Canada invited Chelsea Manning to country just so she could be thrown out

Bizarre request made ahead of immigration hearing for Manning, whose previous attempts to enter Canada have been denied

Canadian government lawyers recently invited US whistleblower Chelsea Manning to travel to a hearing in Montreal – so that border agents could then physically remove her from the country.

The bizarre request, which was eventually denied by an adjudicator, was made ahead of an immigration hearing set to begin on Thursday for Manning, whose previous attempts to enter Canada have been denied.

Manning, a former US intelligence analyst who leaked thousands of sensitive government documents and diplomatic cables about the American wars in Afghanistan and Iraq to WikiLeaks, was sentenced to 35 years in prison in 2013.

Her sentence was commuted in 2017, but she was recently denied entry into Canada because of her conviction.

Border officials can deem persons ineligible for entry into Canada if they have been convicted of crimes abroad that would have led to a jail sentence in Canada of 10 years or more.

Last week, lawyers for the government asked that she travel to the country so that if the government won its case, she could be removed. Manning’s lawyers had said she would attend the hearing virtually, from her home in the United States.

“The purpose of a removal order is to compel an individual who is found to be inadmissible to leave Canada. Should the [Immigration Review Board] issue a removal order against an individual who does not attend their hearing from a location in Canada,” the government told the IRB in documents obtained by the National Post, arguing it would “be impractical for CBSA to enforce the order”.

But that line of reasoning made little sense to the IRB adjudicator Marisa Musto, who dismissed the government’s motion on Monday.

“If she were physically in Canada when the order was made, the requirement would be that she leave Canada. Given that she is already outside Canada, a fact which is not in question, it can be said that the ‘objective’ of [immigration laws] … would, de facto, be fulfilled,” Musto said in her ruling, calling the government’s request “confounding”.

Manning’s lawyers have fiercely contested the ban on her entering Canada, arguing that an attempt by the country’s federal government to block “one of the most well-known whistleblowers in modern history” from entering the country would offend constitutional and press freedoms.

The hearing is expected to last two days, with a judgment issued in the coming weeks.

  • This article was amended on 7 October 2021 to correct a city name that was misspelled.


Leyland Cecco in Toronto

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Chelsea Manning says she has been barred from entering Canada
Former US soldier and one of the most prominent whistleblowers of modern times posts letter to Twitter saying she is ‘not authorized to enter Canada’

Ashifa Kassam in Toronto and Ed Pilkington in New York

25, Sep, 2017 @8:00 PM

Article image
Revealed: Canada uses secretive anti-terrorist database run by US
Tuscan is effectively a second Canadian no-fly list with 680,000 names, despite problems with the official list

Justin Ling in Toronto

21, Jun, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Canada pension fund quietly divests from US migrant detention firms
CPPIB pulls investments in CoreCivic and Geo Group in unannounced move that follows Guardian report on holdings

Tracey Lindeman in Ottawa

05, Jul, 2019 @3:59 PM

Article image
Woman seeking asylum in Canada dies of hypothermia near US border
Body of 57-year-old Mavis Otuteye, who authorities said was trying to cross into Canada, was found in Minnesota near border with Manitoba

Julien Gignac in Toronto

31, May, 2017 @6:35 PM

Article image
Canada to offer temporary residence to those stranded by Trump travel ban
Immigration minister Ahmed Hussen offers help to people stuck in the country thanks to the ban, though it is unclear how many people are affected

Ashifa Kassam in Québec City

31, Jan, 2017 @3:59 PM

Article image
Jogger accidentally crosses US border from Canada and is held for two weeks
Cedella Roman was visiting mother and studying English but evening run along beach led to two-week detention nightmare

Ashifa Kassam in Toronto

22, Jun, 2018 @7:18 PM

Article image
Activists challenge 'unsafe' US-Canada pact that prompts refugees to flee by foot
Refugee advocates aim to strike down Safe Third Country Agreement, which they say encourages migrants to take long, risky routes to enter Canada

Ashifa Kassam in Toronto

06, Jul, 2017 @9:23 PM

Article image
Family’s death at US-Canada border underscores desperate journeys of migrants
Perilous conditions along remote stretch of Manitoba have ambushed border crossers for years

Leyland Cecco in Toronto

21, Jan, 2022 @8:06 PM

Article image
'Move to Canada' threats return – but actually emigrating there is difficult
As a Trump victory looked increasingly likely on Tuesday night, Canada’s citizenship and immigration website was down and Google searches were up

Ashifa Kassam in Toronto

09, Nov, 2016 @6:56 PM

Article image
Canadian Muslim grilled about her faith and view on Trump at US border stop
The case raises concerns that border patrol agents are targeting minorities more broadly in the wake of Donald Trump’s travel ban

Amanda Holpuch in New York and Ashifa Kassam in Toronto

10, Feb, 2017 @12:43 PM