China hits back at US over South China Sea 'takeover' claims

Beijing warns White House to tread carefully after Rex Tillerson likens island-building to Russia’s taking of Crimea

China has warned the US to “speak and act cautiously” after the White House said it would act to foil Chinese attempts to “take over” the South China Sea, amid growing hints that Donald Trump’s administration intends to challenge Beijing over the strategic waterway.

At a press conference in Beijing on Tuesday, the foreign ministry spokesperson, Hua Chunying, urged Washington to tread carefully “to avoid harming the peace and stability of the South China Sea”.

Hua was responding to comments made by White House press secretary, Sean Spicer, the previous day.

Speaking at a press briefing on Monday, Spicer vowed the US would “make sure that we protect our interests” in the resource-rich trade route, through which $4.5tn (£3.4tn) in trade passes each year.

His comments came less than a fortnight after Rex Tillerson, Trump’s nominee for secretary of state, set the stage for a potentially explosive clash with Beijing by likening its artificial island building campaign in the South China Sea to “Russia’s taking of Crimea”.

Tillerson told his confirmation hearing the White House needed to send China a “clear signal” that such activities had to stop and that its access to such territories was “not going to be allowed”.

“They are taking territory or control or declaring control of territories that are not rightfully China’s,” Tillerson said.

Sean Spicer holds first Trump administration press briefing

Chinese media responded by warning that any attempt to prevent China accessing its interests in the region risked sparking a “large-scale war”.

At his first question and answer session with the press on Monday, Spicer again hinted Trump’s administration would take a harder line on the South China Sea.

“It’s a question of if those islands are in fact in international waters and not part of China proper, then yeah, we’re going to make sure that we defend international territories from being taken over by one country,” he told reporters.

Spicer declined to explain how such steps might be enforced. “I think, as we develop further, we’ll have more information on it,” he said.

Competing claims in the South China Sea

However, scholars who have been advising Trump’s team on China policy back a more muscular military approach, primarily through a dramatically strengthened navy in the region.

“We’ve talked a big game on security but haven’t really followed it up all that well with the military muscle that was needed,” Daniel Blumenthal, the director of Asian Studies at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative Washington-based thinktank, told the Guardian.

Blumenthal said a “strong, persistent US naval presence” was required to back up a foreign policy “that at its bottom line says that China’s not going to control the South China Sea … But you can’t do that without military resources.”

China claims sovereignty over nearly the entire South China Sea and in recent years has stepped up a campaign to cement its control over a region where Brunei, Japan, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam also have claims.

It has done so partly by transforming a series of remote coral reefs into what experts say are in effect military outposts designed to help enforce its territorial claims.

Last month, a US thinktank said “significant” weapons systems, including anti-aircraft and anti-missile systems, had been deployed on China’s artificial islands. Beijing claims it has no intention of militarising the islands.

Blumenthal said he believed there was now “broad bipartisan support for trying to stem this expansionism, which is leading to effective Chinese control over the South China Sea”.

In July 2016, a judgment by an international tribunal in The Hague came down overwhelmingly in favour of claims by the Philippines to rocky outcrops in the South China Sea, a verdict disputed by Beijing.

“If indeed [the artificial islands] are not sovereign territory – and we don’t recognise them as so, and the region doesn’t recognise them as so, and the Hague didn’t recognise them as so – then there are all sorts of activities, up and down an escalation ladder, that the United States could take should we want to in terms of Chinese encroachment,” Blumenthal said.

Critics believe such moves would spark a furious reaction from Beijing and throw US-China ties into turmoil.

“This administration is shaping up to be the most hawkish administration against China in living memory … and this is not a recipe for great power stability, it is a recipe for great power friction,” said Ashley Townshend, a South China Sea expert from the University of Sydney’s United States studies centre.

Rex Tillerson: I would block China’s access to islands in South China Sea

“A blockade [of China’s artificial islands] would be incredibly provocative and would almost certainly spark a US-China confrontation on the water … If the US is going to blockade China’s access to territories which it – rightly or wrongly – believes are its, then we are in for a confrontation.”

More likely, Townshend said, was that Trump would order the stepping-up of freedom of navigation and overflight operations, which have come increasingly close to features in the South China Sea claimed by China.

Despite fears about the direction US policy towards China may take under the new president, Blumenthal argued a more robust stance from Washington could in fact improve ties.

“My own view, and my own experience in government, is that when you are very clear with China about what your national interests are and what you are going to do in the region, they become very clear as well and say, ‘You know what, we’re going to stop pushing’ and the relationship in certain areas can improve.

“I think the most dangerous scenario was the one we were heading towards: a lot of tough talk on the South China Sea, but China continuing to encroach and the United States not really putting a lot of muscle behind the statements it was making.”


Tom Phillips in Beijing

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
North Korea rocket test ups ante with belligerent Trump administration | Simon Tisdall
Washington’s own provocative stance may play into Pyongyang’s hands and reduce China’s willingness to cooperate

Simon Tisdall

19, Mar, 2017 @2:39 PM

Article image
Donald Trump and China on dangerous collision course, say experts
Report says ties between the two nuclear-armed countries could deteriorate into an economic or military confrontation

Tom Phillips in Beijing

07, Feb, 2017 @3:30 AM

Article image
Photos show Beijing’s militarisation of South China Sea in new detail
China accused of building ‘island fortresses’ as Philippine newspaper obtains aerial images

Tom Phillips in Beijing

06, Feb, 2018 @10:09 AM

Article image
Kamala Harris accuses Beijing of ‘coercion’ and ‘intimidation’ in South China Sea
In major speech delivered in Singapore, US vice president says America stands with its allies in the Indo Pacific in the face of threats from China

Staff and agencies

24, Aug, 2021 @4:40 AM

Article image
South China Sea fears grow before tribunal rules on disputed islands
China already says it will reject ruling, fanning west’s fears of construction surge in islands and reefs in busy trade route

Julian Borger World affairs editor

29, May, 2016 @3:24 PM

Article image
'Washington's sharksucker': Chinese media fires at Britain over South China Sea
China Daily decries ‘reckless actions’ after HMS Albion sails close to disputed Paracel islands

Benjamin Haas in Seoul

07, Sep, 2018 @3:32 AM

Article image
China lambasts US over South China Sea row
Beijing accuses Washington's intervention in the region of 'fanning the flames and provoking division'

Tania Branigan in Beijing

06, Aug, 2012 @5:01 PM

Article image
China vows action after US warship sails near South China Sea island
Beijing claims passage of destroyer USS Hopper in disputed water violates sovereignty but Pentagon says operations are routine


21, Jan, 2018 @2:24 AM

Article image
China attacks international court after South China Sea ruling
Beijing warns of possible military escalation after UN tribunal overwhelmingly rejects its claims to ownership of strategic waterway

Tom Phillips in Beijing

13, Jul, 2016 @6:39 AM

Article image
US escalates pressure on China over South China Sea and North Korea
Rex Tillerson rules out negotiating on China’s island-building in disputed territory and says China must ‘step up their efforts’ to curb North Korea’s nuclear program

Ben Doherty

05, Jun, 2017 @7:49 AM