Vatican synod holds its line on gay couples but offers new hope to Catholic divorcees

Bishops confirm Catholic teaching on the ‘intrinsic disorder’ of homosexuality

After a three-week marathon of Vatican talks on family issues, Roman Catholic bishops voted on a summary document which decided against overhauling the church’s teaching on gay Catholics but paved the way for greater openness towards divorcees.

Pope Francis described the Vatican summit as a way to “open up broader horizons, rising above conspiracy theories and blinkered viewpoints”.

“Surely it was not about finding exhaustive solutions for all the difficulties and uncertainties which challenge and threaten the family,” the pontiff said, “but rather about seeing these difficulties and uncertainties in the light of the Faith, carefully studying them and confronting them fearlessly, without burying our heads in the sand.”

A push for more welcoming language was evident, but the final text was by no means a triumph for progressives. Although bishops agreed that people should be treated with respect “independently of their own sexual tendency”, the reference to gay Catholics was viewed in terms of “accompanying the families in which people with homosexual tendencies live”, rather than accepting same-sex relationships.

The bishops also criticised international bodies they said were pushing poor countries to introduce same-sex marriage laws with the promise of aid.

There was, however, a greater openness towards Catholics who divorce and remarry outside the church, who under Vatican teachings are excluded from receiving communion. Bishops agreed divorcees must be “more integrated in Christian communities”.

The bishops also paved the way for clergy to decide whether to allow divorcees to participate fully in church life: “It is to be hoped that in the dioceses paths of discernment and involvement of these people will be promoted.”

The statements on remarried Catholics, however, lacked specificity, reflecting the difficulty of reaching consensus among the bishops, who voted paragraph-by-paragraph on a text that on Friday received 1,355 suggested changes. Despite opposing opinions, many of the 270 participating bishops said there was a greater sense of open dialogue at this synod, coming a year after bishops had first met to discuss family issues.

Although the clash of conservatives and progressives ran as an undercurrent through this year’s synod, perhaps the greatest challenge was marked by the hugely diverse experiences bishops have of family life. Many described the synod as an education in global family issues, with polygamy, migration and climate change just some of the issues discussed.

Regional splits were raised, with African bishops prompted to defend themselves against accusations that they were trying to block progress being peddled by a more “western” view of the world. But geographical borders did not necessarily determine conformity to a certain point of view, with an open division being aired in the media between some US participants at the synod.

Such splits may have played a role in Pope Francis calling for a “healthy decentralisation” of the church and the need for a “conversation of the papacy”.

The suggestion that bishops could be given greater powers to decide on family issues at a regional level has worried some Catholics, who believe it could lead to a watering down of church doctrine.

While bishops have made their collective case, it is up to the pope to decide the next move. Beyond the synod vote, he will face tough opposition in any attempt to change the letter of church teachings, but the upcoming jubilee year of mercy could serve as an opportunity to table new plans for Catholic family life.


Rosie Scammell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Catholic bishops veto gay-friendly statements leaving Pope Francis the loser
Final report of Roman Catholic extraordinary synod on the family removes talk of ‘welcoming’ gay people

Lizzy Davies in Rome

19, Oct, 2014 @8:14 AM

Article image
Pope Francis warns Catholic bishops against sticking too rigidly to doctrine
As synod closes, church calls for a more open attitude to divorcees but failed to discuss sexuality and same-sex unions

Rosie Scammell in Rome

25, Oct, 2015 @5:44 PM

Article image
Pope revisits 'punishing' rules on Catholic divorce

Millions of devotees remain banned from receiving communion – but meeting of bishops raises hopes of ban being loosened

Lizzy Davies

27, Sep, 2014 @7:15 PM

Article image
Catholic bishops descend on Rome for contentious synod on the family
Battle between conservatives and progressives likely as church debates how it should approach modern world without veering away from doctrine

Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Rome

03, Oct, 2015 @3:43 PM

Article image
Unsealing of Vatican archives will finally reveal truth about ‘Hitler’s pope’
Historians can now pore over secret files from the papacy of Pius XII, who has long faced accusations of being a Nazi sympathiser

Harriet Sherwood

01, Mar, 2020 @6:33 AM

Article image
Civil war in the Vatican as conservatives battle Francis for the soul of Catholicism
As the pope leaves Rome for a retreat to mark Lent, rebellion and turmoil are in the air

Catherine Pepinster

04, Mar, 2017 @10:35 PM

Article image
It’s a victory for the status quo but all is not yet lost for Francis
Pope Francis may have lost this battle for reform – but at least he has changed the conversation

Andrew Brown

24, Oct, 2015 @6:53 PM

Article image
Two popes, plotting cardinals and the fallout of an explosive book
Benedict and his inner circle are accused of intervening to halt Pope Francis relaxing celibacy rules as the battle between conservative and liberal factions takes a new twist

Angela Giuffrida

19, Jan, 2020 @10:14 AM

Article image
Pope Francis prays alongside Grand Mufti in Istanbul’s Blue Mosque
Pope treads carefully in footsteps of predecessor in ‘moment of silent adoration’ to mark religious cooperation during Turkey visit

Constanze Letsch

29, Nov, 2014 @8:07 PM

Article image
Vatican fights to ‘free Virgin Mary from mafia’
Pope backs drive to end ‘deviant spirituality’ of Italian crime families who use Madonna as a shield of religious respectability

Julian Coman

06, Sep, 2020 @5:50 AM