Japan PM sparks anger with near-identical speeches in Hiroshima and Nagasaki

‘It’s the same every year. He talks gibberish and leaves,’ says one survivor after plagiarism app detects 93% match in speeches given days apart

Survivors of the atomic bombings of 75 years ago have accused Japan’s prime minister, Shinzo Abe, of making light of their concerns after he delivered two near-identical speeches to mark the anniversaries of the attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

A plagiarism detection app found that Abe’s speech in Nagasaki on Sunday duplicated 93% of a speech he had given in Hiroshima three days earlier, the Mainichi Shimbun reported.

The English-language versions of the speeches on Abe’s official website also show a high degree of duplication.

The opening paragraph mentions each city’s name, and continues: “I reverently express my sincere condolences to the souls of the great number of atomic bomb victims. I also extend my heartfelt sympathy to those still suffering even now from the after-effects of the atomic bomb.” Aside from the ceremony titles, the passages match word for word.

Abe did, however, use different wording when referring to how each city had rebuilt in the years after Japan’s wartime defeat.

An estimated 140,000 people died immediately and in the months after the Hiroshima bombing on 6 August 1945, while 74,000 died during and after the attack on Nagasaki three days later.

Apart from the cities’ names, the statements’ closing paragraphs used the same wording, with Abe voicing hope for a world “without nuclear weapons”.

The apparent decision not to tailor the statements to each city’s experience angered survivors of the bombings, who are known as hibakusha.

“It’s the same every year,” Koichi Kawano, head of a hibakusha liaison council in Nagasaki, told the Mainichi Shimbun. “He talks gibberish and leaves, as if to say, ‘There you go. Goodbye.’ He just changed the word ‘Hiroshima’ to ‘Nagasaki.’ He’s looking down on A-bomb survivors.”

Haruko Moritaki, the co-director of the Hiroshima Alliance for the Abolition of Nuclear Weapons, accused Abe of inaction on nuclear disarmament, despite acknowledging the advanced age of the hibakusha.

“[He] says he will stay ‘in tune’ with atomic bomb survivors, who are advancing in years, but he has not taken concrete action. He’s all talk and no action, and that showed in his addresses,” Moritaki told the newspaper.

Survivors used the anniversaries to urge Abe to push for nuclear disarmament while they are still alive. But Japan, which relies on the US nuclear umbrella for its security, has not signed a treaty to abolish nuclear weapons adopted by the UN general assembly in 2017.

Abe did not visit the Nagasaki atomic bomb museum at the weekend, despite being asked to do so when he met hibakusha representatives last year. One survivor quoted by local media wondered why Abe had bothered travelling “all the way to Nagasaki”.

In an editorial, the Asahi Shimbun noted Abe’s desire for a nuclear-free world, but added: “His actions toward the issue are only adding to a sense of frustration and anger among residents in the atomic-bombed cities.”

Criticism of the statements came as Japan’s government said it would appeal against a recent ruling awarding state health benefits to dozens of men and women who lived outside the areas hit hardest by the bombings but who were exposed to radioactive “black rain” caused by the explosions.

Contributor

Justin McCurry in Tokyo

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hiroshima atomic bomb: a simple toll of a bell signals the moment 80,000 died
Japan’s leaders join thousands on the 70th anniversary of the world’s first nuclear attack and warn the weapons must be abolished

Justin McCurry in Hiroshima

06, Aug, 2015 @5:16 AM

Article image
Harry Truman and the nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki | Letters
Letters: Daniel Snowman interviewed the former US president in 1963 and reveals what he was told. Frank Jackson thinks the bombing of Nagasaki was even more of a war crime

Letters

07, Aug, 2020 @3:31 PM

Article image
'To my last breath': survivors fight for memory of Hiroshima and Nagasaki
75 years after bombings, witnesses struggle to remind us of the horrors of nuclear weapons

Justin McCurry in Tokyo

06, Aug, 2020 @1:07 AM

Article image
A little deaf in one ear - meet the Japanese man who survived Hiroshima and Nagasaki

93-year-old becomes only known survivor of both attacks to win recognition from the Japanese authorities

Justin McCurry in Tokyo

25, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
Images of Hiroshima and Nagasaki | Rowena Loverance
Rowena Loverance: Face to faith: An exhibition at Friends House offers a chilling insight into the suffering wreaked by the A-bombs, 65 years on

Rowena Loverance

06, Aug, 2010 @4:54 PM

Article image
Japan recognises dozens more survivors of Hiroshima in landmark ruling
More than a dozen ‘black rain’ plaintiffs died during legal battle to prove people living further away also suffered radiation exposure in 1945

Justin McCurry in Tokyo and agencies

30, Jul, 2020 @4:03 AM

Article image
'We must never repeat the horrors of war': Japanese PM makes pledge at Pearl Harbor
In an historic moment, the Japanese prime minister stood next to Barack Obama at the USS Arizona Memorial and offered ‘everlasting condolences’

Jon Letman in Pearl Harbor

28, Dec, 2016 @7:33 AM

Article image
Japanese band sparks anger with Nazi-style Halloween costumes
Popular girl band Keyakizaka46 performs in outfits modelled on uniforms of Waffen-SS officers

Justin McCurry in Tokyo

01, Nov, 2016 @11:54 AM

Article image
Vladimir Putin's visit to Japan postponed indefinitely
Moscow’s hardline stance on disputed island group torpedoes bilateral talks with Japanese PM Shinzo Abe that were set for later this year

Justin McCurry in Tokyo

15, Oct, 2015 @9:43 AM

Article image
Hiroshima remembers the day the bomb dropped
The city fell silent as tens of thousands of people paid tribute to the victims and survivors of the world’s first atomic bomb

Justin McCurry in Hiroshima and agencies

06, Aug, 2015 @12:20 AM