Inhabitants ebb out of Venice as city is flooded with water and tourists

Increasing floods, badly managed tourism and lack of affordable homes drive residents out

Patricia Blaci has lived in Venice for 25 years, cherishing the centuries-old floating city for all its beauty and complexity. But after her home was severely damaged by flooding in November, the worst since 1966, she decided to leave.

“It wasn’t an easy decision, I have a deep affection for this city and have fought for it,” Blaci, an architect and tour guide, said. “But it has become too difficult to stay. It’s like living on a boat. Occasionally you get water entering, it rises and then goes down, like a tide. This time it went up a lot higher and lasted for five days.”

Venice’s historical centre and its 11 inhabited islands last year lost 1,092 people to other towns, cities and, in some cases, countries. Blaci, who is relocating to Spain, had been mulling the move for some time, but the deluge gave her the final push.

Venice, once the heart of a powerful maritime republic, faces many threats to its survival as sea levels rise, but among the most daunting is depopulation. Recurrent flooding, a soaring cost of living, lack of affordable housing and badly managed tourism have driven 120,000 people away since the early 1950s, the majority across the lagoon to the mainland, but over the last 20 years the pace has hastened alongside the advent of cheap flights and flourishing cruise tourism. As many as 60,000 tourists each day in the summer flock to the historic centre where 52,000 people live.

Tourists in Venice
As many as 60,000 tourists a day visit Venice’s historic centre, many from cruise ships. Photograph: Radosław Kisiel/Alamy Stock Photo

Walk through Venice’s winding alleyways at night, after the day-trippers have gone, and the numerous homes with closed shutters reflect a trend that a succession of administrations have struggled to reverse.

“Look over there,” Blaci said, pointing to a shop selling souvenirs in the San Polo district. “Artisanal shops have closed and have been replaced by these. Money takes precedence. The infrastructure no longer exists for people to live here comfortably.”

Maria Teresa Laghi, who runs one of the few traditional shops left in the area, said: “Venice didn’t lose its soul, it sold it.”

venice and mestre map

Depopulation dominated a referendum in early December on whether the historic centre and islands should split administratively from the industrial mainland borough of Mestre, with pro-separatists suggesting it could stymie the exodus as it would give them better control over their own affairs.

The referendum, the fifth held since 1979, failed because it did not reach the 50% threshold required for it to be valid. However, it is telling that the majority of those who did vote live in the historic centre and supported autonomy.

“The ‘last survivors’ were in favour of division whereas in the past people mostly voted for union,” said Gilda Zazzara, a history professor at Venice’s Ca’ Foscari University.

The mayor of Venice, Luigi Brugnaro, encouraged citizens to snub the referendum, while his supporters accused campaigners of exploiting fears over depopulation.

Brugnaro’s council argues that the problem is not so much people leaving, as people dying: there were 1,038 deaths across the islands between January and October, and only 361 births. At the same time, while 1,092 people have left, the council registered 1,172 new inhabitants.

Matteo Secchi, who leads the activist group Venessia, disputes the immigration figure. “The number is false, because in so many cases people come here, buy a home, get residency and then rent the home to tourists while living elsewhere. We estimate that around 5,000 ‘inhabitants’ do this.”

Local authorities are making some attempts to attract young residents, such as spending €7.2m (£6m) on restoring 168 abandoned homes in the historic centre before launching a competition next year for them to be rented out at below-market rate.

However, there are no regulations governing one of the biggest gripes – the landlords who are renting their homes to tourists using sites such as Airbnb, making it impossible for people to rent a home for a reasonable price over the long term.

“This is the main issue,” said Luciana Colle, deputy mayor of Venice. “Private owners are free to do as they wish but maybe they should be more sensitive to the needs of others.”

Those who have resisted leaving say it is their elected leaders who ought to be more sensitive to their needs. They argue that politicians are unable to empathise with the difficulties of life in the lagoon because the majority live on the mainland. Brugnaro, for example, lives more than an hour away and Colle lives in Mestre.

“They like the idea of representing Venice as it is unique in the world and gives prestige,” said Giorgio Suppiej, the president of Venezia Serenissima, a cultural association. “But none of them have got their feet wet or had their homes flooded. We lose around 1,000 people a year and if it carries on this way, it will be the end.”

There are a few bright spots in Venice’s demographics. Over the years, some of the offspring of those who fled have moved back, attracted by the peace (at least in winter), lack of cars, rich history and close-knit community.

“My parents left for Mestre after getting married and had a vision of a brand new home, supermarkets and being able to use a car,” said Martina Cavagnis, who returned to the Canareggio area 20 years ago. “At the beginning people think these things are great, but then they start to miss the lagoon and the community.”


Angela Giuffrida in Venice

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Venice urges tourists to drink from water fountains

John Hooper: Visitors are to be handed an empty plastic bottle and a map locating 122 places they can fill up

John Hooper in Rome

03, Jun, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Supporters of Venice's planned new port put their faith in flood barrier

Harbour redevelopment scheme sparks fears among conservationists that it will leave city vulnerable to even more flooding

Sam Jones and Fiona Winward in Rome

07, Sep, 2009 @6:23 PM

Venice flood fails to damp down fight over sea walls

Worst floods since 1872 reinvigorate argument over defence of fragile sinking city

John Hooper in Rome

06, Dec, 2008 @12:01 AM

Article image
Benetton in row over palazzo shopping conversion in Venice
Clothing company facing resistance from Italian heritage experts over plans for historic Fondaco dei Tedeschi near Grand Canal

Tom Kington in Rome

13, Feb, 2012 @5:18 PM

Venice: perilous times | Editorial

Editorial: The situation for Venice is becoming critical because of the danger posed by the cruise ships


20, Mar, 2014 @10:07 PM

Article image
Venice pushes ahead with €10 entry fee plan as tourists flock back
Authorities hope charge for day-trippers will help control numbers after visitors hit pre-pandemic levels

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

19, Apr, 2022 @1:53 PM

Article image
Monsters or a must? Venice tussles with return of cruise ships
The arrival of the MSC Orchestra has rekindled tensions over the pros and cons of the giant vessels

Angela Giuffrida in Venice

14, Jun, 2021 @4:00 AM

Article image
Italy tourism minister attacks plans for Venice day-trippers charge
Gian Marco Centinaio says plan to charge visitors up to €10 is ‘useless and damaging’

Angela Giuffrida

05, Feb, 2019 @4:37 PM

Article image
Venice to charge day-trippers up to €10 to enter city
Mayor says tax will improve monitoring of tourist arrivals and help fund clean-up of litter

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

31, Dec, 2018 @4:40 PM

Article image
Battle with time: Italian towns face demise by depopulation
Small Sicilian villages reflect the shifting demographics of economic migration and declining birth rates

Lorenzo Tondo in Acquaviva Platani

12, Jul, 2019 @4:00 AM