Rural Arizona county certifies midterm results after judge orders vote

The Cochise county board of supervisors voted 2-0 to approve the results after threat of lawsuits

A rural Arizona county finally certified its election results on Thursday after a judge ordered the county’s board of supervisors to do their jobs just a couple of hours earlier.

The Cochise county board of supervisors voted 2-0 to approve the midterm results, allowing the statewide canvass of the election to continue as planned on 5 December. A third member of the board who had spearheaded the effort to delay certification, Tom Crosby, did not attend the vote.

Supervisor Peggy Judd, who initially voted to delay the certification, later voted in favor after the court order.

“I am not ashamed of anything I did,” Judd said during Thursday’s certification vote. “And today … because of a court ruling, and because of my own health and situations that are going on in our life, I feel like I must follow what the judge did today or asked us to do, but I feel I don’t like to be threatened.”

After the county refused to certify by the 28 November deadline set by state law, it faced lawsuits from the Arizona secretary of state and the Arizona Alliance for Retired Americans. The lawsuits were heard in court on Thursday, with Pima county superior court judge Casey McGinley swiftly ruling that the board was required to canvass its results by that afternoon. McGinley said there was no legal basis for the board to delay or refuse to certify.

The county attorney would not represent the two supervisors who voted against certifying the election, and neither would an outside attorney the board first wanted to help. Instead, an attorney was only named earlier on Thursday and did not make it to the court hearing, leaving the sued supervisors without legal representation. While Crosby wanted to continue the hearing to allow the new lawyer to get to know the case, McGinley said it would move forward immediately.

A delay of the statewide certification process held huge potential consequences: two statewide recounts, required by law, could not start until the canvass was complete. Lawsuits from candidates and other groups cannot begin without official results. Voters in the county could be disenfranchised if their votes were not included in statewide totals. The continuity of state government itself may have been in danger, the secretary of state’s office warned.

Ann English, the chair of the board and its lone Democrat, has repeatedly voted for certifying the election and against previous efforts by her colleagues to conduct a full hand count of ballots, later declared unlawful. During Thursday’s certification, she said she hoped the people pushing for not certifying realize “there’s a place for change in the legislation, and it isn’t here – we react to the legislation, we don’t create legislation for the state”.

Although the lawsuits were successful in getting the county to do its election duties, others want to see the two supervisors face criminal charges for flouting election law. One state law says a person charged with any election-related duty who refuses to perform that duty in violation of law is guilty of a class-six felony.

Terry Goddard, a former Arizona attorney general, and Rick Romley, a former Maricopa county attorney, wrote a letter to the current attorney general, Mark Brnovich, and the Cochise county attorney, Brian McIntyre, asking them to investigate and consider criminal charges for Crosby and Judd. McIntyre has said he was weighing whether to bring charges.

“Failing to hold supervisors Crosby and Judd accountable for their violations of law could embolden other public officials to abandon their legal duties in future elections,” Goddard and Romley wrote. “This would pose a substantial threat to election administration in Arizona.”


Rachel Leingang

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Arizona set for legal battles after county refuses to certify midterm results
Republican officials face two lawsuits, likely court intervention to force their vote and potential criminal penalties

Rachel Leingang

30, Nov, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Arizona secretary of state sues after Republican officials refuse to certify county election results
Cochise county officials have endorsed claims of voter fraud despite no evidence of any problems

Gloria Oladipo and agencies

29, Nov, 2022 @3:22 AM

Article image
Democrat Kris Mayes wins Arizona race for attorney general after recount
The state held a mandatory recount that saw Mayes beat her Republican opponent Abraham Hamadeh by 280 votes

Sam Levine in New York

30, Dec, 2022 @4:05 PM

Article image
‘A really dangerous candidate’: Kari Lake, the new face of Maga Republicanism
The former local news anchor – and former Democrat – is in a neck-and-neck race for governor in key swing state of Arizona

Maanvi Singh

03, Nov, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
US midterm voters reject election deniers who support Trump’s false claim
Several avid participants in efforts to subvert the outcome of the 2020 presidential contest fell short in the midterm elections

Ed Pilkington in New York and Sam Levine in Detroit

09, Nov, 2022 @5:57 PM

Article image
Early voters in Arizona midterms report harassment by poll watchers
Complaints detail ballot drop box monitors filming, following and calling voters ‘mules’ in reference to conspiracy film

Rachel Leingang in Phoenix, Arizona

20, Oct, 2022 @7:57 PM

Article image
Arizona to vote on introducing more voter ID requirements
Opponents fear the measure might result in increased ballot counting time and identity fraud

Rachel Leingang in Phoenix, Arizona

25, Oct, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Arizona governor candidate refuses to say if she will accept midterms result
Kari Lake, who has echoed Trump’s claims the 2020 election was stolen, refuses three times to answer when pressed on CNN

Sam Levine in New York

17, Oct, 2022 @12:49 PM

Article image
‘I see things now that I’ve never seen before’: the Maricopa county attorney fighting false election claims
Tom Liddy, a lifelong Republican, is a target of his own party for fending off lawsuits against the county over blatant election lies

Rachel Leingang

19, Jan, 2023 @11:00 AM

Article image
Adrian Fontes wins highly contested secretary of state in Arizona
The former Marine beat Mark Finchem, an ex-member of Oath Keepers militia who was at the Capitol on January 6

Ed Pilkington

12, Nov, 2022 @4:14 AM