Murder charges dropped against Texas woman for ‘self-induced abortion’

Lizelle Herrera has been released after being thrown in jail last week, while district attorney says this is ‘not a criminal matter’

The woman who was thrown in jail on a murder charge in Texas for allegedly having caused the “death of an individual by self-induced abortion” has been released after the local district attorney dropped the case.

Lizelle Herrera, 26, was reported to be back with her family on Sunday after the district attorney in Rio Grande City, on the US-Mexico border, put out a statement saying he was immediately dismissing the case. Herrera had been arrested last Thursday and placed in the Starr county jail on the back of a grand jury indictment.

“The issues surrounding this matter are clearly contentious,” the DA, Gocha Allen Ramirez, said. “However, based on Texas law and the facts presented, it is not a criminal matter.”

The prosecutor added: “Ms Herrera did not commit a criminal act under the laws of the state of Texas.”

Ramirez’s statement correlates with the view of legal experts and women’s rights advocates who say that Herrera’s arrest should never have happened in the first place. Texas authorities are now likely to face accusations that by putting the woman behind bars they committed an act of gross overreach.

“There is no law in Texas that authorizes treating people who have miscarriages, still births or abortions as murderers,” said Lynn Paltrow, executive director of National Advocates for Pregnant Women.

The current law in Texas explicitly exempts women from being policed for any self-managed abortion. The state has attracted considerable attention in recent months after it passed SB 8, legislation that allows private citizens to sue anyone who helps a woman get an abortion as early as six weeks into pregnancy.

But SB 8 is a civil – not a criminal – provision, and it cannot be applied to the woman receiving the abortion herself.

Nonetheless, the abortion ban, which passed all the way up to the US supreme court, has put a chill over Texas. A recent study from the policy evaluation project of the University of Texas at Austin found that between August and December last year, 1,400 women had been forced out of Texas to seek abortion care in other states.

The precise details of what happened to Herrera are still unclear, but it appears that the hospital she attended reported her to authorities. In his statement, Ramirez said the Starr county sheriff’s department investigated Herrera after the hospital brought “the incident” to the officers’ attention.

Local advocacy groups in southern Texas expressed joy at Herrera’s release, coupled with anger that she had been detained in the first place. South Texans for Reproductive Justice called the dismissal of charges a “bittersweet victory”.

The group said: “It should not have taken national attention for these charges to be dismissed.”

The confusion over Herrera’s wrongful arrest is an indication of the tensions that are rising in states across the country ahead of a critical ruling by the supreme court on the constitutional right to an abortion framed in Roe v Wade. The court is expected to give its decision in June, and all indications suggest it is likely to rein back abortion rights at least to some degree.

Paltrow warned that any move by the supreme court to hand more control over abortion laws to the states would inevitably lead to increased rates of surveillance, reporting and arrests of women.

“For the past 50 years, anti-abortion activists have been trying to groom people in the US to view pregnant women as criminals,” she said.


Ed Pilkington in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hundreds of thousands of Texas women attempted self-induced abortion – study
Findings show that 100,000 to 240,000 women aged 18-49 attempted at-home procedures in wake of legislative attempts to curtail abortion access in state

Amanda Holpuch in New York

17, Nov, 2015 @9:24 PM

Article image
Texas man faces charges for allegedly slipping abortion drug in wife’s drink
Grand jury indicted Mason Herring on two felony counts earlier this month, including assaulting a pregnant person

Lauren Aratani

14, Nov, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Biden administration sues Texas over ‘clearly unconstitutional’ abortion ban
Kamala Harris says women’s reproductive rights are ‘non-negotiable’ as justice department takes action

Adam Gabbatt

09, Sep, 2021 @10:01 PM

Article image
Most extreme abortion law in US takes effect in Texas
US supreme court fails to act to block near-total ban that allows private citizens to sue abortion providers

Mary Tuma

02, Sep, 2021 @1:58 AM

Article image
‘Outraged, sickened, terrified’: Guardian readers on the Texas abortion ban
Nine Guardian readers share their thoughts on the ruling that bans most abortions – and what it means for reproductive rights

Guardian readers and Rachel Obordo

04, Sep, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
How the Texas abortion ruling will affect access across the US
Providers across the country have heaved a sigh of relief following the supreme court’s decision, but hundreds of restrictions are insulated from its effects

Molly Redden

28, Jun, 2016 @2:18 PM

Article image
Texas doctor protests abortion law by admitting he carried out procedure
Alan Braid writes column for Washington Post describing the hardships and deaths he has witnessed among patients

Martin Pengelly in New York

19, Sep, 2021 @12:13 PM

Article image
Texas abortion providers ask supreme court to halt unprecedented abortion law
Center for Reproductive Rights and Planned Parenthood turn to justices in final bid to block near-total ban

Mary Tuma

30, Aug, 2021 @8:05 PM

Article image
This all-male council in Texas just voted to ban abortion
Council in Waskom, Texas, made up only of white men, votes to make town ‘a sanctuary city for the unborn’

Jessica Glenza in New York

14, Jun, 2019 @5:49 PM

Article image
Supreme court appears open to allowing challenge to Texas abortion law
Justices, in oral arguments, seem skeptical of law that gives private citizens right to sue to enforce six-week abortion ban

Jessica Glenza

01, Nov, 2021 @9:07 PM