Vatican scrambles after pope appears to deny existence of hell

Repubblica founder Eugenio Scalfari has misrepresented pontiff’s words, says Vatican

The Vatican has scrambled to clarify comments made by Pope Francis to a well-known Italian journalist that appeared to deny the existence of hell.

The Holy See issued a terse statement saying a lengthy article published in La Repubblica on Wednesday by Eugenio Scalfari, 93, the newspaper’s founder, was “the fruit of his reconstruction” and not “a faithful transcription of the Holy Father’s words”.

While the Vatican conceded that Scalfari, an atheist who struck up a friendship with Francis in 2013, had held a private meeting with the pontiff before the Easter weekend, it said an interview had not been granted.

During the meeting Scalfari asked the pope where “bad souls” go, to which he was quoted as responding: “They are not punished. Those who repent obtain God’s forgiveness and take their place among the ranks of those who contemplate him, but those who do not repent and cannot be forgiven disappear. A hell doesn’t exist, the disappearance of sinning souls exists.”

On his election, 2013

“You know that it was the duty of the conclave to give Rome a bishop. It seems that my brother cardinals have gone to the ends of the earth to get one.”

On sexuality, 2013

“If a person is gay and seeks God and has good will, who am I to judge?”

On women, 2014

“By virtue of their feminine genius, [female] theologians can detect, for the benefit of all, some unexplored aspects of the unfathomable mystery of Christ. They are the strawberry on the cake and we want more.”

On migration to the EU, 2014

“We cannot allow the Mediterranean Sea to become a vast cemetery.”

On the Catholic church, 2015

“Sometimes, I speak of the church as if it were a field hospital. It’s true: there are many, many wounded! This is the mission of the church: to heal the wounds of the heart, to open doors, to free people... ”

On youth, 2015

“Young people... wonder how anyone can claim to be building a better future without thinking of the environmental crisis and the sufferings of the excluded.”

The Vatican said the “literal words pronounced by the pope are not quoted” and that “no quotation of the article should be considered as a faithful transcription of the words of the Holy Father”.

Scalfari is said to pride himself on not taking notes or recording high-profile interviews. But this is not the first time he has been accused of misrepresenting the pope: in 2014 he was rebuked by the Vatican for an article saying Francis had abolished sin.

The friendship has been criticised in the past, with Scalfari once saying that it was the pope who asked for the meetings as he liked to “exchange ideas and sentiments with non-believers”.

The Catholic church’s teachings affirm the existence of hell and its eternity, saying “the chief punishment of hell is eternal separation of God”.

Pope Benedict XVI said in 2007 that hell “really exists and is eternal, even if nobody talks about it much anymore”, while in 1999 Pope John Paul II announced that hell was “the ultimate consequence of sin itself … rather than a place, hell indicates the state of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God, the source of all life and joy”.

The controversy came as Pope Francis washed the feet of 12 prisoners at Rome’s Regina Coeli prison on Holy Thursday. Among the inmates were two Muslims, an Orthodox Christian and a Buddhist. He told them: “Everyone has the opportunity to change life and one cannot judge.”

It was the fourth time since becoming pope that he held mass in an Italian prison. “I am a sinner like you but today I represent Jesus … God never abandons us, never tires of forgiving us,” he added.


Angela Giuffrida in Rome

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pope Francis appoints first Briton as Vatican foreign minister
Liverpudlian Paul Gallagher, 60, currently working as ambassador to Australia, gains senior post after papal reshuffle

John Hooper in Rome

09, Nov, 2014 @3:23 PM

Article image
Pope Francis willing to visit North Korea, Vatican official says
Conditions would have to be met before invitation from Kim Jong-un could be accepted

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

19, Oct, 2018 @11:10 AM

Article image
From BBC to right hand of Pope: Patten to advise Vatican on media strategy
Former Tory chairman takes new job advising Holy See on how to handle press weeks after quitting BBC for health reasons

John Hooper in Vatican City

09, Jul, 2014 @7:51 PM

Article image
Pope begs forgiveness for abuse scandals as Ireland trip ends
Pontiff vows to pursue justice for victims in penitential prayer at mass in Dublin

Harriet Sherwood in Dublin

27, Aug, 2018 @12:22 AM

Article image
Vatican watchers on alert as Pope embarks on busy four days
Pope Francis to begin intense series of meetings and ceremonies that has brought all cardinals to Rome

Paddy Agnew in Rome

26, Aug, 2022 @4:00 AM

Article image
Pope reveals he had weekly psychoanalysis sessions at age 42
Francis says he visited psychoanalyst for six months ‘to clarify a few things’ and that now nothing frightens him

Harriet Sherwood and Angela Giuffrida in Rome

01, Sep, 2017 @4:26 PM

Article image
Pope appears to back anti-Trump protests in letter condemning populism
Pontiff tells activists he supports their fight against ‘gutting of democracies’ in letter that appears to take aim at US president

Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Rome

17, Feb, 2017 @12:01 PM

Article image
Pope Francis on the modern family: what we learned from Amoris Laetitia
What does the pope’s statement on modern family life say about divorce, gay marriage, abortion and sex education?

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

08, Apr, 2016 @12:31 PM

Article image
Pope Francis urges compassion for all in landmark statement on family values
Papel document calls for Catholic church to revamp its response to modern family life, but remains firmly anti-abortion

Rosie Scammell in Vatican City, and Harriet Sherwood in London

08, Apr, 2016 @4:12 PM

Article image
Pope Francis failed to act on US abuse claims, says former Vatican envoy
Retired diplomat urges pope to resign over allegations against former US archbishop

Harriet Sherwood in Dublin

26, Aug, 2018 @1:35 PM