Judge blocks sale of apartment complex built on top of historical Black cemetery

Potential sale in Maryland halted after local activists opposed the deal as judge says: ‘Bodies of African Americans remain there’

A judge has blocked the sale of a suburban apartment complex in Maryland that was previously used as a cemetery for freed Black slaves, arguing that “many bodies likely still remain on the property”.

The potential $50m sale of Westwood Tower in Bethesda, Maryland, 30 minutes outside of Washington DC, to the investment firm Charger Ventures was halted after local activists opposed the deal, reported NBC and Bethesda Magazine.

The activists had argued the complex was built on top of a historical gravesite called the Moses Macedonia African Cemetery in the 1960s.

“These are people who were so oppressed and so discarded and so disrespected in life, and now, even in death, they meet the same fate,” said Marsha Coleman-Adebayo, president of the Bethesda African Cemetery Coalition, in a previous interview with NBC.

The BACC filed a lawsuit against the Montgomery County Housing Opportunities Commission (HOC), saying that the commission did not get court approval to sell the apartment complex, a procedure that is normally required with cemetery property.

On Monday, Judge Karla Smith of the Montgomery county circuit court granted a preliminary injunction against the Westwood Tower sale while also denying a request from the HOC to dismiss the suit following an 11-hour hearing in the circuit court.

Smith’s decision allows for the sale to be stopped until the lawsuit is completely resolved. In her decision, Smith wrote that there was public interest in preserving the gravesite and that the current contract between the HOC and Charger Ventures did nothing to ensure the cemetery’s protection.

“Regardless of whether Charger decides to keep the parking lot, build on the lot, or dig up the lot, bodies of African Americans remain there,” Smith wrote, also noting that “the court has an obligation to ensure that such resting place is respected”.

On 1 September, Smith had temporarily halted the sale of the apartment complex by granting the plaintiffs a temporary restraining order. A restraining order has a similar effect to an injunction but is often used as a more emergency intervention, according to Bethesda Magazine.

The group, mostly made up of church members from Macedonia Baptist church and descendants of those buried, have been working for years to have the burial ground memorialized. A 2017 archaeological study of the graveyard by the Ottery Group, an archeological consulting firm, concluded that burials were probably still intact and recommended that no ground disturbances should be made to the site.

The cemetery is also what remains of Bethesda’s River Road community, a historically Black area in Bethesda that existed until the 1960s when white developers pushed out the remaining Black families.

Harvey Matthews Sr speaks on the spot where he says an African American cemetery used to be, in February 2017 in Bethesda, Maryland.
Harvey Matthews Sr speaks on the spot where he says an African American cemetery used to be, in February 2017 in Bethesda, Maryland. Photograph: The Washington Post/Getty Images

I call River Road the ‘lost colony’,” said Harvey Matthews Sr, 72, who was raised in River Road. “I lived there, I was raised there, I went to school there, but it’s gone and forgotten. All those whites who live in the surrounding area don’t have any knowledge of the black folks who lived there, and people need to know about that.”

Matthews’ testimony of seeing many gravesites in the Moses cemetery as a boy was used in preliminary injunction hearing.

“They were finding body parts – arms, legs,” Harvey testified, also noting that if the gravesite were to be dug up today, “body parts will jump up at you like popcorn”.

Steven Lieberman, an attorney for the BACC, said that the county could choose to appeal Smith’s decision or attempt to obtain court approval of the cemetery sale, but also noted that this victory could influence decisions in other places regarding the sale of burial grounds.

“Very often, these burial grounds are under a highway bypass, or they’ve been plowed under for other uses, and this really does give people a road map in how to address these issues,” Lieberman told NBC.


Gloria Oladipo

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
As Trump stokes racial tensions, black candidates have breakthrough year
Andrew Gillum, Stacey Abrams, and Ben Jealous bid for governorships as Democrats pin hopes on an increasingly diverse electorate

Sabrina Siddiqui in Washington

31, Aug, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Washington DC’s monument to black history
The National Museum of African American History and Culture, completed by UK architect David Adjaye, opens this week

Rowan Moore

18, Sep, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
Freddie Gray, one year later: Baltimore's black residents still waiting for changes
Shaun Young, 27, was among those who protested against police brutality in the wake of Gray’s death in custody. His assessment of what has changed: ‘Now you get in the paddy wagon they’re gonna buckle you up’

Baynard Woods in Baltimore

19, Apr, 2016 @12:13 PM

Article image
Hidden faultline: how Trump v Clinton is laying bare America's class divide
With the Republican candidate’s professed love for the ‘poorly educated’ reciprocated in the polls, socioeconomic class could swing the presidency in 2016

David Smith in Washington

02, Oct, 2016 @10:30 AM

Article image
Maryland's youngest-ever mayor, age 20: 'I try to take the bull by the horns'
Brandon Paulin, who was elected mayor of Indian Head at 19, arrives in Washington DC to urge millennials to run for public office

David Smith

28, Mar, 2016 @4:48 PM

Article image
Governors: Trump making ‘delusional’ comments on testing and restrictions
State leaders say they cannot embark on Trump’s three-phase program to ease stay-at-home orders without widespread testing

Richard Luscombe in Miami and Edward Helmore in New York

19, Apr, 2020 @7:02 PM

Article image
Capitol police's restraint to mob 'hurtful' says sister of black woman killed in 2013
Valarie Carey, whose sister Miriam Carey was shot dead in car after U-turn by Capitol police, says rioters ‘were treated with entitlement’

Richard Luscombe

11, Jan, 2021 @1:56 PM

Article image
Maryland shooting: four dead, including suspect, at warehouse complex
Sheriff’s office of Harford county, north-east of Baltimore, describes ‘active shooter situation’ at Rite Aid warehouse

Guardian staff and agencies

21, Sep, 2018 @4:23 AM

Article image
Baltimore mayor on Confederate statues: 'Why should people have to feel that pain every day?'
Catherine Pugh discusses her decision to remove four Confederate monuments overnight, an operation aimed at deterring violence like that of Charlottesville

Jake Nevins

22, Aug, 2017 @2:24 PM

Article image
'He'll reap everything he sows': what does Baltimore make of Trump?
Trump has repeatedly demonised big cities with large minority populations – part of his ploy to exploit America’s racial divide

David Smith in Baltimore

30, Jul, 2019 @2:23 PM