Comette family home damaged by egg-sized meteorite

Meteorite believed to be more than 4bn years old smashes through roof of home on outskirts of Paris

When your name is Comette you may get used to jokes about rockets and space and planets. But French schoolboy Hugo Comette, 11, had the last laugh when of all the places, in all the countries on Earth, a piece of rock from outer space landed on his home.

An egg-sized meteorite believed to be 4.57bn years old smashed through the roof of the Comette family home on the outskirts of Paris some time over the summer when everyone was away on holiday.

And there the rock, blackened by its journey through Earth's atmosphere stayed, buried in the roof insulation, until Hugo's mother, civil servant Martine Comette, 32, noticed the roof was leaking and called out someone to fix it.

The roofer took one look at the broken tile and told the Comettes that whatever had smashed their roof tile must have come from the sky. "It would have had to be superman to break a tile in this way," he said. It was only then that the meteorite, weighing 88g (3.5oz), was discovered.

Curious to know exactly what it was, Mrs Comette called out scientist Alain Carion, a mineral expert, who declared it an "exceptional" discovery.

"It's extremely rare. We have had only 50 or so meteorite falls in France over four centuries," Carion told journalists. "We have never found anything like it within an 80km radius of Paris before."

He said the Comettes' meteorite was a piece of chondrite that had come from the belt of asteroids between Mars and Jupiter. Most meteorites recovered on Earth are chondrites. They were formed when dust and small grains present in the early solar system created primitive asteroids. Chondrite meteors include dust believed to predate the formation of our solar system and to have come from elsewhere in the galaxy.

Although they have been told some meteorites sell for up to €1,000 (£860) a gramme, the Comettes say selling theirs is out of the question. "A piece of the history of space of which we know nothing, but which is fascinating, has fallen on us," Mrs Comette, an accountant at the French ministry of finance, told Le Parisien newspaper. "It's like a fairytale, and less likely than winning the lottery, we're told."

Not that the lump of rare chondrite Hugo Comette has been proudly showing off at school has convinced everyone. "I took it to school in a piece of kitchen roll in my satchel, but one friend said he only half believed me when I told him what it was," Hugo said. "He thought it looked like a piece of concrete."

Contributor

Kim Willsher in Paris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Russian meteorite: hunt for debris begins, but was it a comet?
Scientists say there are still many fragments to be found as debate starts over precise nature of celestial object

Howard Amos in Moscow

18, Feb, 2013 @4:44 PM

Article image
Meteorite strike in Nicaragua puzzles experts
Officials appeal for witnesses after residents report a loud boom but no one reports seeing the space rock streaking in the sky

Ian Sample

08, Sep, 2014 @6:28 PM

Article image
Fragments of ‘Valentine’s fireball’ meteorite fall in southern Italy
Object hit balcony in Matera and remnants in pristine condition – ‘almost as if we collected it directly from space’, says expert

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

19, Feb, 2023 @4:25 PM

Article image
Meteorite explodes over Russia: key questions answered
Hundreds of people in Chelyabinsk have been injured after a huge meteorite flared in the sky above the city, but what is it?

Stuart Clark

15, Feb, 2013 @12:27 PM

Article image
Researchers discover two new minerals on meteorite grounded in Somalia
‘Phenomenal’ finds are named elaliite and elkinstantonite, and Canadian scientists are analysing third mineral

Oliver Holmes

29, Nov, 2022 @1:22 PM

Article image
Meteorite footage captured thanks to Russian love of dashcams

Cameras on car dashboards have produced a series of clips showing bizarre traffic incidents on Russia's notorious roads

Howard Amos in Moscow

15, Feb, 2013 @6:58 PM

Article image
Hundreds hurt in Russia after meteorite falls to Earth

Ultranationalist politician suggests 10-tonne meteorite was in fact a new American weapon

Howard Amos in Moscow

15, Feb, 2013 @8:53 PM

Article image
Meteorite smashes into moon in largest lunar impact ever recorded

Rock travelling at 61,000 km/h punched a crater 40 metres wide and produced a flash that could be seen from Earth

Ian Sample, science correspondent

24, Feb, 2014 @4:24 PM

Article image
Russian meteorite fragments fetch stratospheric prices

But, with one small piece costing up to £6,500, how can buyers tell whether they are getting the genuine article?

Leo Hickman

18, Feb, 2013 @1:11 PM

Article image
Meteorite 'could have devastated northern UK'
Slight difference in time at which meteorite entered atmosphere could have resulted in widespread damage, say astronomers

Robin McKie, science editor, in Boston

16, Feb, 2013 @10:26 PM