Rage review: Will Bob Woodward's tapes bring down Donald Trump?

The Watergate reporter offers a jaw-dropping portrait of a president he deems ‘the wrong man for the job’. But Trump’s electoral fate is far from clear

In the pages of Rage, Jared Kushner acknowledges that Donald Trump is not wedded to the truth. Rather, both men find exaggeration a potent weapon in stirring opinion. Asked about the president’s propensity to inflate his achievements, Kushner responds: “Controversy elevates message.”

If so, both the president and his son-in-law should be eternally grateful to Bob Woodward, his latest book and the ensuing tumult. By the president’s own tape-recorded admission, he was acutely aware of the dangers posed by Covid-19 but elected to lie about the danger faced by the American public.

The plague did not vanish, more than 190,000 are dead. When Jonathan Karl of ABC News pressed the president at a press conference about his lie, he was on very solid ground. To say otherwise is delusional – or fan fiction. Kayleigh McEnany, the latest White House spokeswoman, knows that for sure.

While the president claims his sole aim was to avoid chaos, the pandemic has fused itself to the social fabric. As the head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has acknowledged, the effort to eradicate Covid-19 is a marathon not a sprint, and it is far from over.

And yet re-election is a real possibility. Florida has shifted, no longer leaning Democratic. A Biden-Harris win in Nevada appears less certain. Trump is down, but not out. Rage arrives at what may be an inflection point, formally published seven weeks before one of the most consequential electoral contests. However you slice it, the US stands polarized, a nation divided.

As expected from Woodward, those in proximity to power share their stories. James Mattis, the former defense secretary, Dan Coats, the former director of national intelligence, and Kushner all make more than cameo appearances. Coats is caught musing that Vladimir Putin must have something over the president.

“How else to explain the president’s behavior?” Woodward writes. “Coats could see no other explanation.”

Rage also catches the discomfort of Coats’ wife. As fate would have it, Trump dismissed Coats after unexpectedly running into the couple at one of his golf courses.

But what sets Rage apart from the Pulitzer-winning author’s earlier works is that Trump consented to be taped, on the record. In other words, the book possesses more than a patina of similarity to the famous televised interviews between David Frost and Richard Nixon, the president Woodward and Carl Bernstein brought down with their reporting on Watergate nearly a half-century ago.

Woodward recalls a famous Nixon quote, from more than 40 years earlier: “I gave them a sword. And they stuck it in. And they twisted it with relish. And, I guess, if I’d been in their position, I’d have done the same thing.”

The response is pure Trump: “Nixon was in a corner with his thumb stuck in his mouth.”

Rage makes clear that Trump’s affinity for dictators and strongmen is part of his DNA. In addition to capturing the bromance with Kim Jong-un of North Korea, Woodward quotes Trump discussing his rapport with Recep Tayyip Erdoğan of Turkey, and others.

“It’s funny the relationships I have,” Trump says. “The tougher and meaner they are, the better I get along with them … Explain that to me someday.” The answer to that may have been evident to the president.

Senator Lindsey Graham also makes numerous appearances. According to Woodward, the South Carolina Republican served as a conduit between Bill Barr, the attorney general, and the White House. But Graham also appears as a friendly critic.

After seeing Trump wave a Bible in front of St John’s church, across from the White House, after peaceful protesters had been cleared with teargas, Graham exclaims that he has “never been more worried”. South Carolina’s senior senator explained that Trump could have responded to the racial unrest fomented by the murder of George Floyd like George Wallace, Nixon or Robert Kennedy.

Wallace was a segregationist governor of Alabama. Nixon fancied himself as the law-and-order candidate. Kennedy was a slain president’s younger brother, who tried to keep the peace after the killing of Martin Luther King and was then killed himself.

Trump opted to emulate Wallace.

Donald Trump holds up a Bible outside St John’s, across Lafayette Square from the White House in June.
Donald Trump holds up a Bible outside St John’s, across Lafayette Square from the White House in June. Photograph: Brendan Smialowski/AFP/Getty Images

As Graham saw things, incumbent presidents lack the luxury of acting as bystanders to events. In Woodward’s account, Trump is portrayed as preferring to claim credit even as he eschews responsibility.

While the coronavirus spread, Trump repeatedly let governors know the burden of shoring up their sick, their doctors and their people would fall on their shoulders first. Woodward emphasizes Trump’s reluctance to throw the weight of the federal government behind fighting Covid-19. It was to be the world’s greatest backstop.

In Graham’s words, Trump “wants to be a wartime president, but he doesn’t want to own any more than he has to own”.

And yet Rage also makes clear that Trump’s desire for accolades knows few bounds. After adopting a partial ban on travel to and from China, as urged by at least five advisers, Trump asserted that he had fathered and birthed the plan on his own.

“I had 21 people in my office,” he said. But only “one person had said we have to close it down. That was me.”

Woodward is puzzled by Trump’s cooperation. Unlike Nixon when Frost came calling, the president was not paid to be a witness against himself.

Rage comes with a definite viewpoint. Woodward contends that a “president must be willing to share the worst with the people, the bad the news with the good”. Instead of “truth-telling”, Woodward writes, Trump has “enshrined personal impulse as a governing principal”.

When Trump’s “performance is taken in its entirety”, he concludes, history will show that he was “the wrong man for the job”.

Perhaps. 3 November comes first.


Lloyd Green

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fear review: Bob Woodward's dragnet descends on Donald Trump
The Watergate reporter has written another sober, must-read dissection of corruption and rot at the White House

Lloyd Green

08, Sep, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Trump aides insist Woodward tapes reveal strong leadership on Covid
President on tape saying he ‘wanted to always play it down’ but Republican chair claims: ‘History will look back on him well’

Richard Luscombe

13, Sep, 2020 @5:13 PM

Article image
The right man for the job: how Bob Woodward pinned Trump to the page
For Rage, the Watergate and Washington Post veteran spoke to the president for hours on record. The result is a book for the ages

David Smith in Washington

20, Sep, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Trump proposed sending migrants to Guantánamo, claims book by anonymous author
Plan to designate migrants as ‘enemy combatants’ provoked astonishment and mortification, says author of A Warning

Ed Pilkington and Martin Pengelly in New York

14, Nov, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
Bob Woodward obtains letters between Trump and Kim Jong-un for new book Rage
Publisher announces details of successor to bestseller Fear, including North Korean leader describing bond out of a ‘fantasy film’

Martin Pengelly

13, Aug, 2020 @1:56 AM

Article image
Peril review: Bob Woodward Trump trilogy ends on note of dire warning
Behind the headlines about Gen Milley, China and the threat of nuclear war lies a sobering read about democracy in danger

Lloyd Green

18, Sep, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Woodward: Trump raged when told Israel-UAE deal wouldn't make book
Author says president’s tweet declaring the book ‘fake’ followed conversation in which he warned: ‘It’s a tough book’

Martin Pengelly in New York

14, Sep, 2020 @12:38 PM

Article image
The Steal review: stethoscope for a democracy close to cardiac arrest
Mark Bowden and Matthew Teague have produced an indispensable account of how the attempt to steal the 2020 election played out in key states

Charles Kaiser

02, Jan, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Top general feared Trump would launch nuclear war, Woodward book reports
General Milley worried about Trump’s ‘trigger point’ after the election and monitored him to prevent catastrophic military strike

Martin Pengelly in New York

14, Sep, 2021 @5:13 PM

Article image
Michael Wolff: Murdoch hates Trump but loves Fox News money more
In book, Wolff says that Murdoch personally approved network’s early call of Arizona, which signalled Trump’s defeat

Martin Pengelly in New York

19, Jul, 2021 @1:40 PM