UN criticises Rohingya deal between Myanmar and Bangladesh

Conditions in Rakhine state ‘not yet conducive’ for return of refugees, says UNHCR

UN officials have condemned a deal struck between Myanmar and Bangladesh to start repatriating Rohingya refugees, with the UN refugee agency confirming they have not been consulted about the plan.

Bangladesh and Myanmar government officials announced this week they had struck a “very concrete” repatriation deal for the return of the 720,000 Rohingya refugees who fled a brutal military crackdown in August 2017, which would begin by “mid-November”.

Myanmar officials said on Wednesday they had verified 5,000 Rohingya refugees so far, with the “first batch” of 2,000 to be repatriated in the next month.

However, Stéphane Dujarric, a spokesman for the UN secretary general, António Guterres, said the deal had taken the UN high commissioner for refugees (UNHCR) by surprise.

“To be clear … UNHCR, which is in lead on the issues of refugees, was not consulted on this matter,” said Dujarric at the daily press briefing given by the secretary general’s office.

Chris Melzer, the UNHCR’s senior external officer based in Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh, reiterated this, saying: “UNHCR was not a party to that agreement.

“We would advise against imposing any timetable or target figures for repatriation in respect of the voluntary nature and sustainability of return,” added Melzer. “It is unclear if refugees know their names are on this list that has been cleared by Myanmar. They need to be informed. They also need to be consulted if they are willing to return ... It is critical that returns are not rushed or premature.”

Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya have been living in cramped refugee camps in Cox’s Bazar for more than a year after fleeing rape, murder and arson in Rakhine state at the hands of the Myanmar military.

The Myanmar government signed an agreement with the UNHCR in June that they would work with the UN to create “safe and dignified” conditions for the return of the Rohingya to Rakhine, including guaranteeing security, freedom of movement and pathway to citizenship. None of these assurances have been made by the Myanmar government so far and the UNHCR has only been given restricted access to Rakhine state.

“For UNHCR, the conditions in Rakhine state are not yet conducive for a return to Myanmar,” said Dujarric. “And, at the same time, we’re seeing Rohingya refugees continue to arrive from Rakhine state into [Bangladesh], which should give you an indication of the situation on the ground.”

Bangladesh has handed Myanmar a list of 24,342 refugees whom they have cleared for repatriation, but details of the logistics and precise date of the repatriation are unclear. The issue of consent and possible forced repatriation has also been raised, with Rohingya in Cox’s Bazar saying they were fearful of going back and had never been asked whether they wanted to return.

Myanmar officials, including Myint Thu, the permanent secretary at Myanmar’s ministry of foreign affairs, visited the camps in Cox’s Bazar on Wednesday and were greeted by hundreds of Rohingya protestors who held placards demanding citizenship and security. “We are here to meet with the people from the camps so that I can explain what we have prepared for their return and then I can listen to their voices,” said Myint Thu.

Safiullah, who like many other Rohingya uses one name, was among the refugees who met the Burmese members of the Bangladesh-Myanmar joint working group at Kutupalong refugee camp on Wednesday.

“The Burmese officials said to us that around 4,600 Rohingya refugees would be taken to Myanmar,” said Safiullah. “The first bunch, around 2,300, would be allowed to return now. The remaining half would return at a later stage, they told me. The returnees have to spend three days in a transit camp inside Rakhine before they are taken to another camp which will be their new home.”

He had asked whether the Rohingya would be able to return to their own villages and get back their confiscated land and other properties but “the Burmese officials did not give me an answer”.

“I will not return to Myanmar even if the authorities enlist me for repatriation. I am sure this is the view of almost all Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh,” he said.

Some observers have described the announcement as politically motivated by the prime minister of Bangladesh, Sheikh Hasina, ahead of the general election which will be held at the end of December. While Bangladesh initially welcomed the refugees fleeing the military crackdown, a year on their presence has become a politically contentious issue, and there is increasing pressure on Hasina to start their repatriation as soon as possible.

Suktara Begum, a Rohingya refugee woman who spoke to Myint Thu on his visit to the camps, said: “They came to meet us today simply because of pressure from the international community. They have not taken one step to meet our demands in so many months. They are not serious about our return to our homes. We do not trust them.”


Hannah Ellis-Petersen and Shaikh Azizur Rahman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Bangladesh admits no Rohingya willing to take repatriation offer
Buses standing ready to return refugees to Myanmar but no one is willing to board

Hannah Ellis-Petersen, Shaikh Azizur Rahman and Michael Safi

15, Nov, 2018 @1:40 PM

Article image
Rohingya refugees turn down second Myanmar repatriation effort
Bangladeshi official says potential returnees fear for their safety in Rakhine state

Hannah Ellis-Petersen and Shaikh Azizur Rahman

22, Aug, 2019 @4:49 PM

Article image
Rohingya crisis: Bangladesh says it will not accept any more Myanmar refugees
Foreign secretary tells UN the country paying the price for ‘showing empathy to a persecuted minority’

Hannah Ellis-Petersen South-east Asia correspondent

01, Mar, 2019 @6:19 AM

Article image
Bangladesh calls on Myanmar to take back Rohingya refugees
Prime minister Sheikh Hasina condemns crackdown during visit to one of the camps where 370,000 people have taken refuge

Michael Safi in Delhi

12, Sep, 2017 @2:00 PM

Article image
Bangladesh army arrives in Rohingya refugee camps as repatriations loom
Presence of army, police and paramilitary is latest sign that repatriations to Myanmar may not be voluntary

Hannah Ellis-Petersen, Michael Safi and Shaikh Azizur Rahman

14, Nov, 2018 @6:20 AM

Article image
Myanmar blocks all UN aid to civilians at heart of Rohingya crisis
Exclusive: Military offensive against insurgents leaves thousands stranded without life-saving supplies

Oliver Holmes in Balukhali, Bangladesh

04, Sep, 2017 @2:32 PM

Article image
Start of rainy season exposes risks for Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh
Further downpours at Cox’s Bazar could leave refugees from Myanmar at risk of diseases, infections and mudslides

Hannah Ellis-Petersen, and Kaamil Ahmed in Cox's Bazar

18, Apr, 2018 @3:26 PM

Article image
'There is no peace': traumatised Rohingya vow they won't go back to Myanmar
Efforts to send Rohingya back over the border are foundering before they have even begun

Ben Doherty in Moinerghona refugee camp, Bangladesh

29, Jan, 2018 @5:00 PM

Article image
Myanmar and UN announce deal for return of Rohingya
Refugees in Bangladesh who fled violence at hands of the military express concerns over details of the plan

Hannah Ellis-Petersen South-east Asia correspondent

01, Jun, 2018 @12:17 AM

Article image
UN security council overwhelmed by suffering at Rohingya camps
Delegation visiting refugee camps in Bangladesh hear pleas for action by the UN and involvement of the international criminal court

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

29, Apr, 2018 @5:17 PM