Malta rejects spring bird hunting ban

Joseph Muscat, Malta’s prime minister, says hunters have been given a last chance after a proposed ban is narrowly defeated in referendum

The spring hunting of quail and turtle doves, an activity that is banned across Europe, will continue unabated in Malta after voters in a referendum rejected a proposed ban.

The historic referendum was decided on a razor thin margin, with just 2,220 more votes deciding against the ban out of a total of of 250,648 votes cast. The “yes” camp won 50.4% of the vote thanks to a strong showing for the pro-hunting contingent on the island of Gozo, which is part of Malta.

Polls before the vote on Saturday had shown a six-point lead for conservationists, who backed a ban.

Joseph Muscat, Malta’s prime minister, said the public had given a last chance for hunters to practise their tradition. “But hunters have to understand that the story has changed for them, totally. Practically half the people do not want spring hunting to continue,” he said. “They have to understand that they must respect the law in the spring hunting season that will open on Tuesday.”

BirdLife Malta, which led the campaign against spring hunting, described it as “missed opportunity to end the killing of birds in spring”.

The provisional result shows it’s a Yes win.A missed opportunity to end the killing of birds in spring which most people believe should stop

— BirdLife Malta (@BirdLife_Malta) April 12, 2015

Hunters are a politically powerful group in Malta, and the leaders of the two main political parties said before the vote that they did not support a ban on spring hunting.

The European court of justice gave Malta special permission to hunt quail and turtle doves in 2009, , ruling that a limited period should be allowed because hunters did not have enough birds to hunt in the autumn season.

According to government-compiled data based on hunters’ own reports, about 2,480 turtle doves and 1,688 quails were shot during the 2014 autumn season, the lowest number ever recorded. In the spring, 4,131 turtle doves, 38% of the permitted quota, and 637 quail were shot.

Saviour Balzan, an anti-hunting activist and managing editor of the English-language newspaper MaltaToday, said: “We did what we could. We didn’t do it for our personal ends. Today in 2015, we know that at least 49% cent of the electorate does not want spring hunting.”

The result may not reflect diehard support for hunters. Even anti-hunting activists have acknowledged that hunting has changed dramatically in Malta since the 1980s and early 1990s, when it was largely an unchecked and unregulated pastime.

Since Malta joined the EU, fines and penalties are doled out against people who illegally hunt protected birds, and the periods during which hunting is allowed have been curtailed.

“With only a narrow vote to continue to allow this cruel and unnecessary carnage, it is time for the Maltese government to demonstrate that it is determined to stamp out illegal hunting,” said Joe Duckworth, chief executive for the League Against Cruel Sports in the UK. “Enforcement must be improved and strengthened so that illegal hunters are caught and punished appropriately.”


Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Rome

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Malta braces for referendum over spring bird hunting
Vote could see the spring hunting of birds such as quail and turtle doves, which is outlawed in the rest of the EU, banned in Malta

Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Malta

10, Apr, 2015 @8:40 AM

Article image
Conservationists and marksmen of Malta battle over annual bird hunt
Hunters try to block referendum on traditional spring shoot, while British volunteers help patrol countryside to protect birds

Patrick Barkham in Malta

20, Apr, 2014 @4:41 PM

Article image
British birdwatchers trying to stop illegal killing of Europe's rarest birds in Malta embroiled in increasingly tense standoff with local hunters

British birdwatchers trying to stop the illegal killing of some of Europe's rarest birds in Malta have become embroiled in an increasingly tense standoff with local hunters

Matthew Weaver

30, Sep, 2008 @2:10 PM

Article image
Malta gives go ahead to shooting of 5,000 endangered turtle doves
Conservationists urge EU to take action against Malta for continuing the spring hunt despite the birds recently being added to ‘red list’ of species at risk of being wiped out

Patrick Barkham

16, Mar, 2016 @2:10 PM

Article image
Malta should consider moratorium on turtle dove hunting, says EU
European commission investigating violations of the EU bird directive after Malta allows 5,000 turtle doves to be shot, says Karmenu Vella

Arthur Neslen

03, May, 2016 @3:54 PM

Article image
Chris Packham: Malta is a bird hell
The BBC presenter talks of confrontations with hunters and police while making films to highlight the cruelty of the annual bird shoot

Patrick Barkham

28, Apr, 2014 @10:14 AM

Article image
Chris Packham cleared of assault in Malta after confronting bird hunters
BBC wildlife presenter calls on EU to push Malta towards adhering to European birds directive after case against him is dismissed

Patrick Barkham

20, Apr, 2017 @3:22 PM

Article image
France’s refusal to ban Sunday hunting angers anti-hunt campaigners
Tougher sentences to be imposed for those causing accidents but alcohol ban dismissed as ‘laughable’

Kim Willsher in Paris

09, Jan, 2023 @2:28 PM

Article image
Romania bans trophy hunting of brown bears, wolves, lynx and wild cats
Unexpected move reverses a trend that has seen increasing numbers of large carnivores shot by hunters each year since Romania’s accession to the European Union

Luke Dale-Harris

05, Oct, 2016 @3:08 PM

Article image
Ban on hunting birds with lead shot in EU wetlands hailed as ‘huge milestone’
Law comes into force in 30 countries in move campaigners hope will stop an estimated 1m waterbirds a year dying of lead poisoning

Phoebe Weston

15, Feb, 2023 @6:00 AM