Is this really China's biggest coward?

Jon Henley: Teacher Fan Meizhong admits to being a coward after leaving a classroom of pupils as the Sichuan earthquake struck

When last month's Sichuan earthquake struck, Fan Meizhong was teaching a literature class at Guangya high school in the town of Dujiangyan. "It's an earthquake," he shouted, before legging it out of the door, down the stairs and on to the playing field. On reaching the middle of the football pitch, Fan later confided to his blog, "I found none of my pupils were with me." And when, back in the classroom, those pupils - none of whom, thankfully, was harmed - asked why he had not tried to help them escape, he replied: "I have never been a brave man, and I'm only really concerned about myself."

Fan's refreshing frankness has sparked outrage in China, with bloggers dubbing him "Runner Fan" and demanding his dismissal. "But the fact is," the teacher told the Changjian Times, "at the instant of an earthquake, a teacher is weak, too. Neither the state nor the school taught me life-saving or rescue techniques. I was scared, and my instinctive response was to run."

Such candour is rare. History does not abound with tales of men happy to record that they turned tail and ran because they were frightened. Even J Bruce
Ismay, "the greatest coward in history", who as managing director of the White Star line abandoned the sinking Titanic as 1,500 of his passengers perished, never attempted such a bold justification of his actions. Cowardice is, in any case, a moral maze: how much courage did it take to be a conscientious objector?

Fiction, though, loves cowards: think Don Quixote; think Flashman; think Shaggy from Scooby Doo. Hemingway (he would) reckoned cowardice was merely "an inability to suspend the functioning of the imagination". But if, as Mark Twain said, "the human race is a race of cowards", you have to be a pretty brave one to actually admit it.


Jon Henley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sichuan quake: China's earthquake reconstruction to cost $150bn

Schools, housing for 3.9m and jobs on the agenda as repair proposals seek to redress quality shortfalls

Jonathan Watts in Beijing

14, Aug, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
China earthquake 'biggest disaster for children in seven years'

The Sichuan earthquake is the biggest disaster for the world's children in seven years, says Save the Children, as the overall death toll jumped above 51,000

Jonathan Watts in Beijing

22, May, 2008 @4:36 PM

Article image
Dujiangyan's residents turn anger against Chinese officials

Distress turns to anger at Chinese soldiers and officials over the response to the huge earthquake

Tania Branigan in Dujiangyan

13, May, 2008 @5:03 PM

Article image
Tania Branigan on China's gag on the angry families who lost children in the Sichuan earthquake

Thousands of schoolchildren died in the Sichuan earthquake. Their parents blame corrupt or incompetent builders and local officials, yet Beijing seems keener to gag the bereaved than punish the culprits. Report by Tania Branigan

Tania Branigan

25, Aug, 2008 @11:01 PM

Rescued Britons in China - 'Boulders and rocks were flying overhead'

Britons tell of Chinese rescue and how earthquake struck as they were visiting panda reserve

Matt Vegh in Wolong and Duncan Campbell

15, May, 2008 @11:29 PM

Chinese quake forced 3m children from homes

Sichuan earthquake biggest disaster for world's children in seven years, as death toll jumps above 51,000

Jonathan Watts in Beijing

22, May, 2008 @11:01 PM

China earthquake: In the rubble of a school, bodies everywhere - too many to count

Chinese quake has wiped out an entire community in Beichuan, where 8,000 people are still missing

Tania Branigan in Beichuan, China

16, May, 2008 @8:31 AM

Girl for mother pulled from rubble

Mother-to-be trapped under rubble for 50 hours after earthquake in Sichuan gives birth to healthy baby girl

David Wivell in Urumqi

18, Jun, 2008 @11:01 PM

China jails earthquake activist
Veteran dissident Huang Qi given three years for critical website articles about regime's response to Sichuan disaster

Associated Press in Beijing

23, Nov, 2009 @9:08 AM

Tremor injures 400 as flood risk grows

Latest aftershock worst since Sichuan triggering fresh mudslides and destroying 71,000 houses

Tania Branigan

25, May, 2008 @11:01 PM