Hong Kong TV journalist charged over report on police misconduct

Choy Yuk-ling could face jail for film about claims of police collusion with armed thugs

Hong Kong police have arrested and charged a journalist at a public broadcaster in relation to a documentary about the 2019 Yuen Long incident, when police were accused of standing by as armed thugs attacked commuters.

RTHK confirmed the arrest of Choy Yuk-ling, one of the producers of Hong Kong Connection. The respected current affairs programme investigated the police response to the attack, which left 45 people needing treatment in hospital.

Police charged Choi with two counts of giving false information, by misusing a vehicle number plate search as part of the investigation. The case will go before a magistrates court on 10 November, where she faces fines of up to HK$5,000 and six months in jail.

Video footage of the attack, on 21 July 2019, showed dozens of mostly masked men in white shirts storming a mass transit station in Yuen Long, chasing passengers and beating them with sticks. Hong Kong Connection used licence plate searches to connect cars seen at Yuen Long to people involved in the attack, and revealed links between alleged attackers and influential pro-Beijing village committees.

“The show revealed how police were patrolling the town before the rampage and took no action over the men wielding weapons,” RTHK said in a tweet confirming Choy’s arrest.

Police were widely criticised for failing to attend emergency calls from Yuen Long for over half an hour and making no arrests on the night, prompting accusations of collusion, which were exacerbated when pictures emerged of police officers standing alongside the attackers. Police have strenuously denied the accusations of collusion.

Changing and contradictory statements from police over time led to accusations they were attempting to rewrite history.

RTHK’s director of broadcasting, Leung Ka-wing, said the station was “afraid”, and if the arrest was due to Choy’s reporting then it was a serious matter for the entire industry.

“We are worried … whether we can continue the way we produce accurate news as before,” Leung said, but when asked if RTHK would put any current investigations on hold, he replied: “Why should we stop?”

Hong Kong journalists questioned the arrest, suggesting it was an attempt to discourage reporters from accessing public records to investigate authorities. The application form to search vehicle registration records was significantly tightened this year, leaving no option for journalistic queries.

“I think authorities are now exhausting every possible way to suppress the press, to make it difficult, if not impossible, for reporters to do their job to dig out the truth, to publish stories that make [the authorities] feel embarrassed,” the chair of the Hong Kong Journalists Association, Chris Yeung, told RTHK.

A local news reporter, Alvin Lum, said on Twitter that Hong Kong privacy law allowed for journalistic public interest exceptions, and the arrest would set an “outrageous precedent to use of public registries and undermine transparency”.

Since last year’s mass protests, and in particular since the introduction of the national security law in June, Hong Kong authorities have waged a crackdown on dissent and criticism.

While this is the first time a full-time journalist has been arrested in relation to their reporting, observers have blamed the national security law for creating a chilling effect on media and academics. The public broadcaster RTHK has been under particular pressure from pro-Beijing government members and authorities.

Yuen Long was the highest profile incident involving accusations or instances of police misconduct or brutality during the 2019 protests. No police officer has ever been charged, and in May an internal report by the police watchdog, the IPCC, covering the 2019 protest period, largely cleared them of any wrongdoing.

The IPCC said while police were slow to act at Yuen Long, it saw no evidence of collusion between police officers and the attackers – although it acknowledged it did not have the power to investigate collusion – and said that if police had taken any arrest action it would “would only escalate the situation”.


Helen Davidson in Taipei

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hong Kong journalist allowed to travel to UK after court grants bail
Ronson Chan was arrested in September as part of an ongoing crackdown on dissent and free expression in the city

Helen Davidson in Taipei

22, Sep, 2022 @2:41 PM

Article image
Hong Kong protests bring crisis of confidence for traditional media
Young turn to social media as newspapers and TV stations owned by local tycoons take care not to offend mainland China

Jonathan Kaiman in Hong Kong

29, Oct, 2014 @12:01 AM

Article image
‘Worst of times’: Hong Kong media defiant amid police crackdown
Apple Daily hits back after executives arrested in second raid on pro-democracy paper’s newsroom

Helen Davidson in Taipei

17, Jun, 2021 @11:34 AM

Hong Kong journalist resigns in controversy over interview

Paper denies her claims about amending interviewee's Tiananmen Square remarks

Roy Greenslade

22, Jul, 2013 @9:51 AM

Article image
Hong Kong’s Citizen News to close citing fears for staff safety
Independent online news portal to cease operations amid ‘worsening environment for media’ in city

Helen Davidson with agencies

03, Jan, 2022 @5:36 AM

Article image
Hong Kong court convicts journalist who investigated metro attack
Case against RTHK producer Bao Choy has become central to Hong Kong authorities’ press clampdown

Helen Davidson in Taipei

22, Apr, 2021 @2:25 PM

Article image
Hong Kong court acquits media mogul Jimmy Lai of intimidation
Magistrate finds no evidence pro-democracy tycoon tried to instil fear in reporter from rival paper

Helen Davidson

03, Sep, 2020 @10:30 AM

Article image
Timeline of events leading to the closure of Hong Kong’s Apple Daily
Key moments in the recent history of territory’s largest pro-democracy newspaper

Helen Davidson in Taipei

23, Jun, 2021 @2:32 PM

Article image
Hero's welcome for Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai after release on bail
Apple Daily founder and pro-democracy activist returns to office following arrest under national security law

Helen Davidson

12, Aug, 2020 @9:31 AM

Article image
Fears raised after Hong Kong journalist fails to return from China trip
Minnie Chan has reportedly been out of contact since travelling to Xiangshan Forum a month ago

Helen Davidson in Taipei

01, Dec, 2023 @10:38 AM