Hong Kong national security law pits judges against justice officials in activist's trial

Justice department pushes to install national security judge in case as three pro-democracy legislators arrested over unruly scenes during debate

Hong Kong’s department of justice has asked that a national security judge take over the trial of an activist, even though he has not been charged with national security offences, in a move that underlines the erosion of the city’s independent legal system.

It came as a senior Chinese official called for “judicial reform” in Hong Kong and three pro-democracy legislators were arrested.

Activist Tam Tak-chi is facing more than a dozen charges, including for “uttering seditious phrases” and advocating for an independent Hong Kong. He has been charged with sedition under colonial-era crimes laws, but on Tuesday the department of justice told the district court’s chief judge that Tam’s case may involve national security matters and thus should be overseen by a specialist judge, RTHK reported.

It also suggested that a national security judge must be appointed to decide on their request, a suggestion the chief judge, Justin Ko, rejected.

The sweeping national security law enacted in June allows for specialist judges appointed by the chief executive to hear cases, and has blurred the avenues of appeal for such cases in Hong Kong. The department said having a normal judge preside over the case could have implications for any potential judicial review.

Ko ordered both parties to make submissions by the end of the week. The department of justice has been contacted for comment.

There is growing alarm at apparent interference in Hong Kong’s judiciary, particularly since the imposition of the law, and over claims by senior leaders that Hong Kong has no separation of powers.

On Tuesday, deputy director of the Hong Kong and Macao Affairs Office, Zhang Xiaoming, called for Beijing to assert more control over the semi-autonomous region, telling a legal summit that the work was underway on “reforms” related to the judiciary, “oath optimisation” and “qualification screening” for civil servants, and national education.

“We need to see [Hong Kong’s mini constitution] the basic law as something that is alive so we can interpret the basic law whenever necessary,” said the senior Chinese official, who also hailed the removal of four pro-democracy legislators last week.

The group was expelled immediately after a decree by Beijing reinterpreted the basic law to allow for the disqualification of “unpatriotic” legislators. The expulsion prompted the mass resignation of the pro-democracy caucus in protest at the continuing crackdown on opposition.

On Wednesday, police again arrested three of those legislators, in relation to incidents during televised legislative debates in May and June. The former lawmakers Ted Hui, Ray Chan and Chu Hoi-dick confirmed the arrests on their Facebook pages.

Footage showed Chu and Chan rushing to the front of the chamber during a June debate and splashing a foul-smelling fluid as guards grappled with them. Police and firefighters arrived later. Footage in May showed Hui dropping a rotten plant in the middle of the meeting.

Police said that after an in-depth investigation, the three men had been charged with attempting to use harmful substances with the intent to cause harm, mental injury or irritation to others. They have been detained while the investigation continues.

Earlier this month a private prosecution by Chan against a pro-Beijing legislator Kwok Wai-Keung for alleged assault was quashed after the department of justice intervened. Footage widely shared online showed Kwok dragging Chan to the ground during a May meeting which descended into violence. The department of justice said Kwok’s actions were lawful and reasonable “under the circumstances”.

Seven pro-democracy legislators, including Chu and Chan, have already been charged over their involvement in events on the day.


Helen Davidson in Taipei, and agencies

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hong Kong: landmark national security trial of 47 democracy advocates begins
Protests as former politicians, activists, campaigners and community workers appear in court accused of ‘conspiracy to commit subversion’

Helen Davidson and Kelly Ho and Candice Chau in Hong Kong

06, Feb, 2023 @12:11 PM

Article image
Hong Kong 47: trial of dozens in pro-democracy movement set to begin under national security laws
Group of legislators, activists and community workers are accused of holding unofficial pre-election primaries that authorities say constitutes subversion

Helen Davidson in Taipei and Verna Yu

04, Feb, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
'Let's learn about national security': Hong Kong rewrites school rules
Animation features an owl teaching young children about the need for the controversial law in crackdown on education

Helen Davidson in Taipei

05, Feb, 2021 @5:25 AM

Article image
'Remarkably effective': Carrie Lam praises Hong Kong national security law
Chief executive says in annual address the city’s problems driven by ‘external forces’ and pandemic

Helen Davidson in Taipei

25, Nov, 2020 @6:05 AM

Article image
‘They can’t speak freely’: Hong Kong a year after the national security law
Powerful chilling effect as dissenters are detained, often without charges, and face life in prison

Helen Davidson in Taipei

29, Jun, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai to plead not guilty in national security case
Democracy activist and Apple Daily founder will stand trial without jury and could face up to life in prison

Helen Davidson in Taipei and agencies

23, Aug, 2022 @7:25 AM

Article image
Hong Kong protests: police fire teargas as thousands rally against Beijing's national security law
Armoured vehicles and water cannon deployed earlier to tackle protests amid China plans to force through security laws

Guardian reporter in Hong Kong, Helen Davidson, and Lily Kuo in Beijing

24, May, 2020 @5:55 AM

Article image
Chinese parliament approves controversial Hong Kong security law
Move paves way for anti-sedition laws that rights advocates say threaten freedoms, as US opposition builds

Lily Kuo in Beijing

28, May, 2020 @3:58 PM

Article image
Hong Kong protest pair swept up in national security crackdown plead guilty
Andy Li and Chan Tsz-wah were accused of conspiring with media mogul Jimmy Lai to call for sanctions on China and Hong Kong

Helen Davidson in Taipei

19, Aug, 2021 @5:47 AM

Article image
Hong Kong children schooled in national security as city ‘celebrates’ new laws
Kindergartens given specially themed puzzles and others taught to ‘safeguard homeland’ on National Security Education day

Helen Davidson in Taipei

15, Apr, 2021 @5:54 AM