Republicans more likely to view Muslim Americans negatively, study finds

Thinktank New America found 71% of Republicans surveyed said they don’t believe Islam is compatible with US values

While most non-Muslims in the US are accepting of Muslim Americans, Republicans are far more likely to have potentially negative views about them, according to data released Thursday.

New America, a thinktank working with the American Muslim Institution, conducted 1,165 interviews in four metropolitan areas prior to the 6 November midterm elections.

Perceptions of Muslims in America are especially prescient in advance of an election cycle that has highlighted racial, religious and economic divides. Donald Trump has capitalized on anti-Muslim sentiment to rally segments of his base which oppose immigration – most flagrantly with his travel ban from several majority Muslim nations.

Trump also recently referred to a US-bound caravan of migrants as an “invasion” – making flimsy, unproved claims that “Middle Easterners” were among them.

The results provide mixed signals into these perceptions.

“Political ideology” – to be specific, describing oneself as a Republican – “is the strongest indicator of negative attitudes toward Muslim Americans”, according to these researchers.

Sign up for the new US morning briefing

Seventy-one percent of self-described Republicans agreed they don’t believe Islam is compatible with American values, compared to an overall 42%.

Sixty percent agreed with the idea that Muslim Americans weren’t as patriotic as non-Muslim Americans, compared to 38% generally.

Fifty-six per cent of Republicans surveyed agreed they’d be concerned if a mosque or Islamic center were constructed in their neighborhood, compared to an overall level of 33%.

And slightly more than half – 53% – disagree that the influx of Muslim candidates for public office is positive for America, compared to 31% of the entire response pool.

But overall 85% of non-Muslim Americans agreed “diversity is a good thing for America”, the survey found.

About the same amount “believe their fellow Muslim citizens contribute positively to the US economy and to society”.

Some 66% of participants also told surveyors that it’s a “positive sign of progress for our country that over 100 Muslim Americans ran for public office in the 2018 election cycle”.

The same pool of respondents nonetheless expressed concerns about Muslims’ place in America.

About 60% said Muslim Americans were equally patriotic to non-Muslim Americans – meaning some 40% did not, surveyors said.

More than 50% said they were concerned about the spread of Islamic extremism in America.

Despite the professed support of diversity, about one third of survey-takers reported “feeling uncomfortable when they see Muslim Americans wearing a veil”.

The same amount of participants also agreed they “would be concerned if a mosque or Islamic center was built in their neighborhood, and believe Muslims should be subject to extra security screenings at airports”.

Non-Muslim Americans, when pressed to offer a guess, said they believe 60% of Muslim Americans want to assimilate with American society “or have respect for American laws” – meaning a “significant minority [is] assumed to lack these feelings”, surveyors claimed.

Non-Muslim Americans also overestimate the number of Muslim Americans in the US, data shows.

While non-Muslim Americans think 16% of the populace is Muslim, only about 1% of the US population actually identifies with the religion.

The belief is especially prominent among respondents with “less income, less education and who consume no news”, surveyors said.

The survey, which was conducted before a an antisemitic gunman killed 11 worshipers in a Pittsburgh synagogue on Saturday, also found that few Americans thought there was a lot of antisemitic discrimination.

Seventy-one per cent of non-Muslim Americans surveyed agreed Muslim Americans endured a lot of discrimination – at nearly the same levels experienced by African American and transgender individuals.

“Relative to other minority groups, only one-third agree there is a lot of discrimination against Jews in America,” the survey found.

Robert McKenzie, survey director and senior fellow at New America, said he was interested in determining “if we could quantify anti-Muslim attitudes at the state and local level”.

“The survey is the first step to better understand why people have these fears,” he said.


Victoria Bekiempis

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

The Right Word: Republicans resurgent | Sadhbh Walshe

Sadhbh Walshe: Fox News pundits have their tails up as the new year ushers in GOP control of the House of Representatives

Sadhbh Walshe

05, Jan, 2011 @4:17 PM

Article image
As an American Muslim, I'm not scared by Donald Trump. I'm inspired to vote | Moustafa Bayoumi
The Republican nominee’s campaign traffics in threats, including Islamophobia. But the US is a diverse society now – and mobilising to oppose radical haters

Moustafa Bayoumi

10, May, 2016 @3:52 PM

Article image
Republicans need to learn that Muslim and American are not mutually exclusive | Linda Sarsour
Linda Sarsour: Texas legislator Molly White joined some more famous conservatives in the ‘Super Bowl of Bigotry’ this week, vying for the title of Biggest Islamophobe

Linda Sarsour

30, Jan, 2015 @3:10 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on political rage: what prospect for the old norms? | Editorial
Editorial: Donald Trump’s attack on the Khan family has set a new low in the way politicians campaign. It is a reminder of the fragility of taboos


01, Aug, 2016 @7:04 PM

Article image
Why Obama is a 'Muslim': Republicans and symbolic belief | Harry J Enten

Harry J Enten: It's not just southerners. Republicans all over seem willing to believe President Obama is a Muslim. Why? In a word: ideology

Harry J Enten

20, Mar, 2012 @5:40 PM

Article image
Most Republicans think west and Islam are in fundamental conflict, poll finds

Most Americans reject view of a clash of cultures that can only have one winner, but two-thirds of Republicans support it

Tom Clark

26, Sep, 2012 @4:10 PM

Article image
Obama takes on Trump: 'Are we going to start treating all Muslim Americans differently?'
President makes strongest rebuke of ‘loose talk’ after Orlando attack as Hillary Clinton paints rival as ‘conspiracy theorist’

Dan Roberts and Sabrina Siddiqui in Washington and Lauren Gambino in Pittsburgh

14, Jun, 2016 @6:15 PM

Article image
The Muslim Americans leading the push to 'stand up and be leaders' in politics
Religious discrimination and an increase in hate crimes has spurred more Muslims to run for office and adopt an active role in community organizing

Sabrina Siddiqui and Oliver Laughland

04, Aug, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
FBI's pre-election sweep of Muslim Americans raises surveillance fears
Council of American Islamic Relations received about 100 reports of FBI agents visiting homes before Trump’s win, asking about personal details and al-Qaida

Mazin Sidahmed

16, Jan, 2017 @4:23 PM

Article image
Americans with lower incomes more worried about coronavirus, study finds
People who made less than $50,000 per year were 10 percentage points more concerned about threat posed by infectious disease

Amanda Holpuch

13, Apr, 2020 @4:27 PM