‘It’s a death sentence’: Palestinians in Jerusalem brace for Trump aid cuts

For refugees in the densely packed Shuafat camp, a UN agency facing US funding cutbacks is the closest thing to a government

In one neighbourhood of Jerusalem, no one is quite sure who their government is.

The suffocatingly dense district of Shuafat is a Palestinian refugee camp that has grown into a maze of illegally built high-rises, but the Palestinian Authority has no power here.

Israel considers Shuafat under its jurisdiction – its residents pay tax – yet people say the only state presence they feel is when soldiers come in.

Sewage spills on to the road, rubbish burns in old oil drums, and there is no mail system. Few streets have names. Israeli ambulances and fire trucks won’t enter.

So for many residents of Shuafat, the closest thing to a government is the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, UNRWA.

The body was set up to help Palestinians uprooted in the 1948 Arab-Israeli war – at the time considered a temporary crisis. In the absence of peace, UNRWA has continued operations for seven decades, running schools, clinics, sanitation efforts and shelters.

But the aid agency is in crisis after Washington targeted its funding. For the residents on the crowded streets of Shuafat, already notorious as the drug and crime centre of Jerusalem, an end to UNRWA would mean the collapse of nearly all their infrastructure.

Donald Trump says he is using humanitarian aid to Shuafat and more than 5 million Palestinians across the Middle East as leverage to force their leaders into signing up to his yet-to-be-detailed peace initiative.

“That money is on the table and that money’s not going to them unless they sit down and negotiate peace,” he said on Thursday, sitting opposite Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu.

Cutbacks have already started. Last year, the US was the single largest donor to UNRWA, paying $355m, close to half its operating budget. This year, it has contributed $60m.

Blocked off by Israel’s separation barrier, there is only one exit from Shuafat into the rest of Jerusalem, through a military checkpoint. There are no accurate figures regarding how many people live in the camp, which was annexed by Israel after 1967, although UNRWA estimates about 24,000 live there.

Khalid al-Sheikh, 48, works in the Palestinian Child Center, a group in Shuafat that runs reading, music, yoga and other activities.

With overcrowding in schools – up to 46 in a class, al-Sheikh says – the group hopes to reduce psychological stress in a neighbourhood he describes as a “prison”.

A week ago, the girls’ school run by UNRWA was raided by thieves who stole computers. “There are hardly any janitors, no guards,” he said.

“If it was bad before, imagine the situation after. Trump’s decision: it’s a death sentence to the children of the camp,” he said. “If you remove these services, people have nothing left but their dignity.” He warned that the result would be violence.

Shuafat has a history of attacks, both criminal and political. In 2015, the Times of Israel described the camp as a “ticking time bomb”.

Chris Gunness, a spokesman for UNWRA, also warns of the danger of cuts. “Is it in American and Israel security interests to have the collapse of a functioning service provider in Jerusalem?” he asked.

UNRWA also works across the West Bank and Gaza, where Trump’s Middle East policies have met an explosive reaction.

A joint Palestinian-Israeli poll found support for militancy among Palestinians jumped 17% immediately after the US president said he would recognise Jerusalem as Israel’s capital. The declaration broke international consensus that the city’s status would be negotiated by the two sides. Trump now says that issue is off the table.

More than half of the Palestinian refugees UNRWA supports live in other countries –Lebanon, Syria and Jordan. In Lebanon, slum-like conditions and state discrimination in camps regularly lead to clashes with the army.

“We run schools for over half a million children across the region,” said Gunness. “Imagine if those services were to stop ... You would have half a million children on the streets of the Middle East and not in UN schools at a time when extremists are in full recruitment mode. How does that fit with the counter-terrorism narrative of western governments? How does that contribute towards stability in the Middle East?”

UNRWA’s commissioner-general has been travelling around the world meeting governments and individuals in an attempt to cover the shortfall. A public campaign, named “dignity is priceless”, has launched online.

For the moment, Gunness says UNRWA is determined not to make any cuts: “We are robustly determined to maintain services because we are talking about some of the most disadvantaged people in the region.”


Oliver Holmes and Sufian Taha in Jerusalem

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'A travesty': Trump censured over UN Jerusalem vote comments
As UN declares US attempt to have Jerusalem recognised as Israel’s capital ‘null and void’, experts warn Trump’s proposed aid cuts would have devastating consequences

Karen McVeigh

21, Dec, 2017 @6:13 PM

Article image
US ambassador to UN contradicts Trump's position on two-state solution
Nikki Haley said US upholds longstanding policy on Israeli-Palestine conflict, as French foreign minister finds Rex Tillerson’s proposal ‘confusing and worrying’

Julian Borger in Washington

16, Feb, 2017 @7:35 PM

Article image
'Decades of chaos': Arab leaders condemn US decision on Jerusalem
Donald Trump’s unilateral move to back Israel’s claim to holy city has reunited competing factions across the Middle East to a common cause

Martin Chulov Middle East correspondent

07, Dec, 2017 @7:13 PM

Article image
Israel braced for clashes following Trump's recognition of Jerusalem as capital
UN security council to meet to discuss US decision amid widespread international condemnation and violence in occupied territories

Peter Beaumont in Ramallah

08, Dec, 2017 @2:12 PM

Article image
Mike Pence's Holy Land visit in disarray after Jerusalem recognition
Tour was intended to draw attention to plight of Christians in Middle East, but many leaders are now refusing to meet him

Peter Beaumont in Jerusalem

15, Dec, 2017 @1:00 PM

Article image
Moving US embassy to Jerusalem could provoke violent 'chaos', experts warn
Donald Trump’s oft-stated desire to relocate the embassy from Tel Aviv has been seen by many as a grave threat to the Israel-Palestine peace process

Peter Beaumont in Jerusalem

21, Dec, 2016 @4:36 PM

Article image
Differing views on Jerusalem as a capital | Letters
Letters: Palestinian claims to Jerusalem as their capital have no basis in fact or history, says Joshua Rowe. Trump and Netanyahu know the west’s response is all wind and fury, says Christopher Sterling. It’s hard to argue with Israel’s assertion that Trump is simply acknowledging the reality, says Leon Rosselson


08, Dec, 2017 @7:05 PM

Article image
US seeks to quell global outrage over Jerusalem: 'The sky hasn't fallen'
UN ambassador defends decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, a move that sparked condemnation and protests, saying it will advance peace talks

Alan Yuhas

10, Dec, 2017 @8:22 PM

Article image
Donald Trump says US not committed to two-state Israel-Palestine solution
Speaking alongside Benjamin Netanyahu, US president appears to dismantle years of policy by saying he is looking at multiple options for peace

Julian Borger in Washington, and Peter Beaumont in Jericho

16, Feb, 2017 @12:20 PM

Article image
Writers, actors and musicians condemn Trump Jerusalem move
Letter claims US president is furthering Israeli agenda ‘to erase Palestinians from the life of their own city’

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

11, Dec, 2017 @7:03 PM