Jimmy Carr criticised for saying New Zealand city needs earthquake to look better

Comedian branded insensitive for tweet that Dunedin, the country’s oldest city, would benefit from a rebuild

British comedian Jimmy Carr has caused offence in New Zealand by suggesting the country’s oldest city – Dunedin – could be improved by an earthquake.

The comedian has been touring the country and last night performed in Dunedin, on the lower east coast of the South Island.

On Twitter Carr posted photographs from Napier and Christchurch, which were both devastated and rebuilt after major earthquakes.

Carr said the earthquakes and subsequent rebuilds had made both cities “beautiful”, and Dunedin could be beautiful too if rebuilt after an earthquake.

In 1931 an earthquake in Hawke’s Bay claimed 256 lives, and in 2011 the Christchurch earthquake claimed 185 lives, and has so far cost the government an estimated NZ$40bn to rebuild, a project which is ongoing.

Went to Napier, destroyed by an earthquake - rebuilt - beautiful town.
Went to Christchurch, destroyed by an earthquake - rebuilt - beautiful town
I'm now in Dunedin. I'll tell you what this town needs... pic.twitter.com/TfS0fGk7lP

— Jimmy Carr (@jimmycarr) January 22, 2018

Although many New Zealanders took the quip in good humour, others were offended and labelled the joke off-colour and inappropriate for a guest visiting a country which is vulnerable to earthquakes.

The Alpine fault runs up the spine of the South Island and has fascinated geologists for decades, as it is a notoriously active, and predicted to erupt every 330 years, producing large earthquakes of magnitude eight and above.

“Hope you found the Grenfell fire hilarious too, ” wrote one Twitter user.

“Mate not funny – sensitivity FAIL.” wrote another.

@jimmycarr with respect, what you need is a measure more decency and sensitivity. Not funny and will never be the right time. https://t.co/06JnjFzzdY

— Chris Eichbaum (@ChrisEichbaum) January 22, 2018

By midday “Dunedin” was trending on Twitter in New Zealand.

On the weekend Carr tweeted about his “earthquake tour” of the island country, saying he’d better not make any jokes about it as “I’ll be on very shaky ground”.

Earlier in the tour Carr appeared beside New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern on The Project, an evening panel show.

Ardern said she was somewhat nervous of appearing with Carr who is known for his acerbic wit.

“You’ll be fine. I love you,” Carr responded warmly.

“You’re like the opposite of [US president Donald] Trump.”

Contributor

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Comedy review: Jimmy Carr / Hammersmith Apollo, London

He's obviously a clever guy, says Brian Logan, so why does Jimmy Carr insist on dumbing down for the arena crowd?

Brian Logan

17, Jan, 2008 @9:48 AM

Article image
Jimmy Carr, Pleasance, Edinburgh

Pleasance, Edinburgh

Brian Logan

08, Aug, 2003 @2:57 PM

Article image
Jimmy Carr, International Conference Centre, Edinburgh

International Conference Centre, Edinburgh

Brian Logan

16, Aug, 2004 @5:13 PM

Article image
Jimmy Carr | Comedy review

Cliff's Pavilion, Southend: Jimmy Carr wastes his obvious talents on tired politically incorrect gags, says Brian Logan

Brian Logan

12, Oct, 2009 @9:30 PM

Article image
New Zealand earthquake: 6.2-magnitude shake halts parliament
Houses sway as strong quake under central New Zealand is felt in Wellington

Eleanor Ainge Roy

30, Oct, 2018 @3:31 AM

Article image
Uphill cattle: stranded cows rescued after New Zealand earthquake
Two cows and a calf were stuck on pillar of earth and had to be dug out by a farmer after hillside collapsed

Bonnie Malkin

14, Nov, 2016 @11:45 PM

Article image
New Zealand city in an Easter 'kerfuffle' over Ed Sheeran
Dunedin is divided over a mural of the singer and special licences to serve alcohol over Easter

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

26, Mar, 2018 @10:11 PM

Article image
All Blacks coach criticised for saying domestic violence 'not a gender thing'
Steve Hansen made the comments after naming Sevu Reece, who admitted to assaulting his partner, in the team

Charles Anderson in Nelson

08, Jul, 2019 @5:05 AM

Article image
New Zealand earthquake: fears for wildlife along devastated coastline
Colonies and breeding grounds of seals, dolphins and penguins directly in path of landslides and upheaval, say experts, as quake magnitude upgraded to 7.8

Eleanor Ainge Roy

16, Nov, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
New Zealand opposition leader criticised for 'alarming' stance on China
Simon Bridges said he was ‘amazed’ by China’s prosperity and also met Guo Shengkun, who is believed to have links to secret police

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

11, Sep, 2019 @2:00 AM