Senate musical chairs: California prepares for political battle over Feinstein vacancy

An ‘avalanche’ of candidates, including Katie Porter, Barbara Lee and Adam Schiff, announce candidacy for California seat

Dianne Feinstein, the 89-year-old who served as California senator for three decades, has yet to announce her retirement. But the contest to succeed her in two years is already shaping into a bitter battle.

After months of shadow campaigning and whispered political leveraging, earlier this month, Katie Porter – the whiteboard-wielding progressive congresswoman – became the first to officially declare her candidacy. Barbara Lee, the old-school leftist with an ardent antiwar record, has reportedly told colleagues she is running. Adam Schiff, icon of the anti-Trump liberal resistance, has reportedly begun prepping for a run. Silicon valley congressman Ro Khanna is expected to jump in as well.

In California’s open primary system, it’s possible, and likely, that two Democrats will face-off in the 2024 Senate race. Until then, voters may need to brace for what is sure to be a protracted, pricey two years of campaigning.

And we’re likely to see an “avalanche” of candidates to come, said Wendy Schiller, a political science professor at Brown University.

Porter’s early announcement drew criticism for coming not only before Feinstein had announced her retirement, but also amid a spate of severe storms in California. Following Porter’s announcement, Schiff pointedly used his campaign fundraising list to raise money for flood victims.

Katie Porter reads a book in the House Chamber during the fourth day of Speaker elections.
Katie Porter reads a book in the House Chamber during the fourth day of Speaker elections. Photograph: Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

But Porter’s declaration also earned praise, for publicly owning up to the political plots that many ambitious California lawmakers have so far been devising in the dark. Concerns about Feinstein’s cognition and fitness to serve have been circulating for years, and quite a few candidates have been eyeing her seat for just as long.

“The sooner you can get out the door and start talking to donors and consolidate support, the stronger you’ll be,” Schiller said. Porter already had $8m in her campaign war chest after beating back a Republican challenger in her competitive Orange county district, south-east of Los Angeles and managed to raise more than a million in the first day after announcing her run for Feinstein’s seat. Schiff has nearly $21m.

Meanwhile Lee, a beloved Bay Area politician who has served in congress since 1998, hasn’t had to do a lot of fundraising so far. She’s got just over $50,000 on reserve. In a state that is dominated by the Democratic party, the ultimate victor could boil down to who has the most funding. And how each candidate manages to differentiate themselves from fellow lawmakers who ultimately agree on most major policy decisions.

Barbara Lee speaks during a press conference with other members on the Inflation Reduction Act.
Barbara Lee speaks during a press conference with other members on the Inflation Reduction Act. Photograph: Bonnie Cash/UPI/REX/Shutterstock

“They’re not going to run on very slight policy differences,” Schiller said.“They’re going to run on who will be the strongest, most energetic – and they will use that word, energetic – advocate for the state of California.”

Porter, who is a protege of senator Elizabeth Warren (and has already been endorsed by the senator) has built a reputation as a sharp interrogator at congressional hearings, and staunch defender of women’s rights. Her victories in purple Orange county will also have trained her to persevere in politically chequered California.

Meanwhile, Schiff became a household name after serving as lead impeachment manager pursuing Donald Trump for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. While Schiff has earned the ire of criminal justice and immigrant rights advocates in California for his “tough on crime” record as a California legislator prior to being elected to Congress, he will likely be received as a more centrist and moderate alternative to the more leftist contenders.

Adam Schiff speaks to members of the media after final hearing of the January 6 panel.
Adam Schiff speaks to members of the media after final hearing of the January 6 panel. Photograph: Carolyn Kaster/AP

Lee, the only member of both chambers of Congress to vote against the Authorization for Use of Military Force after 9/11, can rely on her unwavering progressive record. “I can personally attest to her courageous, bold, principled stances,” said Aimee Allison, president and founder of She the People, an organisation aimed at boosting the political power of women of colour.

In the Bay Area, which has historically been the state’s political powerhouse and produced a spate of governors and senators including House speaker Nancy Pelosi, Feinstein, governor Gavin Newsom and vice-president Kamala Harris, Lee has strong support and has earned her bonafides working with the Black Panthers, then as a lawmaker pushing to limit defense spending, enacting gun control measures, climate legislation and protections for women’s rights.

When Newsom was considering whom to appoint to the Senate seat vacated by Harris, Lee was a top contender. Now Allison and many other Californians are hoping to see a Black woman ascend to the Senate – at a time when there are none in the chamber. “Black women are the drivers of so many Democratic wins throughout the country at every level,” Allison said. That they aren’t represented at all in the Senate “is a travesty”, she said.

Ro Khanna questions the panel during a House Committee on oversight and reform hearing.
Ro Khanna questions the panel during a House Committee on oversight and reform hearing. Photograph: REX/Shutterstock

It’s still unclear whether Khanna will run against Lee if she declares – having hinted that he might make way for his fellow Bay Area progressive if she runs. Khanna, who has positioned himself to run for either Senate or the presidency in recent years with political tours around the US, has branded himself as someone who can bridge populism and the big tech that dominates his Silicon Valley district.

Other potential contenders will make themselves known soon. Markedly missing from the field so far is a Latino candidate, in a state where 40% of residents are Latinx. Alex Padilla, the state’s junior senator, is the first Latino senator elected from California.

Some politicos think Newsom himself may declare a run – even as others speculate that he is positioning himself for a presidential run.

Feinstein still hasn’t said she’ll retire. But since Porter announced, “we’re all focused on the Senate race of 2024 – you can’t put that back in the box”, Allison said. “So the people who are serious about running for Senate – they’ve got to get started.”


Maanvi Singh

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
After Dianne Feinstein: as a political giant steps down, California weighs its future
As the state’s longest serving senator prepares to retire, the new leadership will determine the trajectory for the Democratic party

Nicholas Schou in Santa Barbara

26, Mar, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
'She represents the past': a Senate hug symbolizes California's Dianne Feinstein fatigue
The senator’s response to the supreme court hearings has sparked calls for her retirement. Many of her progressive colleagues have sought it for years

Vivian Ho in San Francisco

17, Oct, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
California senator Dianne Feinstein, 89, announces she will not seek re-election
Feinstein, who has sat in US Senate since 1992, sets off race among Democrats to succeed to vacant seat

Maanvi Singh in Oakland, California

14, Feb, 2023 @10:40 PM

Article image
Adam Schiff, lead prosecutor of Trump’s first impeachment, declares Senate run
California congressman makes play for Dianne Feinstein’s seat, which is being eyed by at least three other candidates

Maanvi Singh and agencies

26, Jan, 2023 @7:55 PM

Article image
Boy meets Congress: Ben Savage, star of 90s sitcom, to run for California seat
Actor is vying for Los Angeles district represented by Adam Schiff, who is competing for Dianne Feinstein’s US Senate post

Dani Anguiano and agencies

07, Mar, 2023 @10:10 PM

Article image
Dianne Feinstein to step down as top Democrat on Senate judiciary panel
California lawmaker, who has held position for four years, has faced growing opposition from progressives

Maanvi Singh and agencies

24, Nov, 2020 @1:26 AM

Article image
Gavin Newsom’s political fate in balance as polls close in California recall
Early returns indicate a strong showing from Democratic voters in the closely watched race with national ramifications

Maanvi Singh in Oakland

15, Sep, 2021 @12:31 AM

Article image
Californians vote in recall election as polls show Newsom holding favor – as it happened
Data from FiveThirtyEight shows about 57% of likely voters oppose removing the governor from office

Maanvi Singh (now) and Joan E Greve (earlier)

15, Sep, 2021 @12:12 AM

Article image
Molly Jong-Fast: calls for Dianne Feinstein to resign not sexist or ageist
California senator absent for weeks as Democrats and progressives eye effect on pace of confirmations of liberal judges

Martin Pengelly in New York

24, Apr, 2023 @4:54 PM

Article image
Dianne Feinstein: oldest serving senator says she ‘hasn’t been gone’ despite absence
The 89-year-old legislator insisted she had been working when questioned by reporters on Tuesday after being gone for three months

Maanvi Singh and Abené Clayton

17, May, 2023 @1:30 AM