Public humiliation: Chechen leader's simple strategy to control social media

Ramzan Kadyrov is punishing ordinary people who criticise his rule with televised shamings, as well as detentions and abuse

Aishat Inaeva, a social worker from a small town in Chechnya, did not speak out against the region’s notorious leader, Ramzan Kadyrov. She wouldn’t have dared.

Instead, she made a WhatsApp recording, imploring him to look into the plight of ordinary people “pushed below the poverty line” by local officials, a message that went viral among Chechen users of the messaging app.

A week or so later, Inaeva found herself hauled into the studio of Grozny TV, the state television and radio broadcaster, her husband beside her, the republic’s leader in front of her, being forced to apologise publicly for her “lies”.

“You help [the poor] … I was confused, I do not know how and why I did that,” she said to the president, Ramzan Kadyrov, her head bowed. Inaeva’s husband joined in, chastising himself for “allowing her to spread all those lies”.

The 16-minute news segment sent a clear message to Chechnya’s audience: if you’re unhappy with something, keep your mouth shut or prepare to be shamed.

Public humiliation forms part of Kadyrov’s latest strategy to eradicate dissent in the republic. For close to a decade the young leader has been exercising tyrannical rule over Chechnya. A free press no longer exists, and the few journalists from independent Russian and foreign outlets reporting on ongoing abuses inside the republic find themselves at great risk of harassment, arbitrary detentions and even violent attacks by security officials and their proxies.

But the worst punishment is reserved for Chechens themselves. Those who dare to post critical comments online are increasingly being tracked down and penalised.

A recent report by Human Rights Watch described how local authorities retaliate against people who show dissatisfaction with the Chechen leadership and its policies. It found that the onslaught against dissent has intensified over the past 18 months, with even the mildest criticism on social media ruthlessly punished through unlawful, punitive detention, enforced disappearances, cruel and degrading treatment, death threats, threats against family members, and physical abuse of family members.

This severe and sweeping repression by the local authorities is designed to remind the Chechen public of Kadyrov’s total control, and to contain the flow of any negative information from Chechnya that could undermine Russia’s support.

Inaeva’s appearance on Grozny TV in December.

As a result, few people in Chechnya go as far as Inaeva. If they do, retribution is fast.

In April, Ramazan Dzhalaldinov, a man in his 50s from a mountain village not far from Chechnya’s border with Dagestan, posted a video message timed to Vladimir Putin’s annual televised call-in show.

He complained that his village, Kenkhi, was in ruins as a result of the Chechen wars, and alleged that local officials were steeped in corruption. The video was picked up by internet users in Chechnya and Russia and widely shared online.

Fearing punishment from the authorities, Dzhalaldinov fled to Dagestan and made sure that his sons also left Chechnya. But in May, four weeks after Grozny TV broadcast a news segment featuring local people calling Dzhalaldinov a liar and a crook, local police came looking for his wife and their daughters, aged 17, 12 and 10.

A dozen armed men in masks and camouflage uniforms forced their way into the house late at night, dragged Dzhalaldinov’s wife and the children out of bed, and took them to the district police station.

Leaving the younger girls alone in a room, police officers beat their mother and eldest sister, saying it was punishment for the trouble caused by the head of the family. A senior official allegedly fired a gun several times over the mother’s head and choked her daughter, demanding that they persuade Dzhalaldinov to publicly apologise.

After the interrogation, police officers drove the women to Chechnya’s administrative border with Dagestan, ordering them to cross and never return. That night, their home was torched.

A few weeks later, Grozny TV broadcast a video apology by Dzhalaldinov: “I apologise. I made a mistake. I ask other people not to repeat my mistake … Now many will say I was threatened or coerced [to say this]. I make this speech voluntarily … Kadyrov rebuilt this [Kenkhi] village.”

He had been told by officials that if he publicly renounced his statement, he would be able to return to Chechnya with his family.

A video posted on Kadyrov’s Instagram account that appears to show Dzhalaldinov apologising.

Kadyrov then told his two millions followers on Instagram that “some abnormal forces” had tried to use this man “to achieve their filthy, harmful objectives” but luckily, he “found the strength and wisdom” to realise his mistake and publicly admit it, so his apology was accepted.

Even those who use monikers or talk in closed groups on social media face reprisals. Late last year, a 35-year-old faculty member from a university in Grozny, Khizir Ezhiev, was chatting with friends in a private group on Facebook. When someone mentioned Kadyrov’s pilgrimage to Mecca, Ezhiev wrote: “Apparently, all sorts are welcome there these days.”

Weeks later, four men bundled Ezhiev into their vehicle and drove away. His body was found weeks later with multiple injuries. Authorities claimed he had fallen off a cliff.

The day after Ezhiev was abducted, an unrelated video surfaced of a young man walking on a treadmill in his underwear and apologising to Kadyrov.

“I am Adam Dikaev from Avtury village,” he said on camera. “Thinking that no one can find me, I wrote on Instagram [under another name] what I should not have written. They found me and took my pants down. I realised I am nobody. From now on, Putin is my father, grandfather, and tsar …”

His crime? Flippant comments on social networks about Kadyrov grovelling before Putin. The video showed Chechens the level of humiliation the government was prepared to orchestrate.

Over the past year, many from Chechnya have recounted similar stories, and described sweeping repression, relentless pressure and constant humiliation. Some say the current situation feels more unbearable than the bombing and shelling experienced during the recent war.

“We lived through the war and kept our dignity – but now they [the authorities] are taking that dignity away from us, and we who survived the war cannot live with it,” said one Grozny resident, speaking on the condition of anonymity.

Tanya Lokshina is Russia programme director at Human Rights Watch, and author of the report, Like Walking a Minefield: Vicious Crackdown on Critics in Russia’s Chechen Republic


Tanya Lokshina

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Chechen journalists, international journalists – Ramzan Kadyrov has silenced us all
Not making the president angry is the main goal of Chechnya’s local media, an anonymous reporter explains


10, Oct, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
The women risking everything to report from Russia's frontlines
Anecdotal evidence suggests it is mainly female journalists filling the gap left by the murder 10 years ago of Anna Politkovskaya

Irina Borogan in Moscow

06, Oct, 2016 @7:39 AM

Article image
The murder that killed free media in Russia
A decade after the assassination of Anna Politkovskaya, news organisations increasingly avoid topics that could anger the Kremlin

Shaun Walker in Moscow

05, Oct, 2016 @10:37 AM

Article image
Chechen leader Kadyrov to choose assistant on reality TV show
Apprentice-style contest will involve traditional wedding and 24-hour tasks to find ‘the best of the best’ for strongman ruler

Alec Luhn in Moscow

30, Jun, 2016 @3:42 PM

Article image
Chechen leader Kadyrov posts video of Russian opposition leader in gun sights
Mikhail Kasyanov, whose co-leader of Russian party was gunned down a year ago, says video by Chechnya’s pro-Kremlin leader is ‘direct threat of a murder’

Alec Luhn in Moscow

01, Feb, 2016 @10:09 PM

Article image
Russia's intervention in Syria could have been stopped 20 years ago
The war in Chechnya laid the foundations for the Kremlin’s aggressive foreign policy – but back then western leaders were silent

Oleg Kashin

02, Nov, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
Chechen leader to star in two films – one Hollywood, one human rights exposé
Ramzan Kadyrov annouces role in action thriller on Instagram – as foundation releases documentary portraying him as corrupt dictator

Howard Amos for the Moscow Times, part of the New East network

26, May, 2015 @10:10 AM

Article image
'Russia's treatment of Crimean Tatars echoes mistakes made by Soviets'
Repression of Crimea’s original inhabitants is the gravest conflict in Russia today, says opposition politician and historian Vladimir Ryzhkov

Vladimir Ryzhkov for Ekho Moskvy

25, Nov, 2014 @11:02 AM

Article image
Chechen leader's show of strength muddies loyalty to Putin
Ramzan Kadyrov’s show of loyalty to Putin could be warning of Chechen forces’ huge potential

Shaun Walker in Grozny

03, Jun, 2015 @5:03 PM

Article image
Former Kremlin critic changes tack to launch television station in Donetsk
Andrei Babitsky was labelled a traitor in Russia for his coverage of the Chechen wars. So why is he espousing pro-Putin views in Ukraine?

Shaun Walker in Donetsk

10, Jul, 2015 @6:00 AM