Florida’s Covid-19 surge shows the state's reopening plan is not working

As counties end the second week of Governor Ron DeSantis’ ‘safe, smart, step-by-step’ policy, the state marks a record high in daily cases

It has been seven weeks since Florida’s governor, Ron DeSantis, took a coronavirus “victory lap”, pressing ahead with a swift reopening program while berating the media for a “doom and gloom” approach he said bore little relation to reality.

“We haven’t seen an explosion of new cases,” DeSantis insisted during a 29 April news conference, a day on which the state’s Covid-19 tally increased by 347.

“There is a light at the end of the tunnel,” DeSantis, a keen Trump ally, added.

This week, however, it became clear that the Republican governor’s garden of roses is wilting fast in the face of a resurgent virus.

A period that began with Florida’s daily record of new cases below 1,700 saw eight consecutive days above that figure, five of them topping 2,000 and both Thursday and Friday seeing the highest numbers of all: 3,207 and 3,822 cases, respectively, eclipsing the previous recorded high by more than 35%.

The staggering figures have caused experts at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and University of Pennsylvania to conclude that Florida has “all the markings of the next large epicenter of coronavirus transmission”. Such a consequence could be significant in a politically sensitive swing state that analysts agree Donald Trump must win in November to secure a second term as president.

“Governor DeSantis has lost control of Florida’s Covid-19 response,” said Nikki Fried, the agricultural commissioner and only Democrat elected to statewide office, who has previously complained at being shut out of DeSantis’s recovery taskforce.

“His policies are simply not working and he’s recklessly reopening Florida despite the data screaming for caution. Refusing to acknowledge the alarming patterns in cases, hospitalizations and positivity is not only arrogant but will cost lives, public health and our economy,” Fried added.

The rise in Florida’s figures, with close to 90,000 cases and deaths surpassing 3,000, comes as the majority of its 67 counties reach the end of the second week of DeSantis’s “safe, smart, step-by-step” reopening plan.

Restaurants and shops are open in Miami Beach, Florida.
Restaurants and shops are open in Miami Beach, Florida. Photograph: Michele Eve Sandberg/Rex/Shutterstock

Beaches, bars and restaurants, movie theaters and entertainment venues are mostly open again, with tighter restrictions in the hardest-hit counties of Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach. Universal Orlando resort welcomed back guests on 5 June and Disney World will reopen its theme parks next month.

DeSantis, meanwhile, contends that Florida is on the right track, arguing that the rising figures can be attributed to increased testing, particularly among younger residents, and concentrated pockets of outbreaks among agricultural workers, prison inmates and even a 52% positivity rate among airport workers – an unsubstantiated claim debunked by the Orlando Sentinel.

He refuses to consider calls to slow or reverse the pace of Florida’s reopening. “We’re not shutting down. We’re going to go forward. We’re not rolling back. You have to have society function,” DeSantis said on Tuesday.

His comments came the same day Vice-President Mike Pence wrote in a Wall Street Journal opinion piece that concerns over a second wave of coronavirus were “overblown” by the press, and that the White House was “winning the fight against the invisible enemy”.

DeSantis’s critics say that although testing has increased in Florida, the number of cases has risen at a significantly higher rate. They point to other indicators, such as declining availability of intensive care and other hospital beds around the state, and a rising positivity rate in Covid-19 tests that has climbed back above 10% for the first time since April.

Public health analysts see merit in both arguments, but warn of darker days ahead if social distancing is not maintained. Already in Jacksonville some newly reopened bars have closed again after a Covid-19 outbreak.

“The bulk of this is almost certainly due to testing [but] there is definitely evidence of wider community spread, typically among younger folks,” said Dr Charles Lockwood, senior vice-president of USF Health in Tampa and dean of the university’s Morsani college of medicine.

“There are enough signals, a drop in test negativity, a slight increase in influenza-like illnesses, bad behavior in terms of social distancing, that I’m concerned.”

Around the state there are rumblings that renewed closures could become necessary. Jerry Demings, the mayor of Orange county, said he would consider a lockdown if numbers continued to rise, a view echoed by Francis Suarez, the mayor of Miami.

Municipalities are also tightening up restrictions because of the surge. Beginning Friday, businesses in St Petersburg must ensure employees wear masks, now a requirement for visitors to the Florida Keys under a law enacted this week.

Carol Dover, president and chief executive of the Florida restaurant and lodging association, said she remained “guarded” about the immediate future of the state’s $67bn tourism industry, even though numbers since the reopening “are still going in the right direction”.

“Our members are doing everything they can to survive at 50% [occupancy], hoping the governor will be able to get us to 75 or 100%,” she said. “I’m hopeful and somewhat guarded because we’re not completely open yet but I feel the governor has done an amazing job.”


Richard Luscombe in Miami

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Florida’s ‘mini-Trump’ Ron DeSantis under growing pressure as Covid-19 cases surge
The Republican governor has seen rising cases and bleak new records, but the prospect of mask orders and reopening reversals are slim

Daniel Strauss in Washington

17, Jul, 2020 @2:30 PM

Article image
Florida’s governor celebrated his anti-mandate Covid laws. Now Omicron is here
Ron DeSantis struck ‘a blow for freedom’ with his lax measures, but those could allow the new variant to circulate faster

Richard Luscombe in Miami

04, Dec, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
This fourth grader just wants to go to school. Florida’s risky Covid policies force her to stay home
Governor DeSantis’s ‘soft-on-Covid approach’ makes the classroom too dangerous for immuno-compromised children

Richard Luscombe in Miami, Florida

28, Sep, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Half of Florida’s 2.8m public school students now face mask mandates
School boards defy Governor Ron DeSantis’s ban as Orange county changes stance after surge in Covid-19 cases

Guardian staff and agencies

25, Aug, 2021 @7:07 PM

Article image
Ousted expert on Florida's Covid plan: 'They're not listening to the scientists'
After she refused to manipulate virus data, Rebekah Jones was fired – and subjected to vicious criticism from the governor. But, she says, she won’t be silenced

Richard Luscombe in Miami

12, Aug, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
DeSantis names doctor opposed to mask and vaccine mandates as Florida’s surgeon general
Dr Joseph Ladapo attacked concern over the pandemic as ‘Covid mania’ and said ‘there is nothing special’ about vaccines

Oliver Milman

22, Sep, 2021 @12:56 PM

Article image
Over 40 Florida hospitals max out ICU capacity as Covid-19 cases surge across US
Coronavirus infections rising in 41 states, including less densely populated areas

Jessica Glenza

10, Jul, 2020 @7:31 PM

Article image
Florida man stalks beach as Grim Reaper to protest reopening amid pandemic
Death goes viral on social media after attorney dresses up to alert Floridians to the dangers of reopening their economy too soon

Martin Pengelly

02, May, 2020 @2:21 PM

Article image
Florida scientist says she was fired for refusing to change Covid-19 data 'to support reopen plan'
Dr Rebekah Jones says she was fired from Department of Health by the governor after protesting order to censor information

Richard Luscombe

20, May, 2020 @12:13 PM

Article image
Disney World set to reopen at weekend despite coronavirus surge in Florida
State recorded a record high of 120 Covid-19 deaths on Wednesday and is seeing one of the largest outbreaks in the US

Richard Luscombe in Miami

10, Jul, 2020 @6:15 AM