Biden administration sues Texas over ‘clearly unconstitutional’ abortion ban

  • Law bans abortion once embryonic cardiac activity is detected
  • Kamala Harris says reproductive rights are ‘non-negotiable’

The Biden administration sued Texas on Thursday over the state’s extreme abortion law, which amounts to a near total ban on abortion, calling the law “clearly unconstitutional”.

The US attorney general, Merrick Garland, said the law that went into effect last week after the supreme court refused to block it and bans almost all abortions in the state was one “all Americans should fear”.

Senate bill 8, pushed through by Texas’s Republican-dominated legislature, bans abortion once embryonic cardiac activity is detected, which is around six weeks. Most women are not aware they are pregnant as early as that time.

The justice department decided to argue that the law, which offers no exceptions for rape or incest, “illegally interferes with federal interests”, the Wall Street Journal first reported.

Later on Thursday, Vice-President Kamala Harris said the right of women to make their own choices on reproductive rights and decisions about “their own bodies” was “not negotiable”.

She added that Joe Biden’s and her support for the supreme court’s landmark Roe v Wade decision from 1973, which paved the way for abortion to be legal across the US, was “unequivocal”.

VP Kamala Harris voiced her support to abortion and reproductive health providers during a meeting Thursday to discuss the Texas abortion bill.

“The right of women to make decisions about their own bodies is not negotiable,” she said

— Bloomberg Quicktake (@Quicktake) September 9, 2021

On Monday Garland said the justice department would “protect those seeking to obtain or provide reproductive health services”, under a federal law known as the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances.

Garland said that law would be enforced “in order to protect the constitutional rights of women and other persons, including access to an abortion”.

The Texas law incentivizes any private citizen to sue an abortion provider or anyone deemed to have helped a women get an abortion contravening the law. It came into effect on 1 September, and survived an emergency appeal to the supreme court, which voted 5-4 to allow the law to remain in force.

On Thursday, when announcing the lawsuit, Garland said: “The act is clearly unconstitutional” and said that it failed to give women seeking an abortion their constitutional right “at the very moment they need it”.

And he added that the “kind of scheme” that Texas has devised and other states want to follow, where the public enforces the law as a way to avoid legal challenge, and allows individuals to sue abortion providers or those helping a woman obtain the service, was designed to “nullify the constitution”.

Joe Biden condemned the new law and reaffirmed the White House’s support for abortion rights. “This extreme Texas law blatantly violates the constitutional right established under Roe v Wade and upheld as a precedent for nearly half a century,” Biden said in a statement.

The Biden administration has since been under pressure to act, with Democrats on the House judiciary committee writing to Garland on Tuesday, although many experts believe that winning the lawsuit will be a challenge for the federal government.

“The Department of Justice cannot permit private individuals seeking to deprive women of the constitutional right to choose an abortion to escape scrutiny under existing federal law simply because they attempt to do so under the color of state law,” wrote the Democratic members of Congress, who include Pramila Jayapal, representative for Washington, and Val Demings, from Florida.

The Texas law is the strictest legislation enacted against abortion rights in the United States since the supreme court’s landmark Roe v Wade decision in 1973. At least 12 other states have enacted bans early in pregnancy, but all have been blocked from going into effect.

Abortion providers have said the law will probably force many abortion clinics in Texas to ultimately close. Women’s rights advocates fear the conservative-dominated supreme court’s lack of action over the law could signal the start of the unravelling of Roe v Wade.

Harris said on Thursday that no legislative body had the right to circumvent the US constitution.

Harris, who was speaking to reporters at a meeting with abortion providers and patients, said the right of women to make decisions about their own bodies was “not negotiable”.

Reuters contributed reporting


Adam Gabbatt

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Most extreme abortion law in US takes effect in Texas
US supreme court fails to act to block near-total ban that allows private citizens to sue abortion providers

Mary Tuma

02, Sep, 2021 @1:58 AM

Article image
Biden condemns US supreme court’s ‘unprecedented assault’ on abortion rights
President denounces justices for failing to block Texas law and vows to ‘ensure woman have access to safe and legal abortions’

Lauren Aratani

02, Sep, 2021 @4:51 PM

Article image
Supreme court appears open to allowing challenge to Texas abortion law
Justices, in oral arguments, seem skeptical of law that gives private citizens right to sue to enforce six-week abortion ban

Jessica Glenza

01, Nov, 2021 @9:07 PM

Article image
Supreme court rules Texas abortion providers can sue over ban but won’t stop law
Justices are allowing the law, the strictest such regulation in America to date, to remain in effect

Jessica Glenza, Ed Pilkington, Gloria Oladipo and agencies

10, Dec, 2021 @4:57 PM

Article image
Biden urges supreme court to block Texas’ near-total abortion ban
The justice department wrote in its plea that the law defies the supreme court’s major decisions on abortion rights

Guardian staff and agencies

19, Oct, 2021 @12:13 AM

Article image
Protesters denounce ‘kangaroo court’ after high-stakes Texas abortion pill hearing
Abortion rights supporters gathered in a remote Texas city despite efforts by Judge Kacsmaryk to keep the hearing secret

Cecilia Nowell

16, Mar, 2023 @11:58 AM

Article image
Strict Texas abortion law overturned in major supreme court ruling
Huge legal victory for reproductive rights activists paves way to overturn dozens of measures that curtail access to abortion providers across the country

Molly Redden

27, Jun, 2016 @2:09 PM

Article image
Texas judge blocks Biden order requiring hospitals to provide emergency abortions
Trump-appointed judge says US health department overreached in its guidance, in decision issued just before ‘trigger law’ takes effect

Edwin Rios

24, Aug, 2022 @1:13 PM

Article image
How does someone in Texas get an abortion now and what’s next?
The supreme court refused to block the ban – here’s what you should know about the most restrictive US abortion law

Amanda Holpuch in New York

02, Sep, 2021 @6:25 PM

Article image
Texas sheriff says he ‘will not persecute’ those seeking an abortion
Javier Salazar posted on Facebook that he would not use his power to ‘impose the morals’ of others on those ‘exercising a right’

Erum Salam

29, Jun, 2022 @9:00 AM