Trump ignores Farage – and risks midterm elections farrago – with insistence on big lie

Analysis: His British friend tried to help but the former president did not want to forget his voter fraud obsession and focus on the future. CPAC loved it but Republicans hoping to take Congress know they are courting disaster

The sagest advice given to Donald Trump all week came from a man who is neither a Republican nor an American.

Nigel Farage, the British politician, broadcaster and demagogue whose Brexit campaign coincided with Trump’s rise to power, warned his old pal against endlessly fixating on the 2020 election.

“This message of a stolen election, if you think about it, is actually a negative backward looking message,” Farage told the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) in Orlando, Florida.

“There is a better, more positive message the Republican party needs to embrace and it’s this: ‘We are going state by state, vote by vote to make sure that America has the best, the cleanest, the fairest election system anywhere in the western world.’”

Urging an end to the “big lie” obsession is heresy at places like CPAC, the Woodstock of the red meat right. Perhaps no pro-Trump Republican would dare breathe it to the former president, lest he slap them with a demeaning nickname, endorse a primary opponent or blackball them from his luxury Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida.

But Farage, as foreigner and fellow traveller, may have felt liberated to speak an inconvenient truth: that endlessly re-litigating the last election with false claims of voter fraud could prove a serious liability for Republicans in November’s midterms.

The former UK Independence party and Brexit party leader went on: “That negative anger must be turned into a positive. You’ve got to offer the voters of this country a shining city on the hill. You’ve got to give them a vision. People want dreams, people want hopes, and the deliverers of that message are you guys.”

The audience sounded receptive enough. And while some CPAC speakers did promulgate “the big lie” – Ohio Senate hopeful Josh Mandel declared, “I want to say it very clearly and very directly: I believe this election was stolen from Donald J Trump” – they generally gave greater emphasis to winning Congress in 2022 and, of course, Trump returning to the White House in 2024.

Jim Jordan, an Ohio congressman and close Trump ally, declared: “I believe President Trump is going to run again … I think if he runs, he’s going to win.”

But the annual CPAC straw poll testing who should get the Republican nomination raised more questions than answers. Of course Trump won with more votes than everyone else combined. But his 59% was not quite the overwhelming show of force he might have hoped for in what is usually the capital of Trumpistan.

There is now a clear alternative. Ron DeSantis, the governor of Florida, finished second on 28%, well clear of Mike Pompeo, the former secretary of state, on 2%.

In a separate poll where Trump was removed from the equation, DeSantis won by a landslide 61%.

On the other hand, Florida is DeSantis’s home state, so he might expect to punch above his weight here. The governor gave a well received speech on Thursday that notably failed to mention Trump. But the audience for Trump’s address on Saturday was appreciably bigger and brimming with “Trump 2024” badges and caps.

Even those sporting DeSantis regalia were not quite ready to back him. David Duffy, 57, a retired insurance worker sporting a giant “DeSantisLand” flag, said: “We want to keep President Trump as our president. We believe he still is our president and, with DeSantis being 42 years old, we want to give him a little bit more time.”

Asked for her 2024 preference, Marnie Allen, wearing a “DeSantisLand” cap, said: “Trump, only because I owe him. I think we all owe him to make up for the disasters and because he’s going to go in with a vengeance this time and take care of our fourth level of government: career bureaucrats. He will go in this time and he will take a machete to them.”

Nigel Farage speaks in Orlando.
Nigel Farage speaks in Orlando. Photograph: Chris duMond/REX/Shutterstock

The 51-year-old from Orlando, who works in higher education, felt compelled to add: “Not a real machete, of course, but a figurative machete.”

Unless something dramatic happens – a criminal indictment in New York, say – the nomination remains Trump’s to lose. On Saturday he dropped his strongest hint yet that he does intend to pursue it.

He clearly did not get Farage’s memo. Trump told the audience: “The Rinos [Republicans In Name Only] and certain weak Republican politicians want to ignore election integrity also but we cannot ignore it. We have to fix it. Make no mistake, they [Democrats] will try to do it again in ’22 and ’24, and we cannot let them do that.

“And the way we [let them do that] is to come to a very powerful conclusion as to what happened in 2020. We stand down to stop talking about it, we stop making Americans aware of the cheating and corruption that went on. That’s really saying, ‘It’s OK, you can do it again.’ We can’t let that happen.”

The slapping sound you heard was a hundred Republican midterm candidates planting their hands on their foreheads. Trump is coming to a district near you, with a big lie to tell. It remains Democrats’ best hope of a midterm miracle.


David Smith in Orlando, Florida

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘It’s time to move on’: have the US midterms finally loosened Trump’s grip on the Republican party?
After the party came up short in another election, Ron DeSantis may be poised to become its new leader

Chris McGreal in Columbus, Ohio and David Smith in Washington

13, Nov, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Trump announces 2024 run nearly two years after inspiring deadly Capitol riot
Twice-impeached ex-president makes election announcement despite shaky midterms and surge from rival Ron DeSantis

Lauren Gambino in Washington and Martin Pengelly in New York

16, Nov, 2022 @4:33 AM

Article image
Trump to tell CPAC he is Republican 'presumptive 2024 nominee' – report
Unnamed source tells news site Axios Trump’s speech to the rightwing event will have the message ‘I’m still in charge’

Martin Pengelly in New York

22, Feb, 2021 @3:18 PM

Article image
Is rising Maga star Ron DeSantis the man to displace Trump in 2024?
The Florida governor has beaten the former president in recent polls of activists and could offer a younger version of Trumpism without Trump

Richard Luscombe in Miami

12, Jun, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Trump v DeSantis: Republicans split over 2024 run and predict ‘blood on the floor’
County leaders say they fear ex-president is even more divisive than he was two years ago and is therefore unelectable

Chris McGreal

15, Nov, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Birchers review: how the Republican far right gave us Trump and DeSantis
Matthew Dallek’s fast-paced and well-researched history shows how the John Birch Society rose, raved and never went away

Lloyd Green

19, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Trump branded midterms’ ‘biggest loser’ as DeSantis win fuels 2024 talk
Republican governor sweeps to victory in Florida while former president condemned for failure of anticipated ‘red wave’

Miranda Bryant, Martin Pengelly in New York and Hugo Lowell in West Palm Beach

09, Nov, 2022 @5:06 PM

Article image
DeSantis pleads with Florida Congress members to stop endorsing Trump
Governor phones representatives, dismayed that four members of delegation have backed former president for 2024 nomination

Richard Luscombe in Miami

13, Apr, 2023 @12:55 PM

Article image
Ron DeSantis ally backs Trump for president in latest Florida defection
News comes amid reports that governor’s team has pressured representatives from his state not to endorse Trump

Martin Pengelly

19, Apr, 2023 @11:38 AM

Article image
‘They will bend the knee’: Lincoln project cofounder cautions against dismissing Trump
Rick Wilson, a veteran Republican strategist, suggests the ex-president still holds sway despite multiple crises

David Smith in Washington

27, Nov, 2022 @10:00 AM