Better transport options are key to driving us out of our cars | Letters

Readers on the lack of viable alternatives to cars, especially outside London

George Monbiot stirred up a hornet’s nest with his article about the end of the car (Cars choke the life out of our cities. We must scrap them now, Journal, 21 June). While most people now have a car, about 20% of families don’t, and the poorest quartile households use taxis most. To get people to use cars less needs an acceptable alternative. Most journeys are short: 50% under 3 miles and 70% under 5 miles. For those able to, walking and cycling are as fast, or faster if parking is considered, but people are walking less and hardly cycling because our urban roads are seen to be dangerous.

There are places that have halved urban car trips from 70% as in the UK, and upped cycling from 3% to 25%. Such places have maintained their electric trams, which are used for 30% of trips. The rest are walked. Such places have much less traffic, virtually no congestion, low pollution and fitter populations. While fuel duty is a significant revenue for the government more sustainable or active means of travel will have only symbolic investment and the NHS will continue to spend about a fifth of its budget treating traffic pollution-related illnesses.

Incidentally, EM Forster envisaged a car-less future in The Machine Stops. Is this what George Monbiot seeks?
Professor LJS Lesley
President, Merseyside Cycling Campaign, Liverpool

• Further to the correspondence on moving away from car use (Letters, 24 June), perhaps a tiny step forward may be made by developing local dial-and-ride bus services such as those recently reported by Max Planck Research. The crucial developments in this example seem to be that the routes are determined by where people wish to go to, and it is integrated into transport networks. As this example from Germany shows, “you are the bus stop” seems to result in an increase in passenger numbers.

If the home of the European car industry can come up with such innovation, maybe some imagination is needed to do more with what we have.
Roland Pascoe
Chair, The Resilience Foundation

• I’m delighted John Crace (Digested week, 22 June) may be about to join the 46% of London households who don’t own a car. He’ll soon find that you don’t need one in London, especially if you have a bicycle, a car club membership or a Freedom Pass. But let’s not forget those outside London, for whom deregulation seems to have made public transport fragmented and unaffordable. If the government is serious about cleaning up the planet, decent public transport outside London has to become a priority.
Fiona Monroe

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Emissions charge in London is a blunt instrument | Letters
New pollution charges for motorists in London should not be based on a vehicle’s age, argues David Lawrence, while Judith Hanna thinks the Tories are playing politics with the issue


13, Jan, 2019 @5:53 PM

Article image
Will we all have to be forced out of our cars? | Letters
Letters: George Monbiot’s ideas about car use are criticised Charles Foster but applauded by Rosie Harvie, Derek Heptinstall and Duncan Roberts, as Angela Matthews asks how London’s car-free day will affect disabled people and Graham Vidler looks at putting buses first


23, Jun, 2019 @5:24 PM

Article image
Air pollution sickens us in a car-addicted society | Letters
Letters: Readers join the dots between various recent reports on the effects of air pollution on human health and the part played by cars in turning the atmosphere toxic


20, Sep, 2018 @4:58 PM

Article image
Environmental warnings should stop drivers taking the road to ruin | Letters
Letters: Matt Wheeler, Chris Osman, Pam Laurance and Bill White on the changes that need to be made to road regulations and driver habits in order to avoid climate catastrophe


09, Oct, 2018 @5:28 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on low-emission zones: the UK must clean up its act | Editorial
Editorial: Schemes to cut air pollution in cities not only save lives, but show how environmental regulation can be done


23, Sep, 2021 @5:44 PM

Article image
Cars are reaching the end of the road | Letters
Letters: The decline in the UK of young people taking to the wheel is encouraging, says Bruce Ross-Smith, cars are blighting everything, says Susan Woodford, and David Halley sees an urgent need to get rid of them


10, Mar, 2019 @6:09 PM

Article image
With political will, we could easily solve our transport problems | Letters
Letters: Readers share their thoughts on electricity generation, cars, cycling, trains and garden cities


04, Aug, 2017 @5:22 PM

Article image
London should lead in showing electric cars will not tackle air pollution
The government’s new strategy does not do enough in recognising that fewer vehicles, not just cleaner ones, are the answer

Frank Kelly

04, Aug, 2017 @11:10 AM

Article image
Electric trains offer the best route to greener transport
Letters: Rob Harris on why electric lorries are not the answer, and Prof LJS Lesley on the benefits of electrifying the rail network. Plus Graham Larkbey laments the neglect of an England-Wales border station


29, Jul, 2021 @5:15 PM

Article image
Banning cars alone is not the answer | Letters
Letters: Christian Vassie and Rachel White shed light on how York is tackling the climate emergency, while Dick Follows believes city centres should be freed from the tyranny of cars


07, Jan, 2020 @6:22 PM