Australia joins UN condemnation of Cambodia but refugee deal remains

Forty-five members of human rights council warn Hun Sen is presiding over an increasingly authoritarian regime

Australia has joined 44 other nations at the UN human rights council in condemning growing political violence and repression in Cambodia ahead of elections there this year.

Hun Sen, Cambodia’s strongman leader, was in Sydney last weekend for the Australia-Asean summit and met the prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull. It is understood the pair discussed human rights issues and the upcoming elections, as well as trade and the region’s nuclear threats.

But Australia maintains a controversial and expensive refugee deal where it sends refugees from its Nauru offshore processing centre to Cambodia, despite concerns over widespread human rights abuses in the south-east Asian country.

Hun’s presence in Sydney sparked significant demonstrations on the streets of the city, with protesters condemning him as a “thug” with “blood on his hands”.

In Geneva on Thursday morning Australian time, the 45 members of the 47-member human rights council said Cambodia had made significant democratic progress since the signing of the Paris peace agreement in 1991 ending the country’s civil war. But it had regressed in recent years, growing increasingly violent and authoritarian.

“As we near the elections scheduled for 29 July this year, our previous optimism has been replaced by deep concern about the recent serious decline of civil and political rights in Cambodia. These backward steps include signs of escalating repression of the political opposition, civil society and media,” the countries said.

“For the Cambodian government to retain its legitimacy, any elections must be free, fair and credible.”

Hun, a former Khmer Rouge cadre, has ruled Cambodia for more than 30 years. He has been credibly accused of large-scale corruption, enriching his family and cronies, as well as corruption of the criminal justice system, and sustained violence against and persecution of his political enemies.

The human rights council heard the Cambodian government used the country’s courts to jail political opponents and dissolve opposition parties. Dissidents have been murdered and opposition members of parliament publicly beaten or thrown out of parliament and replaced with members of Hun’s ruling People’s party and other parties.

The council heard all political prisoners in Cambodia should be released, including the leader of the opposition National Rescue party, Kem Sokha.

“We are particularly concerned about the conditions under which opposition leader Kem Sokha is being detained following his arbitrary arrest: he is reportedly in isolation, without adequate access to healthcare, subjected to intrusive observation and other conditions, such as constant light,” the council said.

The concerned countries told Cambodia it must reform “before it is too late, to ensure that the 2018 elections are free, fair and credible”.

“In particular, we urge that the elections take place in a peaceful environment without threats, arbitrary arrests or acts of intimidation, and that all international human rights obligations important for successful elections, such as rights to freedom of expression, press, association and peaceful assembly, are respected, protected and fulfilled.”

Australia maintains significant links to Hun’s administration. It has a refugee resettlement agreement under which refugees held by Australia on Nauru can settle in Cambodia.

The agreement has been an expensive failure for Australia and a windfall for Cambodia. It has cost Australia more than $40m in additional aid to Cambodia, as well as millions in administration and resettlement costs, but has resettled only three refugees.

At least four other refugees were moved to Cambodia but have since left. However, the Australian government refuses to confirm how many it has transferred to the country. The foreign minister, Julie Bishop, said the voluntary resettlement deal “remains on the table”.

Former foreign minister Gareth Evans, who helped broker a peace deal in war-ravaged Cambodia in the early 1990s as it recovered from the Khmer Rouge period and its war with Vietnam, this month said the “manifestly indefensible” refugee resettlement deal had compromised Australia’s response to Cambodia’s current political situation.

Daniel Webb, director of legal advocacy at the Human Rights Law Centre, said Australia’s decision to condemn the Hun regime was welcomed, but that the government’s own words revealed how unprincipled the Cambodian refugee deal was.

“It’s about time our government condemned the Hun Sen regime. It should also admit that paying that same regime $55m to offload refugees has been a morally bankrupt failure,” he said.


Ben Doherty

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Last refugee among group Australia sent to Cambodia returns to home country
Iranian was among four who had volunteered for resettlement in a deal a refugee advocate says was aimed at ensuring such an outcome eventually

Lauren Crothers in Phnom Penh

28, May, 2016 @12:39 AM

Article image
Syrian held on Nauru lands in Cambodia as sixth refugee to take up resettlement offer
Immigration chief confirms arrival of man who is one of three to have volunteered last month for transfer

Lauren Crothers

08, Nov, 2016 @8:39 AM

Article image
Australia urged to stop Cambodia returning persecuted refugees to Vietnam
Cambodia plans to send 29 Montagnard refugees back to Vietnam where they face violence but advocates say Australia can apply pressure to stop move

Ben Doherty

20, Sep, 2017 @6:00 PM

Article image
Nauru files: widespread condemnation of Australian government by UN and others
UN high commissioner for refugees ‘gravely concerned’ by allegations raised and says all refugees and asylum seekers should be moved off the island

Helen Davidson and Ben Doherty

10, Aug, 2016 @9:53 AM

Article image
Q&A: what is the Australian refugee deal and why has it angered Trump?
The background to the resettlement agreement that has sparked an outburst from the American president and now strains US-Australian relations

Christopher Knaus and Ben Doherty in Sydney

02, Feb, 2017 @6:35 AM

Article image
Australia resettled two Rwandans accused of murder in deal with US
Government accepted two men who could not be tried in the US, at the same time as protesting medevac bill would leave Australia powerless to prevent ‘murderers’ arriving from offshore detention

Helen Davidson, and Eleanor Ainge Roy in New Zealand

16, May, 2019 @2:16 AM

Article image
Peter Dutton says getting women and children off Nauru is 'first priority'
Australia’s immigration minister says his government is ‘working on’ getting immigration detainees resettled but did not provide details

Ben Doherty

20, Sep, 2016 @4:17 AM

Article image
Refugees condemn Malcolm Turnbull’s promotion of Australia’s asylum policy
Manus Island detainee says Australia went to New York refugee summit and ‘shouted that it is a country that violates human rights’

Ben Doherty

21, Sep, 2016 @6:25 AM

Article image
Trump lashes 'dumb deal' with Australia on refugees after fraught call with Turnbull
Washington Post says US president told Australian prime minister that phone conversation was ‘worst call by far’ in series of talks with world leaders

Katharine Murphy and Ben Doherty

02, Feb, 2017 @4:30 AM

Article image
Turnbull tells UN secure borders essential for managing global migration flow
Australian prime minister argues porous borders and uncontrolled flows of migrants drains support for multiculturalism, immigration and aid to refugees

Ben Doherty

22, Sep, 2016 @4:01 AM