Asylum plans should fill Tories with deep shame | Letters

Readers respond to government’s proposals to process migrants seeking refuge in the UK in detention facilities overseas or on disused ferry boats

There have been many times recently when I have felt ashamed of our government, but no more so than when I see a headline about dispersing asylum seekers to any part of the world except the UK (Revealed: No 10 explores sending asylum seekers to Moldova, Morocco and Papua New Guinea, 30 September). Whether or not this has been dreamed up by Dominic Cummings, the responsibility lies with Priti Patel and Boris Johnson, and they should feel deep shame.

No one hands over their life savings, says goodbye to their family, that is, if they haven’t already lost them to war or famine, and risks their life in a long, frightening and dangerous journey to reach our shores without believing that this is the only way they can save themselves. How many times do we have to ask the government, and the media, to stop assuming that these desperate people crossing the channel are doing so only for what they can get out of this country? I talk to asylum seekers and refugees every week; their stories of violence, trauma and loss are heartbreaking.

They trust that we will help make them safe. And yet, the government talks about them as if they are animals, suggesting that they can be herded on to disused ferries or shipped to the farthest reaches of our overseas territories where they can be “processed”. We process meat and peas. Asylum seekers are human beings, like you and me, and deserve the same respect and compassion as we do. The UK’s record of providing refuge for asylum seekers is appalling. We have room, we can and should do better.
Pat Beesley
Newcastle upon Tyne

• With growing incredulity, I read about the plan hatched in No 10 to send asylum seekers to an offshore location for assessment. In your report, Moldova, Morocco or Papua New Guinea are cited after the outcry brought about by their first suggestions of Ascension Island or St Helena. This follows the discredited approach used by previous Australian governments to use islands off the Australian coast.

May I suggest that the government looks closer to home? England will soon become an inconsequential island off the coast of Europe and fit its crazed and cruel approach.
Richard Yoell
Bromham, Bedfordshire

• Priti Patel’s proposal to dump asylum seekers in the south Atlantic or Papua New Guinea is not without precedent. Eighty or so years ago, another government considered exporting a group of human beings it similarly despised to Madagascar. And so again, this government continues to goose-step over the line that divides the hard right from the far right, inspired by the worst possible historical examples.
Frank Danes
Ely, Cambridgeshire

• One additional concern about putting large numbers of asylum seekers into confined accommodation (Editorial, 1 October) is the risk of transmission of infectious diseases. Cruise ships, in particular, spread coronavirus widely, in staff as well as passengers. Many asylum seekers have had minimal access to hygiene facilities and healthy food in transit, and are particularly vulnerable. As well as denying their right to a safe environment, it also creates a reservoir of infection for local communities.
Dr Michael Peel

• Looking at the latest disgraceful ideas of the government on asylum seekers, the residents of San Serriffe will be thankful that neither Dominic Cummings nor Priti Patel has ever read the Guardian.
Keith Flett
Tottenham, London


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rwanda refugee policy is like the rendition of slaves in the 1800s | Letters
Letters: Prof Julia O’Connell Davidson likens the government’s plans to deport asylum seekers to the forced returns facilitated by the Fugitive Slave Act in the US. Plus a letter from Mark Stephens


16, Jun, 2022 @4:44 PM

Article image
Priti Patel’s asylum tirade plumbs new depths | Letters
Letters: The home secretary incites further disregard for the legal entitlements of vulnerable people, to whom this country has clear international obligations, writes John Nicholson. Plus letters from Jackie Fearnley and SP Chakravarty


07, Oct, 2020 @4:13 PM

Article image
Hostile asylum policies made tragedy inevitable | Letters
Letters: After at least 27 people lost their lives in a Channel boat crossing, readers discuss the government’s culpability in closing off safe routes for refugees


25, Nov, 2021 @5:49 PM

Article image
Our outrage over Rwanda deportation policy is just what ministers want | Letters
Letters: Boris Johnson knows the cruel plan to deport asylum seekers is unworkable, but hopes it will distract voters from Partygate and economic woes, writes Tom Lerwill. Plus letters from John Morrison, Felicity Laurence, John Ling and Rosie Clinton


15, Jun, 2022 @5:12 PM

Article image
Those seeking asylum deserve so much better than this government | Letters
Letters: New immigration proposals betray the UK’s history of accepting refugees, write Dr Edie Friedman and Adam Rose from the Jewish Council for Racial Equality. Plus letters from Ruth Kitching and John Nicholson


28, Mar, 2021 @3:41 PM

Article image
Patel’s asylum plans lack sense and compassion | Letters
Letters: Instead of pursuing cruel and unethical means of controlling immigration, the Home Office must focus on providing safe and legal routes to the UK, write Jewish campaigners for racial equality, while Richard Hargreaves describes Priti Patel’s proposals as indefensible


12, Oct, 2020 @4:26 PM

Article image
There’s no justification for age-testing migrant children | Letter
Letter: Evidence shows that very few migrant children lie about their age, and X-ray tests will do more harm than good, writes Dr Eithne Nightingale


29, Oct, 2021 @5:31 PM

Article image
There is no excuse for woeful UK response to Ukraine’s refugee crisis | Letters
Letters: Heads of refugee advocacy groups write to condemn the government’s inadequate and hostile asylum polices. Plus letters from Mike Hodgson and Julie Platt


08, Mar, 2022 @4:59 PM

Article image
An ambitious overhaul of education is needed | Letters
Letters: The Conservative One Nation group’s report on schooling doesn’t go far enough, according to Greg Brooks and Steven Burkeman, while Ruth Eversley ponders a career recommendation


12, Oct, 2020 @4:28 PM

Article image
UK plans to send thousands of asylum seekers to Rwanda, says Boris Johnson – as it happened
Opposition parties denounce plan as ‘shameful’ and ‘evil’; home secretary Priti Patel in Kigali today to unveil more details

Andrew Sparrow

14, Apr, 2022 @4:45 PM