Texas school official says classrooms with books on Holocaust must offer ‘opposing’ views

In recording obtained by NBC News, curriculum director describes ‘political mess’ after passage of state law

A Texas school district official told educators if they kept books about the Holocaust in their classrooms, they would have to also offer “opposing” viewpoints in order to comply with a new state law.

In an audio clip obtained by NBC News, Gina Peddy, the executive director of curriculum and instruction for Carroll independent school district in Southlake, offered the guidance to teachers during a training on which books teachers can keep in classroom libraries.

NEW: A school administrator in Southlake, Texas, advised teachers last week that if they have a book about the Holocaust in their classroom, they should also have a book with an "opposing" perspective.

Listen to the audio recording obtained by @NBCNews: https://t.co/vS0IjlROMu pic.twitter.com/yPtM1ncjgV

— NBC News (@NBCNews) October 14, 2021

“We are in the middle of a political mess, and you are in the middle of a political mess, and so we just have to do the best we can,” Peddy said.

The training came after the Carroll school board had reprimanded a fourth-grade teacher after parents complained about a book on anti-racism in her class. And it followed the passage of a new Texas law that requires teachers who discuss “widely debated and currently controversial issues of public policy or social affairs” to examine the issues from diverse viewpoints without giving “deference to any one perspective”.

At the training, Peddy advised teachers to remember the requirements of the new law, according to the audio. “And make sure that if you have a book on the Holocaust,” she said, “that you have one that has an opposing, that has other perspectives,” which prompted a teacher to ask what would be the “opposing” view of the Holocaust.

The district superintendent, Dr Lane Ledbetter, did not immediately respond to the Guardian’s request for comment, but offered a “sincere apology” in a statement shared on Facebook.

“During the conversations with teachers during last week’s meeting, the comments made were in no way to convey that the Holocaust was anything less than a terrible event in history. Additionally, we recognize there are not two sides of the Holocaust,” Ledbetter wrote.

A district spokesperson told NBC News it was trying to help teachers comply with the legislation as educators were in “a precarious position with the latest legal requirements”. State education experts told NBC News that the bill does not deal with classroom libraries.

Ledbetter said in the statement that the district understands the law does not require opposing viewpoints on historical facts.

The Texas governor, Greg Abbott, has said that law, HB 3979, is an effort to abolish critical race theory in schools. The theory is an academic discipline that examines the ways in which racism operates in US laws and society, but it is not taught in US secondary schools.

Regardless, school board meetings across the US have seen a wave of protests about critical race theory in recent months and lawmakers in states around the country have proposed laws that would ban the teaching of critical race theory and topics such as the New York Times’s 1619 Project.

Twenty-two states had passed or were considering laws to ban or restrict conversations about race and racism in public school classrooms as of August. In July, Iowa passed a law banning educators from teaching content that could lead to “discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological distress on account of that individual’s race or sex”. Florida passed a law earlier this year banning critical race theory, which it says claims “racism is not merely the product of prejudice, but that racism is embedded in American society and its legal systems in order to uphold the supremacy of white persons”.

Propaganda about critical race theory, as well as anger over Covid restrictions, has rocked school board meetings nationwide, prompting the National School Boards Association to ask Joe Biden for federal assistance in response to threats and violence against school board members and education officials.


Dani Anguiano in Los Angeles

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Texas schools are being told to teach ‘opposing views’ of the Holocaust. Why? | Francine Prose
The question of what specific books and topics can and can’t be taught is linked to a disturbing new law in Texas

Francine Prose

19, Oct, 2021 @3:03 PM

Article image
Texas schools resist Republican request for records on classroom books
Austin and Dallas districts say they won’t respond to lawmaker’s letter targeting 850 books, many on race and LGBTQ+ issues

Gloria Oladipo

13, Nov, 2021 @5:13 PM

Article image
Texas school district pulls the Bible, The Bluest Eye and other books from library
School board in Dallas-Fort Worth area requires reviewing books facing challenges from parents

Erum Salam

23, Aug, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Mexican heritage textbook for Texas schools full of 'offensive stereotypes'
Ruben Cortez and a committee found Mexican American studies textbook for use in public schools has 141 errors of fact, interpretation and omission

Tom Dart In Houston

07, Sep, 2016 @6:07 PM

Article image
Texas attorney general says school district’s Pride week ‘breaks state law’
Ken Paxton called district’s Pride week ‘sex education’ and claimed without parental consent it is against law

Gloria Oladipo

24, Mar, 2022 @3:16 PM

Article image
Texas A&M investigates alleged racial abuse of black high schoolers on visit
A group of white students are accused of using taunts, slurs and Confederate flag references to harass teenagers from Uplift Hampton on campus tour Tuesday

Tom Dart in Houston

12, Feb, 2016 @8:03 PM

Article image
California transit agency allows ad from Holocaust denial group
Bart officials approve advert from Institute for Historical Review, known for publishing antisemitic views

Sam Levin in San Francisco

12, Sep, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Holocaust book Maus hits bestseller list after Tennessee school board ban
Author Art Spiegelman says decision to ban Pulitzer-winning novel that depicts Jewish people as mice and Nazis as cats is ‘demented’

Maya Yang in New York

31, Jan, 2022 @5:23 PM

Article image
Video captures girl body-slammed by school police in Texas
School officials promised a full investigation into the ‘disturbing’ incident after an officer restrained Janissa Valdez, 12, before taking her to the ground

Jamiles Lartey

07, Apr, 2016 @9:26 PM

Article image
School principal fired for saying 'I can't say the Holocaust is a factual event'
William Latson fired for misconduct after writing he was ‘not in a position … as a district employee’ to say the Holocaust happened

Victoria Bekiempis in New York

31, Oct, 2019 @4:23 PM