Joe Biden to referee Democrats in brewing battle over $3.5tn budget bill

Centrists are concerned about the price tag, while progressives say they will oppose attempt to cut funding in the proposal

Congress will return from its summer recess later this month, and some Democrats are already gearing up for a political fight – with each other.

Democratic lawmakers are looking to pass their $3.5tn spending package, after the House and the Senate approved the blueprint for the budget bill last month. The ambitious legislation encompasses much of Joe Biden’s economic agenda, including proposals to expand access to affordable childcare, invest in climate-related initiatives and broaden Medicare coverage.

But to get the bill passed, Democrats will first need to reach an agreement on the cost of the legislation. Centrist Democrats, including Senators Kyrsten Sinema and Joe Manchin, have expressed concern about the bill’s $3.5tn price tag, while progressives have indicated they will fiercely oppose any attempt to cut funding in the proposal.

With his entire economic agenda hanging in the balance, Biden will need to convince the two fractious wings of his party to come together and pass a comprehensive spending package. And given Democrats’ extremely narrow majorities in both the House and the Senate, there is virtually no room for error.

Despite warning signs of intra-party friction over the cost of the budget bill, congresswoman Suzan DelBene, who chairs the centrist New Democrat Coalition, said the House’s focus right now should still be on the content of the legislation.

“I think discussion of a number is more distracting when the focus really needs to be on, what is the substance going to be of this legislation?” DelBene told the Guardian. “If we have strong legislation the people support, I think we can find the path forward.”

Centrist senators Kyrsten Sinema, left, and Joe Manchin, second from left. Manchin wrote an op-ed calling for a ‘strategic pause’ in advancing the spending package.
Centrist senators Kyrsten Sinema, left, and Joe Manchin, second from left. Manchin wrote an op-ed calling for a ‘strategic pause’ in advancing the spending package. Photograph: REX/Shutterstock

Over in the Senate, majority leader Chuck Schumer is attempting to advance the bill using reconciliation, meaning Democrats do not need any Republican support to pass the legislation. But the 50-50 split in the upper chamber means that every single Democratic senator must be on board to get the bill approved.

Schumer has been clear-eyed about the challenges ahead for the legislation. Shortly after the Senate approved the blueprint for the bill in a party-line vote last month, Schumer told reporters, “We’ve labored for months and months to reach this point, and we have no illusions – maybe the hardest work is yet to come.”

Manchin proved Schumer’s point last Thursday, when he wrote a Wall Street Journal op-ed calling for a “strategic pause” in advancing the spending package.

“While some have suggested this reconciliation legislation must be passed now, I believe that making budgetary decisions under artificial political deadlines never leads to good policy or sound decisions,” Manchin said in the op-ed. “I, for one, won’t support a $3.5tn bill, or anywhere near that level of additional spending, without greater clarity about why Congress chooses to ignore the serious effects inflation and debt have on existing government programs.”

Bernie Sanders, the leftwing chairman of the Senate budget committee, responded to Manchin’s warning in kind, threatening to torpedo the bipartisan infrastructure bill if the spending package is not approved.

“Rebuilding our crumbling physical infrastructure – roads, bridges, water systems – is important,” Sanders said on Twitter. “Rebuilding our crumbling human infrastructure – healthcare, education, climate change – is more important. No infrastructure bill without the $3.5tn reconciliation bill.”

Rebuilding our crumbling physical infrastructure – roads, bridges, water systems – is important. Rebuilding our crumbling human infrastructure – health care, education, climate change – is more important. No infrastructure bill without the $3.5 trillion reconciliation bill.

— Bernie Sanders (@SenSanders) September 2, 2021

Progressive groups have echoed Sanders’s argument, insisting that every component of the $3.5tn legislation is vital. Sanders had initially called for spending $6tn on the budget bill, so progressives already view the current price tag as a concession.

“We’re in a moment of crisis. Is this really the time for the Senate to press pause?” Ellen Sciales, the communications director of the climate group Sunrise Movement, said in a statement.

She added: “If the Senate can’t pass an incredibly popular climate and jobs plan during a summer of unprecedented, fatal climate disasters, and an economy reeling from a global pandemic, we must abolish the Senate. $3.5tn was the compromise.”

Natalia Salgado, the director of federal affairs for the Working Families Party, noted that some progressive economists have suggested the US needs to spend $10tn over 10 years to meet its obligations in the Paris Climate Agreement.

“We’re going to come nowhere near that,” Salgado said. “So we can’t afford to lose a single cent in this $3.5tn. Every single penny will count.”

Despite the war of words between moderates and progressives, the White House has continued to express confidence that Congress will ultimately reach an agreement on the legislation.

“The president and his whole team are proud of and fighting for the substance of his Build Back Better agenda,” a White House official said in a statement. “These are complex processes, but as recent weeks have demonstrated, leaders in Congress and the President know how to move them forward.”

And DelBene similarly said that her group, which represents 95 Democrats in the House, remains committee to advancing both the bipartisan infrastructure bill and the spending package.

“The strength of the legislation, both on the infrastructure side and the reconciliation bill, is what people are going to look at moving forward,” DelBene said. “I think we want to see the infrastructure deal and the reconciliation bill get done.”

The risk of the strategy is that, in trying to pass everything, Biden and congressional Democrats may end up with nothing.


Joan E Greve in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Biden hails ‘monumental step forward’ as Democrats pass infrastructure bill
The president will sign $1tn package into law after House ended months-long standoff by approving bipartisan deal

Martin Pengelly in New York and David Smith in Washington

06, Nov, 2021 @4:41 PM

Article image
Sanders urges progressives to stand firm in Democratic battle over Biden agenda
Party locked in a bitter struggle over two massive legislative bills that could make or break the Biden presidency

Ed Pilkington

03, Oct, 2021 @8:20 PM

Article image
Sanders' minimum-wage effort looks doomed as Covid relief votes go through night
Biden’s $1.9tn relief package struggles through Senate but majority leaders vow passage ‘however long it takes’

Lauren Gambino and Joan E Greve in Washington and agencies

06, Mar, 2021 @12:17 PM

Article image
Biden predicts ‘infrastructure decade’ as Senate passes bipartisan bill – as it happened
President says of Cuomo resignation: ‘I respect the governor’s decision’ – follow all the latest

Maanvi Singh (now) and Joan E Greve (earlier)

11, Aug, 2021 @12:04 AM

Article image
Biden hails 'giant step' as Senate passes $1.9tn coronavirus relief bill
Republican opposition holds through marathon ‘vote-a-rama’ but Speaker Pelosi has said measure should be law by 14 March

Lauren Gambino in Washington and Martin Pengelly in New York

06, Mar, 2021 @9:32 PM

Article image
US treasury pushes back as budget office warns Biden’s bill will swell deficit - as it happened
Nancy Pelosi is confident that Americans will soon have ‘historic cause for celebration’ – follow all the latest news

Maanvi Singh (now), Vivian Ho and Joanna Walters (earlier)

19, Nov, 2021 @12:54 AM

Article image
‘Finally doing right’: Democrats’ big bill offers Sanders chance to deliver
The progressive senator is close to realizing many of his policy goals – but can he unite the party behind Biden’s plan?

Lauren Gambino in Washington

24, Oct, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Republicans will ‘move forward’ on infrastructure after Biden veto threat
Portman says GOP will back bill after Biden climbdown while Democrat Manchin appeals for progressive support

Guardian staff and agencies

27, Jun, 2021 @5:46 PM

Article image
Biden seeks term-defining wins in Georgia runoffs Trump called 'illegal'
Contests will decide control of Senate and how far Biden can reach on issues such as pandemic, healthcare, taxation and environment

Guardian staff and agencies

02, Jan, 2021 @2:57 PM

Article image
Joe Biden dismisses bad polling and says domestic agenda set to pass
President speaks to reporters at end of G20 summit in Rome, after progressives Sanders and Khanna voice optimism on spending plan

Victoria Bekiempis and Martin Pengelly

31, Oct, 2021 @8:35 PM