Belgium confronts its colonial demons

Historians will investigate charges of Congo genocide

More than a century after King Leopold II of Belgium claimed Congo as his personal colony, an unprecedented investigation into his country's murky colonial past and long-ignored allegations of genocide is to be carried out.

Doubtless to the fury of Belgium's dwindling band of "old colonials", the state-funded Royal Museum for Central Africa - formerly known as the Museum of the Belgian Congo - has commissioned some of the country's most eminent historians to give the public the one thing they have been deprived of for so long: the truth.

Shocking claims - often well documented - that 10 million Congolese were either murdered or worked to death by Leopold's private army, that women were systematically raped, that people's hands were cut off and that the local populace endured kidnapping, looting and village burnings, have never been the subject of serious debate in Belgium, let alone brought an apology.

Many of these allegations are set out in a book called King Leopold's Ghost by the American author Adam Hochschild. When it was published in Belgium in 1999 it outraged the country's historians but failed to bring about a genuine period of reflection. Controversially, Hochschild compared the death toll in the Belgian-administered Congo to the Holocaust and Stalin's purges.

"We will look at these claims, we will investigate them, and by 2004 we will attempt to provide an answer to Hochschild's book," Guido Gryseels, the director of the museum, said. "We cannot avoid answering these questions. It has become too much of an issue. Everyone raises it all the time, and we don't know what to say."

The investigation will force Belgium to confront its colonial demons and tackle a subject that has been taboo ever since the Welsh-born explorer Henry Morton Stanley secured the colony, rich in rubber and ivory, for Leopold in 1885.

The investigatory panel, likely to be led by Professor Jean-Luc Vellut, will start work in the next two months and present its findings in 2004 (the centenary of Stanley's death) as part of an exhibition at the museum.

If Congo is Belgium's forgotten skeleton, then the museum is its neglected cupboard. An imposing palace near Brussels built by Leopold with money he made in Congo to showcase a place he never visited, it is crammed with millions of objects brought back in dubious circumstances. Tatty stuffed animals vie for attention with display cases crammed with butterflies, fish and African tribal art, but the museum, like much of Belgium itself, is frozen in a colonial time warp.

It commemorates the Force Publique officers, now accused of barbarism. Of the cruelty and suffering endured by the Congolese people there is no mention.

It is a desire to modernise the museum and drag it out of its one-sided, politically incorrect past that has prompted the investigation.

"The museum hasn't changed for 44 years," Mr Gryseels conceded. "It has a colonial spirit to it. As you walk in there is a statue [of a black boy looking up at a white missionary] with the legend 'Belgium brings civilisation to the Congo'. The message of the museum needs to change so it doesn't only reflect the view of Belgium before 1960 [when Congo became independent]. We need African views too, so that visitors can make up their own minds."

More than a century may have passed since Leopold acquired Congo, but Belgium remains acutely sensitive about its culpability.

"It is a reality which touches the deepest part of the Belgian soul," Mr Gryseels said. "We really haven't coped with it, and the revelations came as a real shock. We were brought up knowing that we brought civilisation and good to Africa. [Allegations of brutality] weren't taught in schools."

The investigation will be only the first step towards coming to terms with the past. Disbelief about the seriousness of the allegations and a feeling that foreign historians are over-influenced by works such as Joseph Conrad's Heart Of Darkness, in which Kurtz has African heads on spikes in his front garden, runs deep - even among the historians invited to investigate the matter.

"To compare it with the Holocaust or Auschwitz is an insult to the truth," Prof Vellut said. "We need to put our history in perspective and be cautious."

Many of the specific allegations cannot, he conceded, be disputed, but he argued that discovering the precise scale of the atrocities would be difficult. "Statistics for that period are very unreliable. One hardly knew what the population was. You can see figures which make the Jewish slaughter pale in comparison. Who knows whether 10 million or 15 million Congolese were killed?"


Andrew Osborn in Brussels

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Belgium exhumes its colonial demons
More than a century after King Leopold II of Belgium claimed Congo as his personal colony, an unprecedented investigation into Belgium's murky colonial past and long-ignored allegations of genocide is to be held.

Andrew Osborn in Brussels

13, Jul, 2002 @4:48 PM

Congo villagers tell of a life plagued by killers on all sides
The suffering of Albert Tambwe and his family is almost unbearable. Twenty of his relatives - including two of his children - were murdered or died of disease during the civil war in the Democratic Republic of Congo, and some of the women in his family were raped. Mr Tambwe, his wife and young child are emaciated from malnutrition and disease.

By Chris McGreal in Kongolo, Katanga

09, Aug, 2001 @1:57 PM

Article image
Belgium begins to face brutal colonial legacy of Leopold II
A century after millions died in Congo, attitudes (and street names) are changing

Daniel Boffey Brussels

23, Nov, 2019 @3:35 PM

Article image
Belgium unveils plans to return DRC artworks stolen during colonial rule
Pledge marks first time items will be returned to Congolese ownership without waiting for requests

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

07, Jul, 2021 @3:38 PM

Article image
Belgium comes to terms with 'human zoos' of its colonial past
Sixty years ago, Belgium set up a live display of people from Congo for the 1958 world fair. Now the country is rethinking that legacy

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

16, Apr, 2018 @4:00 AM

Article image
Belgium forced to reckon with Léopold's legacy and its colonial past
African-Belgians are angered by what they see as country’s refusal to engage with the issue

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

12, Jun, 2020 @9:26 AM

Article image
Belgium to return Patrice Lumumba’s gold tooth in bid to atone for colonial crimes
Relic of the murdered Republic of Congo leader will be returned to his family as Brussels confronts its bloody past in Africa

Jason Burke Africa correspondent

18, Jun, 2022 @2:03 PM

Congo's colonial ghost | Khaled Diab
Khaled Diab: As we approach the 50th anniversary of independence, how successful has Congo's post-colonial experience been?

Khaled Diab

21, Apr, 2010 @12:30 PM

Haunted by colonial history
The prime minister of India warned that, unless Pakistan reined in its Kashmir guerrillas, there'd be war. The president of Pakistan solicited the "good offices" of the United States - and sent in his guerrillas anyway. Bloody miscalculation, bloody incompetence all round. But that was 1965, number two out of four conflicts that have racked the subcontinent since independence.

03, Jan, 2002 @3:00 PM

Article image
Why Rwanda said adieu to French

The central African state says its switch to teaching in English is aimed at increasing access to the global economy and is not linked to fraught relations with its former colonial master

Chris McGreal

16, Jan, 2009 @1:08 PM