'Bathroom bills' planned in eight states despite furor in North Carolina

The stage is set for showdowns across the country as others seek to echo North Carolina’s law that sparked an outcry over transgender rights

Boosted by a failed effort in North Carolina to topple an anti-transgender “bathroom bill”, conservative lawmakers in other states are redoubling their efforts to make restrooms and locker rooms the next political and cultural battleground.

In Texas on Thursday, legislators introduced a bill similar to North Carolina’s notorious law and said they were steeling themselves for the challenge of getting it passed amid fears of the possible economic consequences.

“We know it’s going to be a tough fight. The forces of fear and misinformation will pull out all the stops, both in Texas and nationally,” Texas lieutenant governor Dan Patrick said at a press conference in Austin. “You can mark today as the day that Texas is drawing a line in the sand and saying ‘no’. The privacy and safety of Texans is our first priority, not political correctness.”

Transgender rights advocates reacted with outrage and contended that the bill was likely to bring the same turmoil that hit North Carolina last year and appeared to contribute to the election defeat of the governor who signed the measure into law, Pat McCrory. The state’s legislators considered repealing House Bill 2 in a special session just before Christmas but kept it on the books.

Despite the controversy, “bathroom bills” have become a favourite cause of conservative Christian lawmakers. Seven other states in addition to Texas have introduced or pre-filed bills restricting access to facilities for their 2017 legislative sessions, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures: Alabama, Kentucky, Missouri, South Carolina, Virginia, Washington and Minnesota.

Virginia’s measure, proposed on Tuesday, echoes North Carolina’s. The state’s Democratic governor, Terry McAuliffe, pledged to veto it if it reached his desk.

“Just as HB2 has hurt North Carolina, this proposal would harm our on-going efforts to bring jobs to Virginia,” he said in a statement. On Thursday, McAuliffe said he had signed an executive order banning the state from doing business with organisations that discriminate based on sexual orientation or gender identity.

If passed by the Republican-dominated Texas legislature later this year, Senate Bill 6 would require people in public buildings such as schools to use bathroom and locker-room facilities that comport with their “biological sex” stated on a birth certificate, with a limited number of possible exemptions, such as for privatelyleased venues like stadiums.

The bill also stops local governments from passing ordinances that prevent private businesses from deciding their own restroom policies, or from denying contracts to companies based on such policies – effectively undercutting existing laws in cities including Dallas, Austin and San Antonio. It would increase penalties for crimes committed in bathrooms and changing rooms and would take effect in September.

Transgender-rights advocates reacted with outrage at Texas’s own proposals to limit bathroom access.
Transgender-rights advocates reacted with outrage at Texas’s own proposals to limit bathroom access. Photograph: Lucy Nicholson/Reuters

The Texas Association of Business, the state’s chamber of commerce, released a report last year warning that the passage of a law such as Senate Bill 6 could see the Lone Star State’s economy lose from $964m to $8.5bn and as many as 185,000 jobs.

Patrick, though, appears unconcerned by his critics. He described them at the unveiling as peddling “fake news” about the bill’s contents and potential impact. But the backlash against North Carolina’s HB2 was genuine. Some businesses shelved investment plans and major sports events such as the 2017 NBA All-Star Game went elsewhere.

“If you look at all the states in the country that have the most robust economies, they are states, almost without exception, that do not allow men into ladies’ rooms. But many of the states at the bottom of the pile, where their economies are suffering, have different policies,” Patrick said, adding that North Carolina is “doing just fine”.

Patrick said that the rejection of a city-wide equal rights ordinance by Houston voters in 2015 showed that measures such as the new proposal enjoy popular support. That vote saw a wide-ranging anti-discrimination effort roundly defeated after opponents mounted a fear-mongering campaign peddling the spurious notion that the ordinance would lead to a rash of attacks on women in restrooms. There is no evidence that the existence of non-discrimination policies that accommodate transgender people in cities across the US has led to an increase in sexual assault.

The bill is authored by Patrick’s fellow Republican, Lois Kolkhorst, a state senator from Brenham, near Houston. She told reporters that it is in part a riposte to the Obama administration’s attempt last May to introduce new guidance to schools to accommodate transgender students, which was blocked last August by a federal court in Texas.

Kolkhorst described the federal guidelines as an “incredible policy shift” that shocked many Texans. Now, she said, “we are codifying the common decency the general public has always expected.”

Despite claims that “bathroom bills” increase safety by deterring male sexual predators from entering women’s facilities, opponents say that the real danger is an increase in violence against transgender people spurred by divisive laws.

“This bill is judgment and is hateful. It is putting our lives in grave danger,” said Reagan White, a transgender woman.

“A true ‘privacy act’ would not ask a Texan about their private parts before they potty,” said Kimberly Shappley, the mother of a six-year-old transgender child in the Houston area. Shappley said that her daughter, Kai, already finds going to the restroom at school to be stressful because school district policies do not let her use the girls’ facilities, so she goes to the gender-neutral toilet in the nurse’s office.

“Every time [politicians] start pushing something like this it stirs fear and stirs hatred,” Shappley said.

  • This article was amended on 6 January 2017. A previous version of the headline incorrectly counted the number of states that have introduced bathroom bills.

Contributor

Tom Dart in Houston

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Negotiations to repeal North Carolina 'bathroom bill' fall apart
A special session adjourned on Wednesday without voting on a proposal to undo the controversial law, which restricts use of bathrooms for transgender people

Edward Helmore in New York

22, Dec, 2016 @2:15 AM

Article image
North Carolina 'bathroom bill' blocking LGBT protections unlikely to see repeal
HB2, which restricts bathroom options for transgender people and overrides local laws to protect LGBT people from bias, has left residents furious

Joanna Walters

23, Dec, 2016 @7:40 PM

Article image
North Carolina's 'bathroom bill' battle embarrasses residents on both sides
The escalating fight over LGBT rights has turned the historically sophisticated, inclusive southern state into a battleground of intolerance

Matthew Teague and Laurie Richards in Raleigh, North Carolina

10, May, 2016 @12:09 PM

Article image
Dolly Parton denounces North Carolina 'bathroom bill'
Country singer joins growing number of musicians in opposing controverisal new measure barring local governments from creating LGBT protections

Guardian music

10, Jun, 2016 @2:13 PM

Article image
North Carolina discrimination law violates US constitution, experts warn
New law a blow to LGBT rights by requiring public institutions to designate bathrooms to only be used by people in accordance with their biological sex

Amanda Holpuch in New York

25, Mar, 2016 @5:45 PM

Article image
North Carolina Republican condemned over ‘repugnant’ anti-LGBTQ tirade
Democrats and gay rights groups groups call out Mark Robinson for ‘dangerous’ remarks but lieutenant governor remains defiant

Maya Yang

16, Oct, 2021 @9:00 AM

Article image
Big investors join list of heavyweights against North Carolina 'bathroom bill'
Morgan Stanley and RBC are among the 53 investors who signed open letter calling for a ‘full repeal to HB2’ and citing that it’s bad for business

Rupert Neate in New York

26, Sep, 2016 @4:20 PM

Article image
North Carolina: trans people given right to use bathrooms matching identity
Settlement marks the end of a three-year battle over a controversial ‘bathroom bill’, also known as HB2

Amanda Holpuch

23, Jul, 2019 @8:44 PM

Article image
A divided North Carolina draws national attention in fight over transgender law
National and local reactions to a controversial new law dictating where transgender people can use the bathroom has been immediate and powerful

Matthew Teague in North Carolina and Jana Kasperkevic in New York

01, Apr, 2016 @5:55 PM

Article image
Elton John: North Carolina 'bathroom bill' shows 'failure of compassion'
Musician condemns measure barring local governments from creating LGBT protections, calling its effects potentially ‘traumatic and unsafe’

Amanda Holpuch in New York

18, May, 2016 @4:52 PM