DeSantis appoints judge who denied abortion to girl over school grades

Jared Smith, who issued controversial ruling in January, named to new court of appeal by Florida governor

Florida’s rightwing Republican governor, Ron DeSantis, has appointed a judge who was previously ousted over a controversial ruling where he denied a teenager an abortion, citing her school grades.

DeSantis appointed Jared Smith to the newly established sixth district court of appeal, an appointment which will begin on 1 January 2023. Smith previously served as a judge on the Hillsborough county court until he was ousted in August after his decision on the abortion-related case.

In January, Smith had ruled that a 17-year-old teenager was unfit to obtain an abortion as he questioned her “overall intelligence”. According to Florida law, both parental notification and consent is required in order for a minor to receive an abortion. In the teenager’s case, she had asked the court to waive the requirement.

Under Florida’s law, the requirement can be waived if the court finds “by clear and convincing evidence, that the minor is sufficiently mature to decide whether to terminate her pregnancy”.

However, in Smith’s ruling, he cited the teenager’s grades as a factor in his decision that denied her the abortion.

“Addressing her ‘overall intelligence’ … the court found her intelligence to be less than average because ‘[w]hile she claimed that her grades were ‘Bs’ during her testimony, her GPA is currently 2.0. Clearly, a ‘B’ average would not equate to a 2.0 GPA,’” he said in his ruling.

Smith also went on to question the teenager’s “emotional development and stability, and ability to accept responsibility”.

“This court has long recognized that the trial court’s findings … may support a determination that the minor did not prove that she was sufficiently mature to decide whether to terminate her pregnancy,” he wrote.

An appeals court eventually overturned the ruling. In August, Smith lost his re-election bid against Nancy Jacobs, a Tampa criminal defense and family law attorney. According to the Hill, Jacobs received approximately 51.9% of the votes, surpassing Smith by about 3.7 percentage points.

DeSantis is a rising star in the Republican party, especially after his strong performance in November’s midterm elections, which was in stark contrast to the Republican party showing overall. He has emerged as a powerful rival to Donald Trump and is widely expected to challenge the former US president in the Republican 2024 presidential nomination race.

DeSantis’s appointment of Smith comes a week after the Florida supreme court tossed out challenges to the eligibility of six appeals court candidates, including Smith. The challenges argued that the candidates live outside the jurisdiction of the fifth and six district court of appeals, the Tampa Bay Times reports.

The state’s supreme court ruled that the residency requirement would only apply once the judges are appointed, not during the nomination process of the candidates.


Maya Yang

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Judge who denied girl abortion over grades shortlisted for Florida’s top court
Jared Smith, who was ousted for decision, will be interviewed before Ron DeSantis picks new supreme court member

Richard Luscombe

19, Apr, 2023 @2:36 PM

Article image
Miami judge dismisses voter fraud case trumpeted by DeSantis
Case is one of the 19 voter fraud prosecutions, and involves man who says he registered to vote in 2020 without knowing he was ineligible

Sam Levine in New York

21, Oct, 2022 @2:14 PM

Article image
Rough week, Ron? DeSantis flounders with Disney feud and abortion stance
Florida governor’s recent moves see him lose political capital – and support – as he prepares for likely presidential run

Richard Luscombe in Miami

22, Apr, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
DeSantis to face trial for suspension of prosecutor who defied abortion ban law
Andrew Warren, a Democrat, sued Florida governor for suspension after saying he would not enforce new 15-week abortion law

Richard Luscombe

23, Sep, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
DeSantis appears to back woman who led Amanda Gorman poem school ban
Florida governor accuses media of creating ‘ridiculous poem hoax’ after complaint targeted verse recited at Biden inauguration

Richard Luscombe in Miami

26, May, 2023 @5:01 PM

Article image
Florida restaurant sues Ron DeSantis over law banning drag performances
Hamburger Mary’s in Orlando says law has ‘everything to do with the continued oppression of the LGBTQ+ community’

Maya Yang

25, May, 2023 @5:04 PM

Article image
Florida board approves expansion of ‘don’t say gay’ ban to all school grades
Approval of bill prohibiting discussions of sexual orientation and gender identity comes at request of Governor DeSantis

Maya Yang

19, Apr, 2023 @9:28 PM

Article image
Disney sues Ron DeSantis in battle over control of Florida resort
Entertainment giant wants court to overturn governor’s efforts to exert control over Walt Disney World theme parks in Orlando

Lauren Aratani and Martin Pengelly in New York

26, Apr, 2023 @6:55 PM

Article image
Criminal investigation launched into DeSantis asylum seeker flights
Texas county sheriff says it seems evident that asylum seekers had been ‘lured’ to travel to Martha’s Vineyard ‘under false pretenses’

Gloria Oladipo

20, Sep, 2022 @3:08 PM

Article image
DeSantis sends migrants to Martha’s Vineyard, causing ‘humanitarian situation’
Florida governor sends about 50 people with no apparent notice, while Venezuelan migrants from Texas bussed to Washington DC

Richard Luscombe

15, Sep, 2022 @4:10 PM