Ohio train derailment reveals need for urgent reform, workers say

Unions say rail companies’ desire for increased profits is driving up safety risks – and more accidents will happen without action

US railroad workers say the train derailment in Ohio, which forced thousands of residents to evacuate and is now spreading a noxious plume of carcinogenic chemicals across the area, should be an “eye-opening” revelation for Congress and “an illustration of how the railroads operate, and how they’re getting away with a lot of things”.

Workers and union officials cited the Norfolk Southern Railway derailment in early February as a glaring example of why safety reforms to the industry – which include providing workers with paid sick leave – need to be made.

Thirty-eight cars on the train derailed in the town of East Palestine, near the Pennsylvania border, including 11 cars carrying hazardous materials that incited an evacuation order, a controlled release of chemicals, and fears of harmful chemical exposure to residents, wildlife and waterways.

Unions and rail companies have been at loggerheads for years over new contracts that would address what workers describe as poor working conditions, and would provide paid sick days amid grueling schedules caused by labor cuts.

“Without a change in the working conditions, without better scheduling, without more time off, without a better work-life balance, the railroad is going to suffer,” said Ron Kaminkow, the general secretary of Railroad Workers United, an Amtrak engineer in Reno, Nevada, and the vice-president of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (Blet) local 51. “It’s just intrinsic, with short staffing. Corners get cut and safety is compromised.”

Greg Regan, president of the AFL-CIO’s transportation trades department, said the loss of workers in recent years, which has coincided with record profits for railroad corporations, was the driving force for deteriorating conditions on US railroads.

The railroad industry workforce plummeted from over 1 million workers in the 1950s to fewer than 150,000 in 2022, with a loss of 40,000 railroad jobs between November 2018 and December 2020. The six major railroad corporations that have yet to agree to provide workers with paid sick days reported over $22bn in profits, and spent more than $20bn on stock buybacks and shareholder dividends last year.

Regan said the derailment in Ohio was an example of why these working-condition issues need to be addressed.

“It increases a lot of risk in what is a very dangerous industry. When things go wrong there can be very tragic consequences,” added Regan.

The corporations are also opposing reforms to implement mandatory participation to an anonymous close-call reporting system so workers can report safety concerns without fear of reprisal and identify problems before they result in accidents, said Leo McCann, chair of the rail labor division of transportation trades department.

“It’s kind of an eye-opener,” McCann said of the Ohio derailment. “It’s an illustration of how the railroads operate and how they’re getting away with a lot of things.”

Workers criticized the decision by Congress and the Biden administration to impose a tentative new contract agreement on all railroad unions, despite more than half of represented members voting to reject it due to the lack of paid sick days.

The majority of workers in precision railroad scheduling systems – operational systems focused on cutting costs – currently have no paid sick days and face attendance points for taking time off, which could result in termination.

Workers have complained that disciplinary attendance systems, coupled with drastic staffing cuts, have diminished morale, incentivized workers to continue working through illness or fatigue and increased safety risks.

On 2 February, all 12 railroad unions issued a resolution demanding paid sick days for railroad workers. Bernie Sanders and Republican senator Mike Braun held a press conference with union representatives on 9 February to add further pressure to corporations to provide workers with at least seven paid sick days.

The renewed push comes shortly after CSX Transportation announced it came to an agreement with two unions representing 5,000 railroad workers to provide four days of paid sick leave to all workers and allow workers to use up to three personal leave days for sick leave.

“The next step is to make sure we bring other railroads to the table and hopefully get a resolution,” said Regan. “This is the worst relationship that has been between the railroads and their workers in my career.” He said the tension had been exacerbated by the rail companies’ determination to increase profits by cutting staff.

“When you’re going to treat your employees that way, to continue to try to squeeze as many pennies out of each individual worker as you possibly can, without any regard for their wellbeing, you’re going to have really contentious bargaining sessions like we had last year,” he said.

“The railroad companies do not want to actually participate. They’re just anti-regulatory in their mind, but that’s not the case here: it’s about safety, and to ensure workers can go home to their families at night and not have a tragedy happen to them,” added McCann.

“The railroads are more interested in profitability and keeping their return on investment up and their numbers down so they can satisfy Wall Street, and they just live behind this shield hoping nothing will happen.”


Michael Sainato

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘We just need answers’: distrust grows in Ohio town after toxic train derailment
Residents of East Palestine grapple with mixed safety messages two weeks after leak of hazardous chemicals from train

Tom Perkins in East Palestine, Ohio

19, Feb, 2023 @8:30 AM

Article image
What do we know about the Ohio train derailment and toxic chemical leak?
At least five hazardous chemicals released in East Palestine train crash, as residents fear long-term effects

Lauren Aratani

15, Feb, 2023 @4:53 PM

Article image
US railroad workers prepare for strike as rail companies see record profits
As rail companies see record profits and Biden’s recommendations fall flat, unions call for improved rules – or else

Michael Sainato

14, Sep, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
‘Referred to as inmates by managers’: DHL workers push to unionize US hub
Former manager says company managers referred to themselves as ‘wardens’ as they sought to frustrate unionization effort

Michael Sainato

03, Apr, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
Leaked audio reveals US rail workers were told to skip inspections as Ohio crash prompts scrutiny to industry
Exclusive: employee says manager told her to stop marking cars for repair, as Ohio derailment brings hard look at industry’s record of blocking safety rules

Michael Sainato

03, Mar, 2023 @9:00 AM

Article image
US meatpacking workers face new hazard: threat of deportation by Ice
In industry where one-third of workers are immigrants, Ice’s largest raid at an Ohio plant strikes fear in local communities

Mike Elk in Pittsburgh

29, Jun, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
US rail companies grant paid sick days after public pressure in win for unions
Leading railroads give four paid sick days after years in which workers weren’t allowed to call in sick the morning of their shift

Steven Greenhouse

01, May, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
Biden asks US Congress to block railroad strike that could ‘devastate economy’
With 9 December deadline fast approaching, business groups also push US government to intervene in labor dispute before holidays

Dominic Rushe and agencies

29, Nov, 2022 @1:24 AM

Article image
‘Joe Biden blew it’: rail unions decry plan to impose deal through Congress
Workers could be prevented by congressional decree from striking over paid sick leave and quality-of-life issues

Michael Sainato

30, Nov, 2022 @5:49 PM

Article image
‘Crafting an illusion’: US rail firms’ multimillion-dollar PR push
Norfolk Southern, the company behind the Ohio train crash, and other rail firms spent millions on marketing and lobbying

Adam Lowenstein

27, Feb, 2023 @7:00 AM