Ebola: Liberia deaths ‘far higher than reported’ as officials downplay epidemic

Film-maker Sorious Samura, recently returned from Liberia, says Ebola is still not under control, with cultural practices and data problems masking the true extent of the epidemic

The true death toll from the Ebola epidemic is being masked by chaotic data collection and people’s reluctance to admit that their loved ones had the virus, according to one of west Africa’s most celebrated film-makers.

Sorious Samura, who has just returned from making a documentary on the crisis in Liberia, said it is very clear on the ground that the true number of dead is far higher than the official figures being reported by the World Health Organisation.

Liberia accounts for more than half of all the official Ebola deaths, with a total of 2,458. Overall, the number of dead across Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea has exceeded 4,500.

Samura, a television journalist originally from Sierra Leone, said the Liberian authorities appeared to be deliberately downplaying the true number of cases, for fear of increasing alarm in the west African country.

“People are dying in greater numbers than we know, according to MSF [Médecins sans Frontières] and WHO officials. Certain departments are refusing to give them the figures – because the lower it is, the more peace of mind they can give people. The truth is that it is still not under control.”

WHO has admitted that problems with data-gathering make it hard to track the evolution of the epidemic, with the number of cases in the capital, Monrovia, going under-reported. Efforts to count freshly dug graves had been abandoned.

Local culture is also distorting the figures. Traditional burial rites involve relatives touching the body – a practice that can spread Ebola – so the Liberian government has ruled that Ebola victims must be cremated.

“They don’t like this burning of bodies,” said Samura, whose film Living with Ebola premieres on 12 November on Al Jazeera English. “Before the government gets there they will have buried their loved ones and broken all the rules.”

Kim West of MSF admitted that calculating deaths was “virtually impossible”, adding that only when retrospective surveys were conducted would the true figure be known.

Samura believes sexual promiscuity among westerners could play a role in the virus’s spread abroad. Almost immediately after the outbreak was reported in March, Liberia’s health minister warned people to stop having sex because the virus was spread via bodily fluids as well as kissing.“I saw westerners in nightclubs, on beaches, guys picking up prostitutes,” he said. “Westerners who ought to know better are going to nightclubs and partying and dancing. It beggars belief.It’s scary.”

He said another striking feature was that the ineffectiveness of years of aid had been laid bare: “Money has poured in from the west, but it has gone to waste. Ebola should make us think about how the west gives aid to Africa; aid has not been used to create a system able to cope with this challenge. Ebola has exposed the fact it is not working. That money has gone to waste.”

A committee of MPs recently criticised the Department for International Development and the EU for failing to address the problem of aid being misappropriated. It said just £2.4m of £37m of aid had actually made its way to Liberia’s health ministry.

Contributor

Mark Townsend

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The bigger questions around the Ebola outbreak | @guardianletters
Letters: What are your human rights during quarantine? Is the emphasis on economic development in aid at the expense of the population? What about malaria?

19, Oct, 2014 @6:28 PM

Article image
World leaders 'failing to help' over Ebola outbreak in Africa

Médecins Sans Frontières chief claims response to catastrophe is 'almost zero', with nations most concerned with self protection

Lisa O'Carroll

19, Aug, 2014 @7:36 PM

Article image
Ebola crisis: three things Band Aid should really be singing about | Nick Dearden
Nick Dearden: Instead of more tired stereotypes of poor Africans, celebrities could highlight the geo-political problems that allowed the disease to spread

Nick Dearden

11, Nov, 2014 @10:30 AM

Article image
Cut in UK aid to Sierra Leone may have helped spread of Ebola, MPs say
International development select committee says it was wrong for UK to cut aid to Sierra Leone and Liberia by nearly one-fifth

Sarah Boseley, health editor

02, Oct, 2014 @6:54 AM

Article image
West Africa Ebola epidemic is 'out of control'

MSF warns that doctors are struggling to contain second wave of disease in region amid poor monitoring and communication

Sam Jones Global development correspondent

23, Jun, 2014 @3:34 PM

Article image
Ebola epidemic takes toll on business in quarantine zones and across Africa
Repercussions have radiated from far-flung villages to financial markets, and from rural farmers to urban dollar boys

Monica Mark in Kailahun

27, Aug, 2014 @4:47 PM

Article image
Response to Ebola epidemic in west Africa too slow, say scientists
Research in the Lancet Infectious Diseases journal suggests current efforts will not bring the outbreak under control

Sarah Boseley, health editor

23, Oct, 2014 @11:05 PM

Article image
Western aid is essential to prevent another Ebola outbreak, says thinktank
African nations most at risk are ranked near bottom of world health index

Daniel Boffey, policy editor

01, Nov, 2014 @11:20 PM

Article image
Soldiers deployed in Sierra Leone and Liberia to contain Ebola outbreak

Troops set up roadblocks to ensure that only health personnel can move in and out of the hardest-hit communities

Monica Mark, west Africa correspondent

05, Aug, 2014 @5:59 PM

Article image
Ebola epidemic: speeches are not enough, MSF chief tells Obama

Lisa O'Carroll

26, Sep, 2014 @10:51 AM