Gore launches bruising attack on Bush over wiretapping

The former vice-president Al Gore launched a withering attack on the White House yesterday for authorising wiretaps without court oversight, and accused President George Bush of repeatedly breaking the law.

The former vice-president Al Gore launched a withering attack on the White House yesterday for authorising wiretaps without court oversight, and accused President George Bush of repeatedly breaking the law.

The strongly worded speech makes Mr Gore the most prominent political figure in America to weigh in on the wiretapping scandal. Mr Gore, who lost the 2000 election to Mr Bush following the intervention of the supreme court, also went further than other Democratic critics in accusing the president of wrongdoing.

The revelation last month in the New York Times that Mr Bush signed secret orders in 2002 authorising the National Security Agency to monitor the email and telephone calls of thousands of Americans has outraged members of Congress and the judiciary.

Mr Gore said yesterday that the decision to bypass the courts was part of a pattern of behaviour from the Bush administration of "indifference" to the constitution. "We still have much to learn about the NSA's domestic surveillance. What we do know about this pervasive wiretapping virtually compels the conclusion that the president of the United States has been breaking the law repeatedly and insistently," Mr Gore said in a speech delivered to mark Martin Luther King day.

"A president who breaks the law is a threat to the very structure of our government," he said.

Since the 2000 presidential elections, Mr Gore has occasionally used his peculiar position in American politics - he was defeated by Mr Bush despite winning more votes - to advance an agenda that is more liberal than the Democratic party leadership. He has been a far more outspoken critic of the Iraq war than most senior Democrats.

In yesterday's speech, Mr Gore also called for an independent counsel to investigate the secret wiretap programme. He ranked the operation with other controversial decisions by the administration in the war on terror, including its holding of "enemy combatants" indefinitely without trial, and its justification of harsh interrogation techniques.

"The disrespect embodied in these apparent mass violations of the law is part of a larger pattern of seeming indifference to the constitution that is deeply troubling to millions of Americans in both political parties," he said.

Mr Bush insists that he acted within the law and that Congress implicitly authorised the eavesdropping when it allowed the use of force in response to the 9/11 terror attacks. However, yesterday's broadside from Mr Gore increases the pressure on the White House to offer a fuller explanation of its decisions.

The Senate judiciary committee plans to hold hearings next month into the legality of the NSA eavesdropping, and the Republican chairman, Arlen Specter, has indicated that he is sceptical of the Bush administration's assertions that it acted within the law.


Suzanne Goldenberg in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Witty, confident, relaxed - yes, it's Al Gore
Speculation mounts that former presidential hopeful will run again.

Oliver Burkeman in New York

19, May, 2006 @11:04 PM

Article image
Gore: Bush is 'renegade rightwing extremist'
Al Gore has made his sharpest attack yet on the George Bush presidency, describing the current US administration as "a renegade band of rightwing extremists".

Oliver Burkeman and Jonathan Freedland

31, May, 2006 @12:07 PM

Bush and Gore may meet again
View from Washington: It is more than likely that George W Bush and Al Gore will face each other in the 2004 US electoral contest - again, writes Martin Kettle.

Martin Kettle

17, Nov, 2000 @2:44 PM

Leader: It's bush, or else it's Gore
The argument that Al Gore won Tuesday's American presidential election is at first glance overwhelming. The Democratic candidate campaigned tirelessly for the citizenry's support, barnstorming back and forward across the country again and again. His party launched an enormous get-out-the-vote effort with Jesse Jackson, the civil rights leader, knocking on doors in Pennsylvania and Mr Gore and his running mate, Joseph Lieberman, cajoling and pleading in Florida until the very last moment.


09, Nov, 2000 @2:15 AM

Out to gore the bullish Bush
Al Gore has had the best kind of experience that a presidential candidate could hope for, but Julian Glover explains why this may not be quite enough

Julian Glover

07, Nov, 2000 @11:14 AM

Catch the terrorists first, Gore tells Bush

Al Gore, the former US vice president, last night delivered a blistering attack on the Bush administration's possible invasion of Iraq, warning that the president risks derailing the war on terrorism by alienating allies.

David Teather in New York

24, Sep, 2002 @9:26 AM

Bush and Gore face Florida judgment day
Nearly two weeks of legal and political warfare are set to reach a climax today when the Florida supreme court hears legal arguments from George W Bush and Al Gore which could settle the outcome of the disputed US presidential election.

Martin Kettle in Washington

20, Nov, 2000 @11:52 AM

Gore and Bush square up for battle
Fresh from decisive victories over their party opponents in this week's Super Tuesday primary contests, Al Gore and George W Bush shifted decisively into presidential election mode yesterday, beginning an eight-month battle for the hearts and minds of middle America in the race to succeed Bill Clinton.

Martin Kettle in Washington

09, Mar, 2000 @2:17 AM

Leader: In praise of Al Gore
Leader: F Scott Fitzgerald's principle that "there are no second acts in American lives" does not apply to Al Gore.


23, May, 2006 @11:03 PM

Article image
Al Gore and Tipper announce split
Love story ends for former US vice-president and co-founder of Parents Music Resource Centre

Ewen MacAskill in Washington

01, Jun, 2010 @7:23 PM