Clyburn: supreme court nomination of Ketanji Brown Jackson ‘beyond politics’

South Carolina congressman extracted Biden’s promise to instal first Black woman on court

The supreme court nomination of Ketanji Brown Jackson should be placed “beyond politics”, the politician who extracted Joe Biden’s politically priceless promise to instal the first Black woman on the court said on Sunday.

Biden introduced Jackson as his pick to replace the retiring Stephen Breyer this week.

Some Republicans have complained that nominations should not be made on grounds of race or gender – ignoring promises to put women on the court acted on by Ronald Reagan and Donald Trump.

Others have complained about how Democrats treated one of Trump’s nominees, Brett Kavanaugh, who denied allegations of sexual assault. Others have objected on ideological grounds, for example Lindsey Graham, a member of the Senate judiciary committee, claiming the Jackson nomination was the work of the “radical left”.

James Clyburn, the South Carolina congressman and House Democratic whip whose endorsement both propelled Biden to the presidential nomination and produced his promise to pick a Black woman, appeared on Sunday on CBS’s Face the Nation.

He said: “This is beyond politics. This is about the country, our pursuit of a more perfect union, and this is demonstrative of another step in that pursuit.”

Of 115 supreme court justices, 108 have been white men. Two have been Black men, five women. As well as being the first Black woman on the court, Jackson would be the fourth woman on the current nine-justice panel, joining liberals Elena Kagan and Sonia Sotomayor and Amy Coney Barrett, a hardline conservative.

Clyburn said he hoped “that all my Republican friends will look upon” the nomination of Jackson as being “beyond politics”.

“Let’s have a debate,” he said. “Let’s talk to her about her rulings and about her philosophy. But in the final analysis, let’s have a strong bipartisan support to demonstrate that both parties are still in pursuit of perfection”.

No supreme court nomination – or, most observers would argue, hearing or ruling – is ever above politics. If confirmed, Jackson will not alter the balance of a court tilted 6-3 to conservatives by Republican political hardball which gave Trump three picks.

Before Biden made his decision, Clyburn and Republicans including Graham and the other South Carolina senator, Tim Scott, championed J Michelle Childs, a judge from their state. Clyburn said it would be important to instal a justice who did not go to Yale or Harvard. Jackson went to Harvard.

“It’s more traditional, no question about that,” Clyburn told CBS. “This means that we will continue that tradition, and I am one, as you can see, that’s not so much for tradition. I want to see us break as much new ground as possible.

“But … in the final analysis, I think this is a good choice. It was a choice that brings on to the court a background and some experiences that nobody else on the court will have. And I think when you look at not just [Jackson’s] background in the family, life, but also her profession, she was a public defender. That adds a new perspective to the court.”

Steve Vladeck, a professor at the University of Texas, has pointed out that Jackson has more trial experience than four current justices combined – including the chief, John Roberts.

Clyburn also said a successful confirmation process could help Biden politically with Black voters facing difficulties familiar to most Americans, particularly inflation.

“When you have an opportunity to make an appointment like you just had,” he said, “and he made an African American appointment, I guarantee you, you see some of that move up. It may not move up with the people who are having income problems, but it will move up to those who have other reservations about the president.”

Last year, Jackson was confirmed to the court of appeals for the DC circuit with support from three Republican senators: Graham, Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski from Alaska.

This year, Democrats will be able to confirm Jackson simply by keeping their 50 votes together and using Kamala Harris’s casting vote as vice-president.

But on Sunday Mitt Romney of Utah told CNN’s State of the Union he could vote to confirm Jackson.

“Yes,” the former presidential nominee said, “I’m going to take a very deep dive and had the occasion to speak with her about some of the concerns when she was before the Senate to go on to the circuit court.

“Look, her nomination and her confirmation would or will be historic. And like anyone nominated by the president of the United States, she deserves a very careful look, a very deep dive. And I will provide fresh eyes to that evaluation, and hope that I will be able to support her in the final analysis.”


Martin Pengelly in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Republican Hawley’s attack on supreme court nominee Jackson is wrong, says senator
Senate judiciary committee chair Dick Durbin says Hawley’s attacks should be ignored in confirmation hearings this week

Martin Pengelly in New York and agencies

20, Mar, 2022 @6:01 PM

Article image
‘It would be glorious’: hopes high for Biden to nominate first Black woman to supreme court
Activists welcome stated intent to fulfil campaign promise and finally elevate a judge ‘that really understands racism’

Tom McCarthy

20, Apr, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Ketanji Brown Jackson says Roe v Wade ‘the settled law of the supreme court’ – as it happened
Jackson discusses 1973 ruling that established women’s right to abortion – follow all the day’s politics news

Sam Levin (now) and Lauren Gambino (earlier)

23, Mar, 2022 @12:07 AM

Article image
Supreme court: Stephen Breyer ‘did not want to die on bench’, says brother
Pressure campaign was fired by fear of repeat of disaster when Republicans replaced Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Martin Pengelly in New York

30, Jan, 2022 @3:56 PM

Article image
Ketanji Brown Jackson sworn in to supreme court after ruling deals blow to climate crisis – as it happened
Ketanji Brown Jackson becomes first Black woman in US history to sit on the nation’s highest court

Lauren Gambino

30, Jun, 2022 @8:09 PM

Article image
Two more Republicans back Ketanji Brown Jackson for supreme court
Nomination advances in Senate after judiciary committee vote splits along party lines

Lauren Gambino in Washington

04, Apr, 2022 @11:39 PM

Article image
Ketanji Brown Jackson confirmed as first Black woman on US supreme court – as it happened
Joe Biden’s nominee is confirmed by Senate in 53-47 vote

Richard Luscombe

07, Apr, 2022 @8:44 PM

Article image
Ketanji Brown Jackson ‘honored’ to become supreme court’s first Black female justice – as it happened
Jackson speaks at White House after being confirmed 53-47 to become first Black woman on supreme court

Richard Luscombe

08, Apr, 2022 @8:11 PM

Article image
Biden nominates Ketanji Brown Jackson to become first Black woman on supreme court
White House praises ‘exceptionally qualified nominee’ who, if confirmed, will replace retiring Stephen Breyer

Lauren Gambino in Washington

25, Feb, 2022 @6:31 PM

Article image
Clarence Thomas: supreme court could be ‘compromised’ by politics
The court is set to rule this year on divisive issues including abortion, gun control, the climate crisis and voting rights

Martin Pengelly and agencies

12, Mar, 2022 @5:21 PM