Top Trump aides set to defy subpoenas in Capitol attack investigation

Source says Meadows, Bannon and others will move to undercut House select committee inquiry – under instructions from Trump

The former Trump White House chief of staff Mark Meadows and other top aides subpoenaed by the House select committee investigating the Capitol attack are expected to defy orders for documents and testimony related to 6 January, according to a source familiar with the matter.

The move to defy the subpoenas would mark the first major investigative hurdle faced by the select committee and threatens to touch off an extended legal battle as the former president pushes some of his most senior aides to undercut the inquiry.

All four Trump aides targeted by the select committee – Meadows, deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino, strategist Steve Bannon and defense department aide Kash Patel – are expected to resist the orders because Trump is preparing to direct them to do so, the source said.

The select committee had issued the subpoenas under the threat of criminal prosecution in the event of non-compliance, warning that the penalty for defying a congressional subpoena would be far graver under the Biden administration than during the Trump presidency.

But increasingly concerned with the far-reaching nature of the 6 January investigation, Trump and his legal team, led by the ex-Trump campaign lawyer Justin Clark the former deputy White House counsel Patrick Philbin, are moving to instruct the attorneys for the subpoenaed aides to defy the orders.

The basis for Trump’s pressing aides to not cooperate is being mounted on grounds of executive privilege, the source said, over claims that sensitive conversations about what he knew in advance of plans to stop the certification of Joe Biden’s election victory should remain secret.

Philbin appears less convinced than Trump about the strength of the legal argument, the source said, in part because the justice department previously declined to assert the protection for 6 January testimony, suggesting it did not exist to protect Trump’s personal interests.

The former president’s lawyer, the source said, instead seems to view the strategy more as an effective way to slow-walk the select committee, which is aiming to produce a final report before the 2022 midterm elections, to keep the inquiry non-partisan.

It was not clear on Tuesday whether Trump would push aides to defy all elements of the subpoenas, the source cautioned – access to some emails or call records demanded by the select committee might be waived.

But Trump’s strategy mirrors the playbook he used to prevent House Democrats from deposing his top advisers during his presidency. The former White House counsel Don McGahn, for instance, only testified to Congress about the Mueller inquiry once Trump left office.

House select committee investigators had demanded that the four Trump aides turn over emails, call records and other documents related to the Capitol attack by Thursday and then appear before the panel for closed-door depositions next week.

But with the former president expected to insist to Philbin that Meadows, Scavino, Bannon and Patel mount blanket refusals against the subpoenas, the source said, the select committee at present appears likely to see none of the requests fulfilled.

The move means that House select committee investigators now face the key decision over how to enforce the orders – and whether they make a criminal referral to the justice department after the Thursday deadline for documents or next week’s crunch date for testimony.

The House select committee chairman, Bennie Thompson, told reporters recently that he was prepared to pursue criminal referrals to witnesses who defied subpoenas and subpoena deadlines, as the panel escalates the pace of the evidence-gathering part of its investigation.

“We’ll do whatever the law allows us to do,” Thompson said last Friday on the subject of prosecuting recalcitrant witnesses. “For those who don’t agree to come in voluntarily, we’ll do criminal referrals.”

A spokesperson for the select committee declined to comment about how the panel intended to secure compliance.

The legal battle to force some of Trump’s most senior White House aides to comply with the subpoenas – however it is manifested – is likely to lead to constitutional clashes in court that would test the power of Congress’s oversight authority over the executive branch.

But members of the select committee in recent days have expressed quiet optimism at least about the potential prosecution of witnesses who might defy subpoenas, in part because of the Biden administration’s public support for the investigation.

The select committee said in the subpoena letters to Meadows, Bannon, Scavino and Patel that they were key persons of interest over what they knew about the extent of Trump’s involvement in the Capitol attack, which left five dead and more than 140 injured.

Meadows, the former White House chief of staff, remains of special interest to House select committee investigators since he was involved in efforts to subvert the results of the 2020 election and remained by Trump’s side as rioters stormed the Capitol in his name.

He was also in contact with Patel at the defense department, the select committee asserted, and communicated with members of the Women for America First group that planned the “Stop the Steal” rally that deteriorated into the 6 January insurrection.

Scavino, the former White House deputy chief of staff, became a person of interest after it emerged that he met with Trump the day before the Capitol attack to discuss how to persuade members of Congress not to certify the election, according to his subpoena letter.

The select committee said in the subpoena letter to Bannon that they wanted to hear from Trump’s former chief strategist, who was present at the Willard Hotel on 5 January to strategize with Trump campaign officials how to stop the election certification.

Patel, meanwhile, is under scrutiny since he was involved in Pentagon discussions about security at the Capitol before and after the riot. The select committee added they were also examining reports Trump tried to install him as deputy CIA director.


Hugo Lowell in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Why Trump appears deeply unnerved as Capitol attack investigation closes in
Flurry of recent revelations raises the specter that the committee is swiftly heading towards an incriminating conclusion

Hugo Lowell in Washington

20, Dec, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
US Capitol attack committee issues subpoenas to 10 senior Trump officials
Stephen Miller and Kayleigh McEnany among those subpoenaed as committee expands investigation

Hugo Lowell in Washington

10, Nov, 2021 @3:30 AM

Article image
Capitol attack: Trump not immune from criminal referral, lawmakers insist
Kinzinger asks if Trump ‘incompetent or a coward’ during 6 January riot while Raskin ponders 14th amendment to bar new run

Ed Pilkington in New York

09, Jan, 2022 @6:11 PM

Article image
Capitol attack panel will determine if Trump committed crime – Republican
Kinzinger promises to determine if criminal statute violated, saying: ‘He’s not a king. Former presidents, they aren’t former kings’

Richard Luscombe

19, Dec, 2021 @7:13 PM

Article image
Capitol attack panel set to subpoena Trump allies, Republican Kinzinger says
Members of Congress involved in attempt to overturn election have refused to testify voluntarily before June public hearings

Martin Pengelly in New York

01, May, 2022 @5:56 PM

Article image
US Capitol attack: Trump impeachment looms as Republicans ponder his fate
President shapes legal team amid calls to quit from Democrats and own party, as arrests over riot continue

Richard Luscombe in Miami and Martin Pengelly in New York

10, Jan, 2021 @8:23 PM

Article image
House committee on Capitol attack subpoenas Trump’s ex-chief of staff and other top aides
Mark Meadows, Steve Bannon and Dan Scavino among advisers called to testify over president’s connection to 6 January events

Hugo Lowell in Washington DC

23, Sep, 2021 @11:48 PM

Article image
Capitol attack: Schiff says Mark Meadows contempt decision imminent
House panel investigating Trump supporters’ deadly riot but former White House chief of staff has not co-operated

Martin Pengelly in New York

28, Nov, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Trump tore up records turned over to House Capitol attack committee
National Archives says it received ripped-up documents from White House before turning them over to Congress

Martin Pengelly in New York

01, Feb, 2022 @6:57 PM

Article image
Donald Trump impeached a second time over mob attack on US Capitol
Ten Republicans support unprecedented second impeachment as Nancy Pelosi says Trump represents ‘clear and present danger’

Lauren Gambino in Washington

13, Jan, 2021 @10:57 PM