Europe must prepare for US exit from vital Russia treaty, former Nato generals warn

Joint statement urges US to remain in Open Skies Treaty, designed to reduce risk of war breaking out through miscalculation

A group of retired Nato generals and defence officials have urged the US to stay in a 1992 treaty with Russia on mutual reconnaissance flights, but also warned European capitals to prepare for a US exit.

The US defence secretary, Mark Esper, and the secretary of state, Mike Pompeo, are said by US sources to be determined to leave the Open Skies Treaty (OST), which European leaders and arms control advocates believe reduces the risk of a war breaking out through miscalculation by adding to mutual transparency.

A joint statement by a group of 16 retired military commanders and defence ministers, coordinated by the European Leadership Network (ELN) released on Tuesday, said the OST was a vital pillar of stability between nuclear powers.

“With 34 states parties, including the United States, Russia and most European countries, the multilateral accord has facilitated 1,517 short-notice and unarmed overflights,” the statement said.

“Throughout its operation, the treaty has increased military transparency and predictability, helped build trust and confidence, and enhanced mutual understanding.”

If the US does withdraw from the treaty, it will lose the right to carry out overflights of Russia, but Russia would still be able to fly over US military facilities in Europe.

The signatories to the statement include General Sir David Richards, the former UK chief of defence staff, General Klaus Naumann, the former chief of staff of the German armed forces, and General Bernard Norlain, France’s former Air Defence Air Combat commander.

They suggested Europe could be the biggest loser from a US withdrawal

“While the intelligence and confidence building advantages are limited for the US itself, they are very real for America’s Nato allies. The strategic benefits to the US of ‘stability in the Euro-Atlantic region’ are also very real,” they said.

The former officers and defence ministers urged Russia to drop infringements of the treaty, cited by its US opponents as reasons for withdrawal: limitations on flights over the Baltic enclave of Kaliningrad and the creation of an exclusion corridor along the border of the Russian-occupied regions of South Ossetia and Abkhazia.

But if the US does leave the treaty, the statement argues its Nato allies should stay in the agreement, noting that European states perform 55% of the flights and are the subject of nearly 59% of Russian overflights. European states do not have the satellite-surveillance capacity of the US, so are particularly reliant on Open Skies flights, which can be carried out under cloud cover.

It calls for the remaining parties to the treaty to meet within two months of a US withdrawal to discuss how the agreement would function without Washington. That would involve limits on what information Nato members could share with the US.

“It’s important for western European governments, to be prepared for this,” said Andreas Persbo, ELN research director. “For them this treaty has some value, and it would be in their interest to continue flying over Russia, and Russia would like to continue to overfly western Europe. The question is can that be maintained without Russia exacting too heavy a price from western governments.”

Contributor

Julian Borger in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Nato and Russia trade barbs after collapse of nuclear arms treaty
US pulls out of cold war-era INF treaty after Moscow’s ‘secret deployment’ of cruise missiles

Dan Sabbagh Defence and security editor

02, Aug, 2019 @12:47 PM

Article image
Russia must have role in Europe-based missile defence system, says Nato chief
Anders Rasmussen calls for Russian involvement in missile defence project

Richard Norton-Taylor

18, Apr, 2010 @3:45 PM

Article image
WikiLeaks' Nato revelations cause 'bewilderment' in Russia

US embassy cables show Nato had drawn up plans to defend Poland and Baltic states against Russian attack

Tom Parfitt in Moscow

07, Dec, 2010 @2:36 PM

Nato snubs US by resuming Russia contacts

West European members stall Nato membership bids from Georgia and Ukraine despite US pressure

Ian Traynor in Brussels

03, Dec, 2008 @12:01 AM

Article image
Blinken says Nato united on Ukraine as EU ministers prepare to meet
US secretary of state says Germans ‘share our concerns’ after navy chief’s comments rattle alliance

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

23, Jan, 2022 @7:24 PM

Article image
Nato head Anders Fogh Rasmussen calls for partnership with Russia
Focus on good relations with Moscow will worry Nato members in central Europe protesting over Obama's Kremlin overtures

Ian Traynor in Brussels

03, Aug, 2009 @3:35 PM

Article image
‘Europe is sidelined’: Russia meets US in Geneva and Nato in Brussels
EU leaders warn of consequences in response to further aggression against Ukraine

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

12, Jan, 2022 @1:10 PM

Article image
Nato unprepared for potential threats from Russia, say MPs

Cross-party report issued as group of former Russian and European defence ministers warn of risk of accidental war

Richard Norton-Taylor and Julian Borger

30, Jul, 2014 @11:30 PM

Article image
'Fit for purpose' Nato looks to Russia for help with missile defence shield

Nato adopts mission statement to bridge arguments on nuclear weapons, missile defence, and relations with Turkey and Russia

Ian Traynor in Lisbon

19, Nov, 2010 @7:41 PM

Article image
Nato countries begin largest war game in eastern Europe since cold war
Ten-day military exercise, Anaconda-2016, will involve 31,000 troops and thousands of vehicles from 24 countries

Alex Duval Smith in Warsaw

06, Jun, 2016 @4:15 PM