Spain: Ciudadanos leader urges snap election to resolve ‘institutional crisis’

Albert Rivera says Rajoy government is ‘over’ after his party’s corruption conviction

Spain’s centre-right Ciudadanos party has warned the prime minister, Mariano Rajoy, that his party’s recent corruption conviction has fatally wounded the government and plunged the country into an “institutional crisis” that can be resolved only through a snap general election.

Speaking to the Guardian as Rajoy prepares to face a no-confidence debate on Thursday and Friday, the Ciudadanos leader, Albert Rivera, said the government was “over and done with”.

Last week, Spain’s highest criminal court found the governing People’s party (PP) had benefited from a long-running illegal kickbacks-for-contracts scheme involving one its former treasurers and ordered it to pay a €240,000 fine.

“This is the first time in Spanish democracy that a governing party has been convicted of corruption and that’s why we think this legislature is done for,” said Rivera.

“It’s a tremendous blow to the PP and to Rajoy, it’s done for the legislature and opened up an institutional crisis that can only be solved by letting Spaniards have their say by calling early elections.”

Rivera said the prime minister’s situation was “untenable”, adding: “Rajoy needs to stop denying reality and admit this government has run its course to avoid any further damage to Spain.”

Despite the strong language, however, Ciudadanos is so far refusing to support the no-confidence motion, which was proposed by the Spanish socialist party (PSOE).

The motion is being backed by the anti-austerity Podemos party but is likely to struggle to attract majority support in parliament even if Basque and Catalan nationalist parties throw their weight behind it.

Rivera, whose party is implacably opposed to Catalan independence, said he and his fellow Ciudadanos MPs would never back a motion involving “populists and nationalists”.

He also said that the PSOE leader, Pedro Sánchez, was intent on governing even though the socialists have only 84 of the 350 MPs in congress.

If Rajoy failed to call an immediate election, said Rivera, Ciudadanos would propose an instrumental motion that would see an “independent candidate” dissolve parliament and call new polls after obtaining final approval for Spain’s 2018 budget.

The Spanish prime minister, Mariano Rajoy
The Spanish prime minister, Mariano Rajoy, attends parliament in Madrid before the assembly debates a no-confidence motion against his government. Photograph: Pierre-Philippe Marcou/AFP/Getty Images

But such a move could prove tricky without the backing of another party as Ciudadanos has only 32 MPs – three short of the 35 needed to propose such a motion.

There was speculation on Wednesday morning that Ciudadanos could yet support the PSOE’s no-confidence motion provided Sánchez announce a possible election date during the debate.

Recent opinion polls suggest that Rivera’s party, which was founded in Barcelona in 2006, would finish first in a general election, ahead of the PP, the PSOE and Podemos.

Ciudadanos and Podemos’s performance in the 2015 general elections ended decades of two-party domination. Since then, the anti-austerity grouping has begun to stall, while Rivera’s party has gained momentum.

Cuidadanos took the most seats and largest share of the vote in last December’s Catalan regional election even though the three pro-independence parties retained their majority.

Rivera’s party fought an aggressively unionist campaign in Catalonia and has criticised Rajoy for failing to do more to prevent and tackle the independence crisis.

Ciudadanos’s critics argue that it deliberately sought to outflank the PP on the right, accusing it of cynically abandoning its liberal foundations for electoral gain and showing its true, rightwing colours.

The accusations get short shrift from Rivera.

“We won the Catalan elections by taking votes from the PP, from the PSOE and from everyone,” he said.

“That opinion comes from within the political bubble – especially from Podemos and from some within the PSOE. They’re the ones who gave up their country and its symbols, and a lot of people on the left – and within the PSOE – are now congratulating us, saying, ‘It was about time that Spain stopped belonging to the right, it should be something that all parties can use’.”

Rivera, whose recent speeches have sought to prioritise the idea of unity and Spanishness over traditional party politics, says that patriotic pride has been the exclusive domain of the right for too long.

“That’s one of the mistakes that’s been made here: confusing Spain with the right. Spain is everyone: it’s us liberals, the socialists, the conservatives. I think that because of our past, because of the dictatorship and the ‘black Spain’, we’ve disowned all that.”

According to Rivera, the looming confrontation in Spain – as elsewhere in Europe and beyond – is one between inclusive, outward-looking parties and nationalists.

“I think we’re seeing a wave of worldwide change: the intellectual, political battle isn’t between socialists and conservatives any more, it’s between a European, pro-globalisation liberalism and the populists and nationalists,” he said.

“We’re engaged in a debate of pro-globalisation and anti-globalisation; protectionism and free trade. It’s a debate that pits patriotism – in civil terms such as equality, citizenship and openness – against exclusive nationalism.”

As a Catalan, much of Rivera’s ire is reserved for Quim Torra, the region’s new, hardline nationalist president, whose history of anti-Spanish remarks has come back to haunt him since he assumed office.

But the Ciudadanos leader rejects suggestions that appealing to Spaniards’ patriotism could prove a dangerous strategy given that the line between patriotism and nationalism can be a thin one.

“It’s like mixing up oil and water; they’re incompatible,” he said. “Torra believes that Spanish people are inferior; I believe we are all equal under the law. One of those is nationalism and the other is patriotism. Catalan nationalism wants to separate people into first- and second-class citizens: Catalans and the rest of the Spanish. I’m Catalan and I want all us Spaniards to have the same rights.”

Rivera, whose political approach is sometimes compared with that of Emmanuel Macron, shares the French president’s “neither left nor right” vision and questions the enduring validity of labels that were devised more than 200 years ago.

He is also fond of paraphrasing a “magnificent definition” of patriotism from another French leader, Charles de Gaulle: “Patriotism is wanting the best for your country – loving your country and wanting the best for your society – and nationalism is hating everyone else.”


Sam Jones in Madrid

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Catalan leader calls for end to 'indisputable unity' of Spain
Imprisoned Jordi Sànchez urges complete overhaul of Madrid’s approach to crisis

Sam Jones in Madrid and Patrick Wintour

03, Jun, 2018 @9:23 AM

Article image
Centre party Ciudadanos throws Spanish election results into question
Two-party dominance of socialists and People’s party could be nearing an end with rise of Albert Rivera’s anti-separatist party that is campagining for change

Ashifa Kassam in Madrid

10, Dec, 2015 @7:08 PM

Article image
Spain avoids third election and ends 10-month political impasse
Conservative Mariano Rajoy returns as PM after securing majority of parliament as Socialist party abstains from vote

Sam Jones in Madrid

29, Oct, 2016 @8:23 PM

Article image
Spain braces itself for unwanted gift on Christmas Day: a third election
As political impasse continues, Spain faces real prospect of its third general election in just over a year – on 25 December

Sam Jones in Madrid

25, Aug, 2016 @1:37 PM

Article image
Spain heads into election unknown as Sánchez runs out of road
Political landscape fragmented amid Catalan secession crisis and re-emergence of far-right

Jon Henley European affairs correspondent

15, Feb, 2019 @1:22 PM

Article image
Spanish PM defends handling of Catalan crisis after election blow
Mariano Rajoy calls for dialogue and cooperation, after deposed Catalan leader offers to meet him but not in Spain

Sam Jones in Barcelona and Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

22, Dec, 2017 @5:14 PM

Article image
Crisis over Catalonia – an explainer
Madrid’s hardball continues with European arrest warrant issued for deposed Catalan president after independence push

Sam Jones in Madrid

04, Nov, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
Mariano Rajoy to step down as leader of People’s party
Announcement comes days after he was ousted as Spain’s PM by a vote of no-confidence

Sam Jones in Madrid

05, Jun, 2018 @12:45 PM

Article image
Catalonia's president to bring crisis to head in parliament
Spain awaits Carles Puigdemont’s first address to region’s MPs since referendum, to see whether he declares independence

Sam Jones in Barcelona

10, Oct, 2017 @10:52 AM

Article image
Catalonia poised for hung parliament in bitterly contested election, polls say
No clear winner is in sight and coalition talks are expected following the election results late on Thursday night

Sam Jones in Barcelona

21, Dec, 2017 @5:00 AM