Texas tragedy highlights migrants’ perilous journey to cross US border

The number of migrant deaths in 2021 was 650, a stark reminder of the human cost of US immigration policies

The deaths of 50 migrants – traveling from Mexico, Guatemala and Honduras – in terrible conditions in Texas has cast a spotlight on the immense risks people are willing to take to cross the US border in search of a better financial life or escaping violence in their native countries.

Laura Peña, the legal director of the Texas Civil Rights Project’s Beyond Borders program, represents asylum seekers at the border. Responding to the tragedy in San Antonio, she said both the Texas governor, Greg Abbott, and President Biden have “utterly failed people who are trying to seek safety by crossing the border”.

“The closure of borders are forcing people to take more dangerous routes. That’s just the facts. It’s resulted in thousands of deaths across the border … And it’s a direct result of these efforts to harden the border and criminalize people instead of investing in processing – simple processing of people who are trying to seek asylum and refuge at our ports of entry at our borders.”

The processes Peña is referring to are the same ones used to allow more than 3,000 Ukrainian refugees to enter the US at the border of Mexico.

She added: “We’ve been advocating for a dignified, humane process at the border, where people are not forced to risk their lives. We’ve seen the ability of the federal government to do that. We saw all the resources come to bear for our Ukrainian brothers and sisters, rapid humane processing at the border. But when it comes to Black and brown migrants, those same benefits are completely stripped away. They are not afforded across the board. It’s the underlying racism, and how and where both the federal and the state governments choose to militarize.”

On Tuesday, Biden called the deaths “horrifying and heartbreaking”.

“While we are still learning all the facts about what happened and the Department of Homeland Security has the lead for the investigation, initial reports are that this tragedy was caused by smugglers or human traffickers who have no regard for the lives they endanger and exploit to make a profit.

“Exploiting vulnerable individuals for profit is shameful, as is political grandstanding around tragedy, and my administration will continue to do everything possible to stop human smugglers and traffickers from taking advantage of people who are seeking to enter the United States between ports of entry.”

The San Antonio fire chief, Charles Hood, said the people found were “hot to the touch”, suffering from heatstroke and heat exhaustion.

The peak of summer in San Antonio, where temperatures remain consistently in the 90s or higher, is no deterrent to those seeking work or fleeing persecution. Nor is the prospect of being discovered by border patrol agents. The result of the treacherous journey, however, is the gruesome image of stacks of bodies.

The number of migrant deaths in 2021 was 650, the most since 2014. The figure is a stark reminder of the human cost of US immigration policies, which generally limit the number of migrants able to seek asylum.

Congressman Joaquín Castro, who represents the district that covers San Antonio, called for ending Title 42, the pandemic-era policy invoked by the Trump administration that allows for turning away migrants without offering them the chance to seek humanitarian protection ostensibly to prevent the spread of contagious diseases like Covid-19.

Castro argued that was an immediate aid to the infrastructure of US immigration, which has been overwhelmed.

The tragedy in San Antonio tonight, the loss of life, is horrific. My prayers are with the victims, their families and the survivors being treated in our community. May God bless them.

We must end Title 42 which has put desperate, oppressed people in grave danger of death. https://t.co/P0l8YmtHmq

— Joaquin Castro (@JoaquinCastrotx) June 28, 2022

More changes to US immigration law are imminent. The conservative-majority supreme court is also set to rule on Trump’s “Remain in Mexico” policy, which forces asylum seekers from Mexico to return home while awaiting the result of their pending immigration cases. Advocates argue the policy makes migrants face a forced return to the unsafe and vulnerable conditions from which they were escaping.

And to avoid that, advocates say, migrants are willing to endure extremely dangerous conditions and risk everything in hopes of making the journey across the US border with Mexico.

Biden tried to end the policy upon taking office, but was unsuccessful.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) said: “If the supreme court prevents the Biden administration from ending Remain in Mexico, it will enshrine a new legacy for the United States – a legacy of turning its back on international commitments and sending people directly into harm’s way.”

Though Monday’s grim discovery stood among the deadliest tragedies involving migrants, it is not the first of its kind in San Antonio. In 2017, 10 men traveling by tractor-trailer died, having gone without water, food and air conditioning for hours.

Further south in Brooks county, Texas, 10 migrants traveling by van died after crashing into a utility pole last August.

In Houston, six migrants died in an SUV after being chased by police through rainy weather in 2019.

Advocates have long said that those episodes illustrate the risks migrants are willing to take to access the US and leave behind uncertain lives in their native countries.

The Texas senator Ted Cruz and Governor Greg Abbott quickly blamed Biden for the most recent deaths in San Antonio. Abbott said: “These deaths are on Biden. They are a result of his deadly open border policies. They show the deadly consequences of his refusal to enforce the law.”

The condemnation of the president comes after members of the Texas GOP criticized Democrats such as gubernatorial candidate Beto O’Rourke for calling for more meaningful gun control measures after the shooting deaths of 19 children and two of their teachers at a school in Uvalde.

Following news of the dead in San Antonio, O’Rourke echoed calls for expanding avenues for legal migration to discourage human smuggling rings responsible for organizing such dangerous trips across the border.

Contributor

Erum Salam

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mexico to deport up to 500 migrants who tried to cross US border
US briefly shuts crossing and fires teargas to repel groups of people including children

Staff and agencies

26, Nov, 2018 @8:27 AM

Article image
Fight over border intensifies as Texas governor pledges more razor wire
Greg Abbott says he will defy Biden and US supreme court and install more concertina wire to try to prevent migrant crossings

Erum Salam

26, Jan, 2024 @6:14 PM

Article image
Under the bridge: migrants held in El Paso tell of dust, cold and hunger
In a Texas border town, migrants subjected to Trump’s hardline approach are enduring appalling conditions

Ed Pilkington and Edwin Delgado in El Paso, Texas

31, Mar, 2019 @12:08 PM

Article image
The numbers game: how migrants at the border await their fate
On the Mexican side of the Rio Grande, the mysterious ‘La Lista’ holds enormous power over matters of life and death

Bryan Mealer in Matamoros, Mexico

01, Jul, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
‘A storm is coming’: migrants stuck on US-Mexico border as temperatures plummet
Trump’s pandemic-era immigration restrictions lock migrants on both sides of the border in perilous situations

Justo Robles in El Paso, Texas, and Valerie Gonzalez in Matamoros, Mexico

23, Dec, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Is there a crisis at the border? Advocates in Texas say it's 'political manipulation'
The Texas governor has sent troops to fortify the border while advocates say the immigration numbers are being politicized

Nina Lakhani in Mission and McAllen, Texas

19, Mar, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Haiti deportations justified because of Covid, Biden homeland secretary says
As pressure remains over events at Texas border, Alejandro Mayorkas promises investigation of use of horses to round up migrants

Amanda Holpuch

26, Sep, 2021 @4:42 PM

Article image
Trump’s border wall and the slow decay of American soil | Carlos Sanchez
The ‘big, beautiful wall’ has kept US citizens away from the no man’s land it created – and in effect ceded the territory to Mexico

Carlos Sanchez

05, Jan, 2022 @4:00 PM

Article image
Texas detention camp swells fivefold with migrant children
The Tornillo camp originally had a capacity to house 400 children temporarily, now it has 2,400 beds and will remain open at least until the end of the year

Edwin Delgado in Tornillo, Texas

03, Oct, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Fear, confusion, despair: the everyday cruelty of a border immigration court
At a federal immigration court in Texas asylum seekers wait in limbo as a result of Trump’s policies

Adam Gabbatt in El Paso

26, Jul, 2019 @5:00 AM