Russia criticised for 'dumping' trapped whales at sea

Greenpeace criticises long-awaited operation, saying it risked trauma or death for the animals

Russia’s long-awaited operation to release the first batch of whales held in cramped enclosures in the country’s far-east region was dangerously flawed, environmentalists have said.

The animals – 11 orcas and 87 beluga whales – have been held in captivity in a bay near the port city of Nakhodka since last year. They were due to be sold to Chinese oceanariums, before images of the animals languishing in the “whale prison” caused an international outcry.

Vladimir Putin last week hailed Russia’s moves to return the whales to the wild. However, Greenpeace Russia said the two orcas and six beluga whales were simply dumped into the Sea of Okhotsk on Thursday after being transported 1,100 miles by truck and then boat to their natural habitat. The journey took seven days and the whales were held in small containers the entire time.

The decision to free the animals came after a visit to their pens in April by Jean-Michel Cousteau, an oceanographer and son of the late marine expert Jacques Cousteau. Yet despite promises by Russian officials that Cousteau’s team of maritime experts would be involved in their release, no international or independent scientists were invited to take part. Cousteau had recommended that the whales be transported only by sea.

Greenpeace said no attempt was made to prepare the whales for their return to the wild, seriously raising the risk of trauma or death for the animals. It also said that the entire operation was carried out in secrecy.

“It’s cruel to release orcs and beluga whales who have spent seven days in these containers straight into the sea,” Oganes Targulyan, a Greenpeace expert, told Russian media. “They weren’t released, but dumped [into the sea].”

Russian officials said the operation had been successful, and that none of the whales suffered during the journey. Nine orcas and 81 beluga whales remain in captivity. They will be freed in batches over the next four months.

A court in Russia’s far east this month ordered a number of companies to pay fines totaling 150.2m roubles (£1.8m) for their roles in the “whale prison”. But according to documents published on Russia’s state procurement website, the same companies were also hired by the state fisheries and oceanography institute to release the whales. They stand to earn more than 360m roubles in total.


Marc Bennetts in Moscow

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Russia urged to halt oil survey during rare whale's breeding season
Seismic survey planned around Sakhalin island would affect a fragile population of western grey whales, marine experts warn

David Adam, environment correspondent

14, Jul, 2010 @3:32 PM

Article image
Beluga whale that strayed into River Seine dies during rescue operation
Whale had been lifted out of river as part of ambitious attempt to return it to sea

Angelique Chrisafis in Paris

10, Aug, 2022 @9:49 AM

Article image
Pathologist finds €500,000 ‘floating gold’ in dead whale in Canary Islands
Team hope sale of block of rare ambergris, used by perfumers, will help victims of 2021 La Palma volcano

Stephen Burgen in Barcelona

04, Jul, 2023 @2:28 PM

Article image
Greenpeace 'Tokyo Two' anti-whaling activists found guilty

Junichi Sato and Toru Suzuki have both been found guilty of theft and trespass after intercepting a box of whale meat

Justin McCurry in Tokyo

06, Sep, 2010 @9:44 AM

Article image
Drew Barrymore saves the whales and melts cold war ice in Big Miracle

Hollywood fictionalises the story of Cindy Lowry, who persuaded the Americans and Russians to free trapped whales in Alaska

John Vidal, environment editor

09, Feb, 2012 @1:12 PM

Article image
Beached whales become food for Indonesian islanders
Locals make use of meat from 40 pilot whales that have been stranded on Sabu island

Kate Hodal in Bangkok and agencies

03, Oct, 2012 @10:08 AM

Full text of the letter on seismic surveys and the impact on whales

A joint letter to Russia calling for the postponement of a controversial search for oil and gas because of the potential impact on endangered whales

14, Jul, 2010 @3:32 PM

Article image
More than 140 pilot whales die in 'heartbreaking' New Zealand stranding
A hiker camping in remote Stewart Island alerted authorities to the discovery

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

26, Nov, 2018 @1:11 AM

Article image
Whale meat on the menu as Japanese suppliers enlist influencers
With the domestic market in long-term decline, whalers and restaurants are working with the Japan travel bureau in a bid to win over skeptical visitors

Justin McCurry in Osaka

23, Mar, 2023 @12:59 PM

Article image
Hundreds of whales die in mass stranding on New Zealand beach
Urgent plea issued for locals to drop work and school commitments and head to the remote beach to save surviving whales

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

10, Feb, 2017 @3:52 AM