Pacific leaders condemn Australia's 'weak' climate target in open letter to Scott Morrison

Fourteen eminent signatories urge Canberra to commit to net-zero emissions by 2050

Pacific leaders have condemned Australia’s Paris climate target as “one of the weakest”, urging Canberra to commit to net-zero carbon emissions by 2050 and abandon its Kyoto carryover credits.

Fourteen Pacific leaders, including former presidents and prime ministers, foreign ministers, archbishops and other church leaders, have penned an open leader to the prime minister, Scott Morrison, “as Pacific Islander leaders whose homelands and cultures face certain devastation from climate change”.

“Pacific island nations have long been leaders in driving global progress to combat climate change,” the letter says. “However, Australia’s current Paris Agreement emission reduction target remains one of the weakest among wealthy nations.”

Signatories included the former Kiribati president Anote Tong, the former Tuvalu prime minister Enele Sopoaga, the former Marshall Islands Hilda Heine, Vanuatu’s opposition leader, Ralph Regenvanu, and Cardinal Sir John Ribat, the Catholic Archbishop of Port Moresby.

The letter urges Australia to commit to net-zero emissions by 2050 and to develop a long-term low greenhouse gas emissions strategy by 2021. And it condemns Australia’s use of Kyoto protocol carryover credits, “which legally cannot, and morally should not, be used to meet Australia’s 2030 Paris Agreement target”.

“Australia needs the Pacific as much as the Pacific needs Australia,” it says. “As our children and grandchildren face unprecedented risks due to climate change, now is the time to stand together and work together to secure their future safety and prosperity.”

This Open Letter from high profile Pacific leaders urging @ScottMorrisonMP 2 take urgent climate action was published in the @smh this morning. Support the letter at https://t.co/3cf8J7wiMK. @Pacificcalling @peacifica @TheAusInstitute @OxfamAustralia @CANPacificIs @wtmpacific pic.twitter.com/AscuhcwTGD

— Edmund Rice Centre (@ERCAus) November 30, 2020

Australia was a signatory to the Pacific Islands Forum Boe declaration in 2018, which said climate change was the single greatest security threat to the Pacific.

But its climate position has consistently put it at odds with low-lying Pacific countries vulnerable to natural disasters, who have asked the Pacific grouping’s largest and most influential nation to do more.

Delayed by Covid-19, it is uncertain whether the Pacific Islands Forum leaders’ meeting will proceed this year, even virtually. These meetings have exposed the faultline between Australia and its Pacific neighbours over climate.

At last year’s forum, after a heated and protracted leaders’ meeting, Fiji’s prime minister, Frank Bainimarama, described Australia as “very insulting and condescending” in climate talks.

Australia has maintained the Pacific is “vuvale” – Fijian for family – and its “Pacific Step-Up” is assisting island nations in mitigation and adaptation, while working to cut emissions.

“Australia is successfully meeting our commitments and our targets and in fact we are exceeding them,” Morrison said this month. “But on top of that, dealing with climate change is also about building climate resilience for locked-in impacts … not just here in Australia, but in Pacific countries and that is where a big part of our support effort, some half a billion dollars, goes.”

Australia has established a $300m Covid-19 response package to assist with economic and social recovery in the Pacific region, and has also committed $80m to the Covax global alliance for vaccines to help south-east Asian and Pacific countries access a vaccine when one becomes available.

But in a submission to the government’s consultation on the Pacific Islands Forum 2050 strategy, the Australia Institute argues Australia “lacks ambition” in the Pacific, and is generally “reactive to changes in political balance and ... consistently parsimonious in extending development assistance”.

“Australia blows hot and cold and it is disappointing that domestic political fashion exerts more influence on South Pacific policy than do strategic considerations,” said Allan Behm, the director of the institute’s international and security affairs program.

“Complex challenges facing the South Pacific, including climate change, human security challenges of health and food security, population growth and economic opportunity, require more targeted engagement, assistance and leadership from Australia.”

The submission argues that climate change is the most critical challenge facing the Pacific region and will exacerbate other existing fragilities and stressors surrounding food security, political instability and governance challenges.

“Australia and New Zealand must go beyond adaptation and remediation by increasing the ambition of greenhouse gas emissions reduction efforts and to begin managed immigration of peoples in the most vulnerable Pacific states.”

Contributor

Ben Doherty Pacific Editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Coronavirus in the Pacific: weekly briefing
Covid-19-related developments throughout the Pacific Islands

Dan McGarry in Port Vila and Tess Newton Cain

23, Jun, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Coronavirus in the Pacific: weekly briefing
Covid-19-related developments throughout the Pacific Islands

Dan McGarry in Port Vila and Tess Newton Cain

30, Jun, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Q&A: former Tuvalu PM says Scott Morrison denies climate change is happening in Pacific
Special episode of the ABC show featuring Pacific leaders was dominated by climate crisis and Australia’s response

Kate Lyons

02, Dec, 2019 @8:36 PM

Article image
Australia should create ‘Pacific visa’ to reduce impact of climate change and disaster on islanders
Displacement is growing in the Asia-Pacific region, and a new policy paper argues migration policies must be established now

Ben Doherty Pacific Editor

21, Oct, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Pacific states face instability, hunger and slow road to Covid recovery: Dame Meg Taylor
While the worst of the Covid-19 pandemic has so far spared the Pacific, its economies are in free-fall, the region’s chief diplomat warns

Sheldon Chanel in Suva

10, Aug, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
We can't allow Pacific leaders to use coronavirus as a cover for authoritarianism | Dan McGarry and Tess Newton Cain
Lives and livelihoods must be the priorities for the region, not manufacturing an endless emergency

Dan McGarry in Port Vila and Tess Newton Cain

02, Aug, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
China’s foreign minister tells Pacific leaders ‘don’t be too anxious’ after they reject regional security pact
Several Pacific nations reportedly want to defer action on the draft agreement or have it amended

Kate Lyons and Reuters

30, May, 2022 @7:27 AM

Article image
Coronavirus in the Pacific: weekly briefing
Covid-19-related developments throughout the Pacific Islands

Dan McGarry in Port Vila and Tess Newton Cain

16, Jun, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Coronavirus in the Pacific: weekly briefing
Covid-19-related developments throughout the Pacific Islands

Dan McGarry in Port Vila and Tess Newton Cain

07, Jul, 2020 @10:00 PM

Article image
Serious defects discovered in patrol boats Australia supplied to Pacific Islands
Potentially serious faults in Guardian-class patrol boats may force some countries to pause use of vessels

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

30, Jun, 2022 @5:30 PM