Use Holocaust memorial funds to educate instead, Rabbi says

Jonathan Romain tells inquiry that Westminster site would ‘not combat antisemitism’

Funds earmarked for a national Holocaust memorial in Westminster would be more effectively spent on educating people about the murder of 6 million Jews in the second world war, a rabbi has told a public inquiry.

Rabbi Jonathan Romain, of Maidenhead synagogue, told the inquiry into a planning application for the memorial next to the Houses of Parliament that “monuments do not combat antisemitism”.

He said: “The substantial cost of the proposed memorial … could be better used. If £100m – or maybe it has now risen even higher – went into Holocaust education nationally, rather than a London-centric edifice – that would have far greater impact.”

There was no point in duplicating the Holocaust wing at the nearby Imperial War Museum, Romain said. and the need for a memorial was debatable. “Britain was not involved in initiating the Holocaust or assisting in it or standing by, and so, unlike various European countries, Britain has no guilt to expunge.”

Romain said he was sure that most British Jews “feel that if there is to be a museum, let it be to Jewish life, Jewish culture, Jewish contribution to wider society … but not to dead Jews and Jewish victimhood.”

The inquiry into the location of the memorial opened this week after the application was called in last November by Esther McVey, the then housing minister. The final decision will be taken by her successor, Christopher Pincher.

The memorial in Victoria Tower Gardens next to parliament was proposed by David Cameron five years ago and has been backed by Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer along with the former prime ministers Theresa May, Gordon Brown, Tony Blair and John Major and more than 170 MPs and peers and many faith leaders.

Opposition has come from some senior Jewish figures who have challenged its location, and the Royal Parks, which said it would have a “significant harmful impact” on the area.

Toby Simpson, the director of the Wiener Holocaust Library, told the inquiry that the memorial was a “once-in-a-lifetime opportunity” to ensure that victims of the Nazis were “permanently honoured”, and it was fitting that it be located in a position of the greatest possible prominence.

Such a memorial was “sadly very relevant today” amid a rising tide of intolerance and prejudice, he said.

The inquiry is scheduled to last five weeks.


Harriet Sherwood

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Holocaust memorial service pays tribute to victims of genocides
Survivors and relatives gather in London for service ahead of Holocaust Memorial Day

Caroline Davies

25, Jan, 2018 @7:26 PM

Article image
Holocaust memorial in Westminster is given go-ahead after inquiry
Controversial £100m education centre to be built next to parliament, but opponents may launch appeal

Harriet Sherwood

29, Jul, 2021 @12:22 PM

Article image
Team led by David Adjaye to design UK's Holocaust memorial
Location next to parliament in London has triggered objections from residents and opposition from Imperial War Museum

Harriet Sherwood

24, Oct, 2017 @2:50 PM

Article image
Imperial War Museum Holocaust Galleries review – history’s greatest horror
Under glaring lights, the IWM’s new permanent exhibit lays bare the unspeakable atrocity through the small, human details

Jonathan Freedland

10, Oct, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Church of England says Christians must repent for past antisemitism
Document acknowledges Christians’ part in persecution of Jewish people over centuries

Harriet Sherwood

21, Nov, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Theresa May backs building of Holocaust centre near parliament
Plans for memorial and museum sparked protests over environmental impact

Heather Stewart

06, May, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Find a better site for Holocaust memorial in London | Letters
Letters: Plans for a Holocaust memorial close to the Thames in central London are criticised by Patricia Hollis, Michael Daley and Quetta Kaye and Alice Roberts, while Michael Madden suggests a simpler form of memorial


03, Nov, 2017 @6:52 PM

Article image
Ken Loach: I give no legitimacy to Holocaust denial | Letters
Letters: The Holocaust is as real a historical event as the second world war itself, and it is contemptible to imply that I have anything in common with people like David Irving, writes Ken Loach


05, Oct, 2017 @6:01 PM

Article image
Imperial War Museum in clash over planned Holocaust memorial
Imperial War Museum in clash over planned Holocaust memorial

Harriet Sherwood

07, Oct, 2017 @8:30 PM

Article image
My family after the Holocaust: ‘The urge to draw a line under the past is strong’
Our grandparents lived through the horror of the war. So why do we want to reclaim our German nationality?

Kate Figes

10, Mar, 2018 @6:00 AM