000 people.

Other mayors were unclear about which tier they would be placed under.

The mayors criticised the government’s handling of the coronavirus pandemic, expressing their support for the accusation by the Labour leader, Keir Starmer, that Boris Johnson had presided over “serial incompetence”.

“There’s no perfect response and I don’t envy the government,” said Burnham. “But things being briefed to newspapers or issued late at night without explanation or detail … That is incompetence in my view, and it’s serial because it keeps happening.”

The metro mayor of the North of Tyne combined authority, Jamie Driscoll, cited the failings of the test-and-trace system as evidence of the government’s incompetence, saying: “Getting this virus under control depends upon an effective test-and-trace system and it’s not even close [to that], never mind world-beating.”

Under current plans, those who cannot work due to the local lockdown measures will be offered two-thirds of their salary, rather than the 80% offered under the original national furlough scheme.

The government will also increase the support grants for businesses under local lockdowns from up to £1,500 every three weeks to up to £3,000 per month, but Burnham warned that this “would not be enough to save businesses who are on a knife-edge”.

The local leaders have written to MPs of northern constituencies to ask them to bring about a separate vote and debate on this financial package in parliament. They hope the package will be rejected and replaced with more expansive support measures.

Rotheram called for the 80% of pay offered in the original scheme to be restored. “If 80% was the right benchmark in March, nothing has changed. If it’s right then, it’s right now,” he said.

Burnham echoed that call, saying: “You can’t choose to pay two-thirds of rent or bills.”

Burnham said to accept the measures would be to “render our businesses to failure and collapse”, and would lead to a rise in redundancy and damage prospects for long-term recovery.

“It will level down and worsen the north-south divide,” he said.

Burnham also called for better support for self-employed people, greater evidence to be presented to those living under local lockdowns about why the measures were in place and stronger enforcement powers.

Driscoll agreed. “You have to make obeying the restrictions financially viable for people,” he said, warning the country was facing the hardest winter for the NHS on record. “The financial support is part of keeping people safe.”

He said the local leaders felt like “passengers” rather than “partners” of the government.

Dan Jarvis, the Labour MP and Sheffield city region combined authority mayor, described the government response as a “top-down, overly centralised approach that has not been as effective as it could have been”.

He said “frustrations bubbled over this week” when local leaders found out about the new measures through newspaper reports, rather than policy consultations. “We are part of the solution and need to be involved at an early point in the government decision-making process,” he said.

The leaders also implied that the government had handled the lockdowns differently because the regions were situated in the north.

Discussing what he considered to be the failures of the new measures, Burnham said that during national lockdowns, the government took a “whatever it takes” approach, but with the north, the attitude had been “what we are prepared to spend”.

“And it’s actually about treating parts of the country as second-class,” he added.

A government spokesperson said that all financial support would be kept under review, to support businesses and protect jobs.

They added: “Throughout the pandemic, we have worked hard to protect jobs and support the economy, whilst trying to limit the spread of coronavirus. This is why we have set out an unprecedented package of financial support.

“The job support scheme is just one element of this comprehensive package, which includes rental support, mortgage holidays, and £9.3bn of extra funding for the welfare safety net to help those unable to access other forms of support.”


Molly Blackall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Northern England mayors given noon deadline to submit Covid plans
Boris Johnson to outline three-tier system of restrictions, with pubs closed and mixing banned

Nazia Parveen North of England correspondent

11, Oct, 2020 @9:46 AM

Article image
Reduced Covid furlough scheme is an insult, say northern leaders
MPs and mayors say measures not enough as council leaders plead for local lockdown lifeline

Josh Halliday North of England correspondent

09, Oct, 2020 @4:53 PM

Article image
Northern mayors accuse government of southern bias in lockdown rules
Andy Burnham and Steve Rotherham say furlough extension shows government values northern workers less

Helen Pidd North of England editor and Aaron Walawalkar

01, Nov, 2020 @10:53 AM

Article image
Conservatives step up charm offensive in north of England
Chancellor to promise infrastructure cash and greater regional devolution as he seeks to woo voters outside of Tory heartlands

Rowena Mason, political correspondent

04, Aug, 2014 @11:01 PM

Article image
A radical year in the north

Ann Czernik reports and photographs regularly for the Guardian Northerner on the social challenges facing our three regions as austerity takes its toll. In the last year, she has looked at York's housing crisis, action to defend jobs and teenage binge drinking as well as public reaction to 2012's byelections and police commissioner and local council polls. Here's her calendar with a precis of prospects for the year ahead.

Ann Czernik

09, Jan, 2013 @10:13 AM

Article image
Tories promise £4bn for public transport in Midlands and north
Election pledge counters Labour plans to renationalise railways and cut ticket prices

Peter Walker Political correspondent

04, Dec, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Tier 3 lockdowns: how each region's support package compares
The government has faced battles with local leaders in parts of England over the terms of imposing tighter restrictions

Ben Quinn, Cath Levett and Harry Fischer

21, Oct, 2020 @4:07 PM

Article image
UK's regional light rail services at risk from coronavirus outbreak
Northern cities’ networks need urgent help from the Treasury to cope with collapse in fares

Gwyn Topham Transport correspondent

20, Apr, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
No agreed power, no agreed budget: Dan Jarvis on his fight to be Sheffield mayor
Labour candidate seeks to overcome voter apathy with pledge to work for wider Yorkshire deal

Frances Perraudin

23, Apr, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Masks should remain mandatory on public transport, say English mayors
Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham also in favour of continued mask-wearing in essential shops

Peter Walker, Helen Pidd, Linda Geddes and Gwyn Topham

05, Jul, 2021 @5:47 PM