Tech firms criticised for 'lack of answers' on Covid-19 disinformation

MPs say tech firms have failed to explain how they are tackling false information

MPs have berated leading tech firms for failing to answer questions about taking responsibility for disinformation in the coronavirus pandemic, accusing the companies of giving vague, preprepared answers.

Representatives from Facebook, Google and Twitter appeared in front of a Commons select committee but struggled to give satisfactory responses to politicians, who wanted to know what they were doing to combat issues such as false claims linking 5G to the pandemic.

In one unusual exchange, Facebook’s UK public policy manager, Richard Earley, was repeatedly asked by Labour’s Kevin Brennan about his seniority within the global Facebook team, and whether he had ever met the company’s founder, Mark Zuckerberg.

“I have seen him, I haven’t personally met him,” said Earley, who also said he had not met Nick Clegg, the former deputy prime minister who now works as Facebook’s global policy chief.

Zuckerberg has refused to appear in front of the digital, culture, media and sport select committee, resulting in a formal summons from parliament. The Facebook boss has ignored the demand without facing any punishment – and has since stayed away from the UK – although Earley insisted the company took the work of the committee seriously.

Earley was criticised for not being able to confirm the number of content moderators the firm currently had reviewing explicit material. He said Facebook had taken steps to “minimise any negative impact on our ability to review content” during the pandemic, including moving responsibility for the most serious content review subjects – such as child abuse material and self-harm content – to its available full-time employees, and putting in place systems that allowed other contracted moderators to work from home.

“We’ve also had a large number of employees who don’t even review content in their daily roles volunteering to step forward and help make sure we did not see significant negative impacts on that queue,” he said.

But when pressed by the committee on whether Facebook had the same number of moderators working as before the pandemic, or fewer, Earley said he was unable to answer because the situation was changing each day.

Twitter’s UK head of government, public policy and philanthropy, Katy Minshall, was asked directly whether she would be removing potentially damaging tweets by Donald Trump.

“We have taken action on tweets that break our rules, that absolutely includes world leaders. If any tweet breaks the rules, we will take appropriate action,” she said.

Asked again if Twitter had ever reduced the reach of Trump’s tweets, Minshall said the company had taken action against other world leaders and was willing to mark politicians’ tweets as potentially harmful if they overstepped the mark.

“I didn’t actually detect an answer there,” said the committee chairman, Julian Knight.

Earlier in the hearing Stacie Hoffmann, a cybersecurity expert from Oxford Information Labs, a cyberintelligence company, said the coronavirus pandemic showed that social networks were capable of removing damaging content when they really wanted to.

She suggested this exposed the flaw in their previous focus on finding technical solutions to removing material: “They didn’t want to talk about human content moderation.”

Knight said all of the representatives had failed to provide “genuine, hard information on how you are specifically going about tackling Covid disinformation”, meaning his committee would be asking them to provide further evidence in writing.

“We will be writing to all the organisations and frankly we will be expressing our displeasure at the quality of the answers – well, a lack of answers – that we’ve received today and will be seeking further clarity,” he said.


Jim Waterson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Tech giants join with governments to fight Covid misinformation
Facebook, Twitter and Google part of working group targeting false claims about vaccines

Alex Hern Technology editor

20, Nov, 2020 @3:16 PM

Article image
Top tech firms avoid encryption issue in government talks
Executives commit to removing extremist material but do not address Amber Rudd’s concerns after Westminster attack

Peter Walker Political correspondent

30, Mar, 2017 @7:18 PM

Article image
Tech giants struggle to stem 'infodemic' of false coronavirus claims
Critics say efforts are too little, too late as research reveals vast majority of false claims appear online

Julia Carrie Wong

10, Apr, 2020 @8:46 AM

Article image
Facebook sees the Lite

The social networking site hit the headlines with its $50m FriendFeed deal – but does its new slimmed-down version hint at its global ambitions?

Bobbie Johnson

19, Aug, 2009 @5:30 PM

Article image
The ultimate internet glossary: from 4chan to Zynga
Know your lolz from your lulzsec, and your belfies from your selfies? Hannah Jane Parkinson is here to help with an almost definitive list of digital geekery

Hannah Jane Parkinson

11, Sep, 2014 @11:00 PM

Article image
Social media firms must face heavy fines over extremist content – MPs
An inquiry by the Commons home affairs committee condemns technology companies for failing to tackle hate speech

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

01, May, 2017 @5:01 AM

Article image
EU: data-harvesting tech firms are 'sweatshops of connected world'
Data protection supervisor lambasts companies’ deluge of ‘take it or leave it’ privacy emails ahead of GDPR

Samuel Gibbs

02, May, 2018 @10:04 AM

Article image
Amber Rudd's 'showdown' talks with tech firms on extremism are pure PR
Meetings between UK government and Facebook et al are more ritual than battle as they avoid subjects both parties disagree on, such as tax and user privacy

Alex Hern

31, Mar, 2017 @8:24 AM

Article image
WhatsApp to impose new limit on forwarding to fight fake news
Restrictions on ‘frequently forwarded’ messages intended to disrupt false Covid-19 claims

Alex Hern UK technology editor

07, Apr, 2020 @7:00 AM

Article image
Nearly one in six Britons would refuse Covid-19 vaccine – survey
Campaigners say social media firms behaving irresponsibly over anti-vaccine material

Alex Hern UK technology editor

06, Jul, 2020 @11:01 PM