Pregnancy and the Covid-19 frontline | Letters

Pregnant healthcare workers must be able to choose whether to work or not, writes Dr Marion Campbell, while Sarah Brown says that the government is failing to protect key workers like her daughter

Your article describes the tragic death from Covid-19 of a pregnant NHS nurse (Pregnant nurse’s death adds to concern among health workers, 15 April). You quote guidance from the Royal College of Obstetrics and Gynaecology which states that “women who are less than 28 weeks pregnant can continue in non-Covid patient-facing roles if necessary precautions are taken”. You omit to say that the RCOG strongly emphasises that the choice to continue working in any patient-facing role rests with the woman and that this choice should be respected by employers. If women are being coerced into working, the failure is with the trusts and health boards, not the RCOG guidance.

Despite this tragic death, there is no evidence that women below 28 weeks gestation are at increased risk of infection and death. The current guidance from the RCOG allows pregnant women the choice to work or not. To introduce a blanket ban on pregnant women working in patient-facing roles would be a decision based on fear and emotion, not rationality.

I am a consultant in emergency medicine and I am 25 weeks pregnant. I continue to work in the emergency department, in a section reserved for low-risk patients. I would prefer us to apply evidence-based medicine to all aspects of this crisis rather than to regress to Trump-style paternalism and science scepticism.
Dr Marion Campbell
Consultant in emergency medicine, NHS Lanarkshire

• On Thursday evenings, I am deeply moved by the clamour of public support for our key workers and also instantaneously grief-stricken. My daughter is a frontline doctor with inadequate personal protective equipment. Her wife is also a doctor and pregnant. My daughter has been sleeping and living in the garage because she is frightened she might pass on the virus to her pregnant wife and their two-year-old child.

We are banging pots, but why are we not clamouring for personal protective equipment for our key workers? Why is it they are made to feel like cannon fodder or frightened they might cause the deaths of those they love most?

Your report (Government ‘ignores’ UK textiles firms desperate to make PPE, 16 April) demonstrates what we have repeatedly observed – that this government fails to act when help is offered.
Sarah Brown
Brighton, East Sussex

Letters

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Dispatches from the Covid-19 frontline
Letters: Readers and members of the medical profession share their reflections on how the UK is handling the coronavirus outbreak

Letters

25, Mar, 2020 @7:27 PM

Article image
What a public inquiry into Covid must cover | Letters
Letters: Wendy Savage sheds light on a people’s inquiry that is already under way, plus letters by Neil Hornsby, Dr Richard Carter and Alan Marsden

Letters

19, Mar, 2021 @3:58 PM

Article image
Single-use plastic’s life-saving role | Brief letters
Brief letters: Doctors volunteering in Scotland | Funny female writers | Disinfecting streets | How Boris Johnson can thank nurses | Single-use plastic

Letters

13, Apr, 2020 @5:14 PM

Article image
We need to protect all frontline workers
Letters: A mental health support worker on looking after patients without proper PPE and two parents concerned for their social worker and care worker children. Plus Will Gelson asks us to remember all healthcare professionals putting their lives at risk

Letters

05, Apr, 2020 @5:14 PM

Article image
All’s not fair in Covid vaccination strategy
Letters: Readers on the inequality, logistical problems and north-south divide in the distribution of vaccines

Letters

24, Jan, 2021 @5:18 PM

Article image
It’s imperative to keep Covid in the headlines | Letters
Letters: Alan Walker calls on the media to keep the death toll in the public eye as the pandemic is not over, Marcia Heinemann is relieved that the official symptom list has been expanded and Jonathan Hauxwell is concerned about the lack of free tests

Letters

05, Apr, 2022 @4:45 PM

Article image
Labyrinthine Covid booster system is the real reason for delays | Letters
Letters: Guardian readers share their frustrations at trying to obtain a third coronavirus vaccination

Letters

03, Nov, 2021 @5:48 PM

Article image
BAME Covid-19 deaths demand a broader inquiry | Letters
Letters: Jabeer Butt of the Race Equality Foundation fears obfuscation rather than action, while GP and clinical lecturer Dr Grace Okoli says talking about vitamin D levels distracts from the real issues. Plus a letter from Dr Tony Rao

Letters

20, Apr, 2020 @4:18 PM

Article image
A Covid Christmas and the price of life | Letters
Letters: Dr Hazel Chipchase on the care she received from stressed NHS staff, Dr Michael Peel on putting a price on lives. Plus John Yates and Ron Brewer on the coronavirus Christmas problem

Letters

23, Nov, 2020 @5:50 PM

Article image
Government failures still hamper our Covid-19 response | Letters
Letters: Prof Sarah Gilbert on the lack of pandemic preparedness, Sarah Woolnough on the dearth of support for those struggling with long Covid, and Catherine Tann and Brian Clarke on the missing lateral flow tests

Letters

27, Jun, 2021 @3:02 PM